If you were anywhere near a radio in 2011, you heard Not Over You. It was inescapable. That rhythmic piano thumping, the soul-baring vocal—it was peak Gavin DeGraw. But honestly, looking back at the full Sweeter album over a decade later, that one hit was just the tip of the iceberg.
Sweeter wasn't just another pop record. It was a massive pivot. Before this, Gavin was the guy from One Tree Hill who wrote alone, sitting at a piano with his thoughts. Then he decided to "rattle his cage." He called up Ryan Tedder from OneRepublic and Butch Walker, and everything changed. The result? A record that feels "tough-sexy" (his words, not mine) and way more experimental than the stuff that made him famous.
📖 Related: Why the I’m Kinda a Big Deal GIF Still Dominates Our Group Chats
The Secret Sauce of the Sweeter Tracklist
Most people don't realize that gavin degraw sweeter songs represent the first time he ever co-wrote with other artists. That’s a huge deal for a guy who built his brand on being a "pure" singer-songwriter. You can feel that collaborative energy in the title track, Sweeter. It starts with this jangly, funky guitar riff that feels more like a late-night club in New York than a sensitive ballad. It’s a song about wanting someone else’s girl, and it’s surprisingly blunt. No "fairytale" fluff here.
Then you have the deeper cuts. Radiation is a trip. It’s got this R&B-infused, Prince-esque vibe that sounds absolutely nothing like Chariot. Gavin’s voice drops a few octaves, and it’s basically an ode to that one toxic ex you keep calling after midnight. It’s messy. It’s real.
Why "Not Over You" Was the Perfect Lead
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. Not Over You. Ryan Tedder has a way of finding a hook and drilling it into your skull, but Gavin brought the grit. He told ArtistDirect that the song lives on the line between being vulnerable and being prideful. It’s that feeling of seeing an ex and pretending you’re fine when you’re actually dying inside.
👉 See also: Where to Stream Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants Without Losing Your Mind
The production on this track is what kept it from being just another mopey breakup song. It has a beat. You can move to it. That’s the magic of the Sweeter era—taking heavy emotions and wrapping them in something that feels physically alive.
The Raw and the Polished
The album isn't all radio gloss, though. Some of the most interesting gavin degraw sweeter songs are the ones where he lets the guard down.
- Soldier: This is the big, cinematic anthem. Butch Walker produced this one, and you can tell. It’s got that "wall of sound" feeling. It’s a devotion song, pure and simple.
- Stealing: This is a personal favorite for many hardcore fans. The lyric "I call it stealing, you call it borrow" is probably one of the best lines he’s ever written. It’s pensive, piano-driven, and hits that old-school DeGraw sweet spot.
- Run Every Time: This is Gavin admitting he’s bad at commitment. It’s upbeat pop-rock, but the lyrics are a confession. He’s telling the person he’s with that he’s probably going to bolt.
Breaking the Mold
Critics were actually kind of split on this record. Some, like AllMusic, loved the "greater textures" and the fact that he wasn't just repeating the past. Others, like the folks at Sputnikmusic, were way harsher, calling it "vanilla." But honestly? I think they missed the point. Sweeter was Gavin trying to find a middle ground between being a "legacy" artist and a modern pop star.
He was 34 at the time. He was trying to figure out how to stay relevant without losing his soul. If you listen to Candy, you hear him singing about how "we can't survive on candy"—a literal metaphor for the shallow stuff in life. He was self-aware about the pop machine even while he was jumping into it.
How to Revisit the Sweeter Era
If you haven't listened to the record in a while, don't just shuffle it. Play it front to back. Notice how it moves from the aggressive funk of the opening tracks to the more atmospheric stuff like Where You Are and Spell It Out.
✨ Don't miss: Why Criminal Minds Season 2 Episode 6 "The Boogeyman" Still Haunts Us
- Listen for the production: Try to spot the difference between the Ryan Tedder tracks (poppy, hook-heavy) and the Butch Walker tracks (rockier, more organic).
- Check the lyrics: Look for the moments where he’s being "tough-sexy" versus "vulnerable-messy."
- Watch the live versions: Gavin is a monster on the piano. Most of these songs take on a whole new life when he’s playing them live and riffing on the vocals.
Sweeter didn't just give us a few radio hits; it proved that Gavin DeGraw could evolve. He didn't have to stay the guy from 2003 forever. He could get a little louder, a little funkier, and a lot more honest about the darker sides of romance.
Next time you’re putting together a playlist, throw Radiation or Run Every Time on there. You might find that they’ve aged even better than the singles. Dig into the liner notes of the Sweeter album to see how the collaboration with Eric Rosse and Ron Aniello shaped the different textures of the ballads. Check out the live acoustic sessions from this era on YouTube to hear the raw skeleton of these songs before the big production was added.