If you’ve spent any time on BookTok or Bookstagram in the last few years, you’ve seen the gold-leafed cover. You know the one. Jennifer L. Armentrout basically set the publishing world on fire when she dropped From Blood and Ash back in 2020. It wasn't just a book launch; it was a shift in the "Romantasy" genre that we're still feeling today. People either worship at the altar of Poppy and Casteel or they have a thirty-minute rant ready to go about the pacing of the later sequels. Honestly, there is very little middle ground here.
The story starts with Penellaphe—or Poppy—who is the Maiden. She's "Chosen," which in fantasy-speak usually means her life sucks. She can't be touched, can't be seen, and can't talk to anyone except a very small circle of people. It’s isolating. It’s lonely. Then enters Casteel Da’Neer. Or Hawke, if you’re sticking to the early-book vibes. He’s the royal guard who isn't really a guard, and suddenly the "Maiden" isn't so interested in being a silent icon for a kingdom she doesn't even understand.
The World-Building That Actually Makes You Think
Let’s be real. Most people pick up From Blood and Ash for the romance, but the lore is surprisingly dense. Maybe too dense for some. You have the Ascended, who are basically these vampire-adjacent aristocrats who rule the Kingdom of Solis. Then you have the Atlantians, the "enemy" who were supposedly wiped out or driven back long ago.
Armentrout does this thing where she flips the script. In the beginning, you think the Ascended are the holy, blessed leaders. By the middle of the first book, you realize they are effectively parasites. They take the "Thirds"—the third-born children of commoners—and use them for... well, it’s not for a Sunday brunch. It’s dark. It’s gritty. It’s actually pretty horrifying when you look past the tension between the leads.
Poppy isn't your standard "damsel" either. She has a dagger and she knows how to use it. She’s been trained in secret, which is a trope we see a lot, but it feels earned here because her life literally depends on it. She’s curious. She asks too many questions. That’s her best and worst trait.
📖 Related: Kate Phillips Movies and TV Shows: Why She Is the Secret Queen of Period Drama
Why the Romance Works (And Why It Frustrates)
Casteel Da’Neer is the blueprint for a specific kind of modern fantasy hero. He’s sarcastic. He’s incredibly lethal. He’s obsessed with Poppy’s agency because she’s never had any. Their dynamic is built on a foundation of "I should probably kill you," which is the bread and butter of the enemies-to-lovers trope.
The chemistry? It's intense. Armentrout doesn't shy away from the "spice" factor, which helped the book explode during the 2020 lockdowns when everyone was looking for an escape. But here is the thing. As the series progresses into A Kingdom of Flesh and Fire and The Crown of Gilded Bones, the romance shifts from "will-they-won't-they" to "we are a power couple against the world."
Some fans love the stability. Others miss the tension.
There’s also the "Joining" to consider. If you know, you know. This is probably the single most controversial plot point in the entire series. It’s a rite that links characters together, and it’s been the subject of thousand-word Reddit threads and screaming matches on Twitter. It changed the dynamic of the core relationship in a way that some readers felt betrayed the initial "it’s always been you" vibe of the first two books.
The Pacing Problem and the Expansion of the Universe
We have to talk about the length. These books are massive. They’re chunky. Most of them clock in over 600 pages.
Critics often point out that From Blood and Ash suffers from what people call "inner monologue bloat." Poppy spends a lot of time in her own head. Like, a lot. Sometimes she’ll ask the same three questions for four chapters straight. If you love her voice, it feels like hanging out with a friend. If you’re here for the plot, you might find yourself skimming.
🔗 Read more: How the Legend of Fat Puss in Boots Actually Saved the Shrek Franchise
Then there’s the prequel series, Flesh and Fire.
Interestingly, a huge portion of the fanbase actually prefers the prequel. A Shadow in the Ember introduces Sera and Nyktos, and many argue it’s a tighter, more cohesive story than the main line. It deals with the Primal of Death and the origins of the entire world. If you’re struggling with the later books in the main series, the prequels are usually where people find their spark again.
A Quick Reality Check on the Reading Order
If you're jumping in now, don't just read 1, 2, 3, 4. You’ll get confused. The lore in the main series starts to lean heavily on the "Primal" history established in the prequels.
- Start with From Blood and Ash.
- Move to A Kingdom of Flesh and Fire.
- Hit The Crown of Gilded Bones.
- Wait. This is where most people suggest switching to the first prequel book before going back to the main series.
It’s a bit of a project. But for fans of the "Chosen One" narrative flipped on its head, it’s worth the effort.
The Impact on the Genre
Before this series, "New Adult" was a bit of a wasteland. It was either YA (Young Adult) with no spice, or straight-up Adult Fantasy with very little focus on the romantic emotional beats. From Blood and Ash bridged that gap. It proved there was a massive market for high-stakes fantasy worlds that prioritized the internal emotional lives (and physical desires) of the characters.
It’s not high literature. It doesn't pretend to be. It’s addictive, soap-opera-style fantasy with high body counts and higher emotional stakes.
The series also faced some backlash regarding its editing. As the books got more popular, the turnaround time for releases got shorter. This led to some "wait, didn't they just say that?" moments. Fans have been vocal about wanting more rigorous editing to match the scale of the world JLA has built. It’s a fair critique. When a world becomes this big, the cracks in the foundation show up more easily.
What’s Next for the Series?
The story isn't over. We’re still waiting for the final resolution of the war against Isbeth and the ultimate fate of the kingdoms. The stakes have moved from "will Poppy find a boyfriend?" to "will the entire world be devoured by ancient gods?"
The scope has shifted significantly. We’ve gone from a small-scale story about a girl in a veil to a cosmic battle involving Primals, deities, and the literal fabric of life and death. It's ambitious. Sometimes it overreaches, but you can't deny the sheer imagination involved in the "Wolven" lore or the way the Draken function in this universe.
📖 Related: Why Everyone Still Wants a Big Trouble in Little China Tank Top Three Decades Later
Practical Tips for New Readers
If you're just starting, keep a few things in mind. First, Poppy is an unreliable narrator for the first half of the first book. Everything she thinks she knows about the world is a lie told to her by people who want to use her. If something feels "off" about the politics, that’s because it is.
Second, pay attention to the names. Armentrout loves to drop names of gods and historical figures that seem like flavor text but end up being major players three books later.
Third, take breaks. Binging these 600-page monsters back-to-back can lead to "Poppy-fatigue."
Actionable Next Steps
If you are looking to dive into the world or just caught up, here is how to handle the "Blood and Ash" experience:
- Follow the Hybrid Reading Order: Do not ignore the Flesh and Fire prequel series. Read A Shadow in the Ember after the third main book. It provides the necessary context for the "Primals" that dominate the later plotlines of the main series.
- Engage with the Community (With Caution): The FBAA fandom is huge. Sites like Goodreads or the "Blood and Ash Series" Facebook groups are great for clarifying confusing lore, but they are spoiler minefields.
- Track the Lore: If you find the lineage of the gods confusing—and you will—keep a small note on your phone or a bookmark. The difference between an "Ascended," an "Atlantian," and a "Primal" is the key to understanding the political conflict.
- Manage Expectations: The first book is a romantic mystery. The later books are epic high fantasy. The tone shifts significantly, so be prepared for a story that grows much larger than the "Maiden in the castle" premise it started with.
The series remains a cornerstone of modern fantasy for a reason. It’s messy, it’s emotional, and it’s unapologetically bold. Whether you love the "Heartmate" trope or you're just here for the dragon-like Draken, there’s no denying that Poppy’s journey from a silent girl behind a veil to a literal queen of gods is one of the most successful runs in recent publishing history.