So, we finally got to the end of the second season of MGM+’s sci-fi horror nightmare. Honestly, From season 2 episode 10, titled "Once Upon a Time...", did exactly what this show does best. It gave us one massive, reality-shattering answer while simultaneously dumping a truckload of new questions on our doorsteps. If you’re like me, you probably spent the last ten minutes of that finale staring at your screen in total silence, trying to figure out if Tabitha Matthews actually escaped or if she just stepped into a different layer of the same hell.
It’s heavy.
The episode isn't just a season finale; it’s a complete pivot for the series. Up until this point, From felt like a "trapped in a town" story, similar to Wayward Pines or Lost. But the moment Tabitha gets pushed out that lighthouse window by the Boy in White, the rules of the game change. We aren't just looking at a physical cage anymore. We’re looking at a metaphysical one.
The Lighthouse, The Boy in White, and the "Great Escape"
Let’s talk about Tabitha. Her entire arc in From season 2 episode 10 is driven by this desperate, almost manic need to save the children she’s been seeing in her visions. The "Anghkooey" kids. She believes, thanks to Eloise’s drawings and Victor’s repressed memories, that the tower is the key.
She climbs those stairs. She’s terrified.
Then she meets the Boy in White. He says, "I'm sorry, this is the only way," and shoves her. It’s a violent act of mercy. When she wakes up, she’s in a hospital. She looks out the window, and she’s in a city. This is the first time we’ve seen the "real world" since the Matthews family drove their RV past that fallen tree in the series premiere.
But is it the real world?
Fans have been tearing this apart on Reddit and Twitter. The reflection in the glass is a big deal. Some viewers noticed that Tabitha’s reflection looks slightly "off," leading to theories that she’s actually in another simulation or a different level of the town's influence. However, the more grounded theory is that she’s the first person to actually "die" the right way. In many folk-horror traditions, you have to leave a realm through the same way you enter it—or through a leap of faith.
📖 Related: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Boyd and the Music Box: Ending the Nightmare (For Now)
While Tabitha is playing Assassin’s Creed at the lighthouse, Boyd Holbrook is busy dealing with the literal personification of fear. The music box. This thing has been the MVP of Season 2's horror.
The tension in the dungeon scene is suffocating. Boyd sees his late wife, Abby. Now, Abby has been a voice of nihilism since Season 1, telling him that "hope is what feeds the forest." In From season 2 episode 10, she tries to convince him to give up, to let the three prisoners—Marielle, Julie, and Randall—die so their suffering can end.
It’s a classic psychological trap.
Boyd, being the stubborn leader he is, refuses to buy into it. He smashes the music box. The moment the gears stop turning and the porcelain figure shatters, the "Cicada curse" lifts. The screaming stops. The three victims wake up. It feels like a win, but it’s a hollow one. Why? Because the forest is still there. The monsters are still there. Smashing the box saved three lives, but it didn't break the cycle of the town itself.
The Victor Factor: Why His Memories Matter More Than Ever
Victor is the heart of this show. He’s been in the town since he was a child, and his survival isn't just luck; it’s a roadmap. In this episode, he gives Tabitha his lunchbox. It seems like a small, eccentric gesture, but it’s actually a passing of the torch.
Victor’s mother tried to do exactly what Tabitha did. She went to the tower to save the children. She never came back. Victor found her body by the bottle tree.
By helping Tabitha find the "Bottle Tree"—which acts as a portal or a "faraway tree" specifically for the lighthouse—Victor is finally confronting the trauma of his past. He’s admitting that his mother might have been right, even if she failed. This adds a layer of tragic irony to the show. The town feeds on grief, and Victor is a walking reservoir of it.
👉 See also: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
What "Anghkooey" Actually Means
We have to address the creepy kids. "Anghkooey."
People have searched for this word in every language from Gaelic to Norse. Some think it’s a corruption of "Ankou," a figure in Breton mythology who represents death and collects souls. In From season 2 episode 10, the kids aren't just background dressing; they are the catalyst for the finale’s climax.
They seem to be tethered to the tower. If Tabitha is in the real world now, her mission likely involves finding out who those children were before they ended up in the town’s basement. Were they previous residents from the 1800s? The 1950s? The dates on the lighthouse wall suggest this has been happening for centuries.
The Logistics of the "Level Up" Theory
There’s a segment of the fan base that believes the town is a series of concentric circles. Think of it like Dante’s Inferno.
- The Town (Where the monsters live).
- The Forest (The deeper supernatural layer).
- The Lighthouse (The exit or transition point).
- The Hospital (The "New" Layer).
If Tabitha is just in another layer, then the stakes for Season 3 are astronomical. It would mean that "dying" in the town doesn't send you home; it just moves you to a different ward of the asylum. However, the presence of a doctor and a regular city outside her window suggests that she has genuinely punctured the veil.
The problem? No one will believe her.
Imagine showing up in a hospital, covered in scratches, claiming you’ve been trapped in a magical town with skin-eating monsters for weeks. She’s going to be committed to a psychiatric ward faster than you can say "talisman." This creates a fascinating new dynamic where the horror moves from "monsters in the dark" to "gaslighting in the light."
✨ Don't miss: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Real-World Comparisons: Why This Writing Works
The reason From season 2 episode 10 resonates so much is that it mirrors the "Mystery Box" style of storytelling pioneered by J.J. Abrams, but with much tighter stakes. Unlike Lost, which often felt like it was making things up as it went, From feels like it has a physical internal logic.
Every object matters. The lunchbox. The bottle tree. The drawings.
The writers are using a technique called "Information Layering." They give you enough to satisfy your immediate hunger (stopping the cicadas) while starving you of the main course (what is the town?). It’s a cruel way to treat an audience, but man, it’s effective.
Practical Steps for Fans Re-watching the Finale
If you’re going back to watch the episode again to find clues for the next season, keep your eyes on these specific things:
- The Dates in the Lighthouse: Look at the years carved into the stone. They align with the dates Tabitha saw on the stones in her visions. These aren't random; they represent "reset" events in the town’s history.
- The Hospital Window: Look closely at the reflection. There is a debate about whether the "Boy in White" can be seen for a split second.
- Jade’s Underground Adventure: Don't forget that while Tabitha was at the tower, Jade was in the tunnels seeing the "seven" children on the stone slabs. This confirms the ritualistic nature of the town. Jade is seeing the past, while Tabitha is trying to change the future.
The biggest takeaway from the finale is that the town isn't just a place where people die. It’s a place where people are processed. Whether they are being harvested for fear, grief, or something more ancient remains the show's biggest hook.
For now, the best thing to do is pay attention to the symbols. The crows, the cicadas, and the carvings aren't just set dressing. They are the language the town speaks. Tabitha just learned the first word.
Next Steps for the Viewer
To fully grasp the implications of the finale, you should map out the timeline of Victor's childhood. Compare the clothes the "Anghkooey" children are wearing to the different eras represented by the dates in the lighthouse. This often reveals which "cycle" of the town we are currently witnessing. Additionally, re-watch the opening credits; the drawings there change slightly and often foreshadow the exact fate of characters several episodes before they happen on screen. Focus on the drawing of the tower—it’s been there since Season 1, hiding the exit in plain sight.