Ole Edvart Rølvaag didn't just write a book about farming. He wrote a horror story where the monster is the horizon. If you grew up in the Midwest, you probably saw a dusty copy of the Giants in the Earth book on a grandparent's shelf or tucked away in a local library's "Classics" section. It looks unassuming. It looks like a dry, historical account of Norwegian immigrants hitting the dirt in the Dakota Territory.
But it’s actually a brutal psychological thriller about what happens when the human mind meets a landscape that doesn't want it there.
Honestly, it’s a miracle Rølvaag even got this published in the way he did. He wrote it in Norwegian first. Think about that. A "Great American Novel" written by a guy who lived in Minnesota but thought in his mother tongue. It was published in 1924 as I de dage, then translated into English in 1927. People usually categorize it as "pioneer literature" alongside My Ántonia, but Rølvaag’s vibe is way darker. It's visceral.
The story follows Per Hansa and his wife, Beret. They are opposites. Per Hansa is the kind of guy who sees a wasteland and thinks, "I can own this." He’s got that manic, pioneer energy. Beret? She’s the heart of the book. She looks at the flat, treeless prairie and sees a grave. She’s convinced they’ve wandered into a place where God can't find them. And for 400-odd pages, Rølvaag proves her right.
The Psychological Toll of the Dakota Prairie
Most pioneer stories focus on the "conquering" of the land. We love a good "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" narrative. The Giants in the Earth book flips that script. It asks what those bootstraps cost your soul.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Rølvaag was an immigrant himself. He arrived in the U.S. in 1896 and worked as a farmhand before becoming a professor at St. Olaf College. He knew the wind. He knew the way the grass hissed. In the book, the "Giants" aren't literal monsters—they are the forces of nature: the blizzards, the locusts, and the crushing, soul-sucking loneliness.
Why Beret is the real protagonist
A lot of early critics dismissed Beret as "weak" or "insane." That’s a massive misunderstanding of what Rølvaag was doing. Beret represents the cultural and spiritual cost of migration. While Per Hansa is busy breaking the sod, Beret is mourning the loss of civilization. She misses the mountains of Norway. She misses fences. She misses the feeling of being enclosed and safe.
There’s this incredible scene where she hides in a heavy chest because the emptiness of the prairie is literally trying to swallow her. It’s claustrophobia in an open space. Agoraphobia turned into high art.
- Per Hansa’s Vision: He sees a kingdom. He’s obsessed with building the biggest house, the best wheat, the grandest future. He’s the personification of the American Dream, which, as the book suggests, is a form of madness.
- Beret’s Reality: She sees the "Great Plain" as a demon. She interprets their hardships—like the terrifying locust plagues—as divine punishment for their hubris.
The tension between them isn't just a marital spat. It's the friction between the need to progress and the need to belong.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
Fact vs. Fiction: Did Rølvaag Exaggerate?
You might think the locust swarm scenes are just dramatic flair. They aren't. Rølvaag based these on the real-life "Rocky Mountain Locust" invasions of the 1870s. These weren't just bugs. They were a biological carpet that blocked out the sun and ate everything—including the wool off a sheep's back and the handles of wooden pitchforks.
The Giants in the Earth book captures the sheer helplessness of these events. Imagine working for three years to finally get a crop, and in twenty minutes, it’s just... gone. The "Giants" won.
The Winter of 1880-1881
The book culminates in a winter that mirrors the "Hard Winter" many Dakota settlers actually faced. We’re talking about snow so deep people had to tunnel to their barns. Rølvaag’s descriptions of the cold are bone-chilling. He describes the frost as something alive. It creeps into the house. It cracks the walls.
It’s important to remember that these people were living in sod houses. "Soddies." Basically, they lived in dirt. When it rained, the ceiling leaked mud. When it was dry, fleas lived in the walls. Rølvaag doesn't romanticize this. He makes you smell the damp earth and the unwashed wool.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Why Modern Readers Should Care
We live in a world of constant connection. It’s hard to wrap our heads around the kind of isolation Beret felt. But if you look closer, the Giants in the Earth book is actually very modern. It’s about the mental health of displaced people. It’s about the immigrant experience—that weird, painful feeling of being caught between two worlds and belonging to neither.
People still debate the ending. No spoilers here, but it’s one of the most haunting final images in all of literature. It leaves you wondering if Per Hansa’s ambition was worth the price.
The Legacy of the Novel
- It’s part of a trilogy (Peder Victorious and Their Fathers' God follow it), though the first book is the undisputed masterpiece.
- It helped establish the "Midwestern Gothic" genre.
- It’s a staple in Scandinavian-American studies because it captures a specific dialect and cultural mindset that has mostly vanished.
Basically, if you want to understand the DNA of the American West, you can’t just watch Yellowstone. You have to read Rølvaag. He shows the grit without the glamor. He shows the cost of the dirt.
How to Approach Giants in the Earth Today
If you’re picking this up for the first time, don't expect a fast-paced thriller. It moves like the seasons. It’s slow. It builds. But the payoff is a deeper understanding of what it means to be human in a place that doesn't care if you live or die.
Actionable Ways to Experience the History
- Visit the Heritage: If you’re ever in South Dakota, go to the areas around Sioux Falls. You can still see the vastness Rølvaag described. It’s easier to get now, but the wind hasn’t changed.
- Read the Lincoln Colcord Translation: This is the "standard" English version. Colcord worked closely with Rølvaag to make sure the rhythm of the Norwegian stayed intact.
- Compare with Contemporary Accounts: Read diary entries from real pioneer women of the 1870s. You’ll find that Beret’s "madness" was actually a very common response to the environmental trauma of the Great Plains.
- Check out St. Olaf College: They hold a lot of Rølvaag’s papers and original manuscripts. It’s a goldmine for anyone interested in how this book was constructed.
The Giants in the Earth book isn't just a relic of the past. It’s a warning about what happens when we try to conquer nature without respecting it. It’s about the "Giants" that still live in the land—and the ones that live inside us. Read it during a storm. You’ll never look at a flat horizon the same way again.
Rølvaag knew that the land eventually wins. The trick is surviving long enough to see the harvest. He didn't write a happy ending because the prairie doesn't give them out easily. But he did write a true one. And that's why we’re still talking about it a century later.