Honestly, if you were anywhere near a bookstore in the early 2010s, you couldn't escape the faction symbols. Dauntless, Abnegation, Erudite—it was everywhere. But while Tris Prior was the face of the revolution, there’s always been this lingering obsession with Tobias Eaton. That’s exactly why Four: A Divergent Story Collection exists. It wasn’t just a cash grab; it was a necessary deep dive into the head of a character who spent most of the main trilogy being an impenetrable wall of muscle and trauma.
Tobias is complicated.
Most YA love interests from that era were either shimmering vampires or brooding hunters with no discernible personality traits beyond "protectiveness." Veronica Roth did something different with Four. She gave us a guy who was genuinely terrified. Not of monsters, but of becoming his father. Four: A Divergent Story Collection takes us back to the beginning, before Tris ever jumped off a moving train, and shows us exactly how a boy named Tobias became a legend named Four. It’s gritty. It’s occasionally heartbreaking. And it explains a whole lot about why he acted so weirdly in the first book.
The Transfer, The Initiate, and The Son
Most people forget that this collection isn't a single narrative. It’s a series of vignettes. We start with "The Transfer," which is basically the origin story of Tobias leaving Abnegation. If you thought the "stiff" lifestyle was just about wearing gray and being boring, this story corrects that real fast. It paints a vivid, claustrophobic picture of Marcus Eaton’s abuse. You feel the weight of every belt slap and every cold silence.
Then you've got "The Initiate." This is where we see the transition. He’s not Four yet. He’s just a transfer who’s way too good at everything and far too quiet for his own good. This section is vital because it introduces his rivalry with Eric. We finally understand that Eric isn't just a "bad guy" because the plot needs one; he and Tobias represent two completely different ways of being Dauntless. One is about bravery; the other is about cruelty.
"The Son" is where things get messy with the factionless. We see Tobias discovering that his mother, Evelyn, is still alive. It changes the stakes. Suddenly, he's not just a guy trying to survive initiation; he's a pawn in a much larger political game that he doesn't even want to play. Roth manages to make these moments feel earned, even though we already know where they lead.
🔗 Read more: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
Why the Perspective Shift Matters for the Divergent Series
Reading Four: A Divergent Story Collection changes how you view the original trilogy. Period. When you go back to Divergent after reading this, his interactions with Tris feel weighted with all this subtext you didn't have before. You realize he wasn't just being a "tough instructor" for the sake of it. He was trying to keep her alive in a system he already knew was rigged.
Breaking the "Strong Male Lead" Trope
Tobias is vulnerable. That’s his whole thing. In "The Traitor," which is the fourth story in the collection, we see his internal monologue during the events of the first book. It’s fascinating. He’s second-guessing everything. He’s worried he’s failing. He’s falling for Tris but also terrified of what that means for his cover.
- He has four fears. (Hence the name).
- He hates his father but fears he is like him.
- He values the factionless but fears their chaos.
- He loves Tris but fears her impulsivity.
The prose in these stories is sharp. It’s punchy. Roth doesn't waste time on flowery descriptions of the ruined Chicago skyline. She focuses on the internal grit. The sweat. The sound of a heart racing in a fear landscape. It feels more "adult" than the primary trilogy, likely because Tobias is a slightly more cynical narrator than Tris ever was. He’s seen the rot in the system for years. He’s not discovering it; he’s been living in it.
The Secret Scenes You Probably Missed
The back half of the book usually contains these little "exclusive" scenes from the main books, but told from Tobias’s point of view. The "First Jump" scene is a standout. Watching Tris jump through his eyes—seeing this tiny, gray-clad girl plummet into the net—is a total shift in energy. To Tris, it was a moment of terrifying liberation. To Tobias, it was the moment his world started to tilt on its axis.
He didn't think she was a hero at first. He thought she was a suicide case. That nuance is what makes Four: A Divergent Story Collection actually worth the shelf space. It deconstructs the "love at first sight" trope and replaces it with "confusion at first sight," which feels way more realistic for two traumatized teenagers in a dystopian hellscape.
💡 You might also like: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Addressing the Critics: Is It Just "More of the Same"?
Some critics argued that this collection was redundant. They said we didn't need to know his backstory to appreciate the main plot. They’re wrong.
Understanding the "why" behind the "what" is the core of good storytelling. Without this book, Tobias is just a secondary character who happens to be the love interest. With it, he becomes the co-protagonist of the entire saga. You see the parallels between his struggle to leave Abnegation and Tris’s struggle to fit into Dauntless. They are two sides of the same coin, both trying to escape the boxes society (and their parents) built for them.
The pacing is also significantly better than Allegiant. Let’s be real: the third book in the trilogy had some pacing issues. It got bogged down in the "Bureau of Genetic Welfare" stuff and lost its heart. This collection returns to the street-level stakes that made the first book a global phenomenon. It’s about the Dauntless compound. It’s about the pits, the chasm, and the cold reality of faction life. It’s visceral.
What Most People Get Wrong About Tobias Eaton
A lot of readers think Tobias is "perfect." They see him as the ultimate protector. But Four: A Divergent Story Collection shows he's actually kind of a mess. He makes bad calls. He trusts the wrong people. He’s frequently motivated by spite rather than altruism.
Take his relationship with his mother. In the main books, it feels like a power struggle. In this collection, you see the abandonment. You see a kid who was left alone with a monster and then found out his "dead" mom was just hiding. That kind of trauma doesn't just go away because you moved to a different faction and learned how to throw a knife. It informs every cynical comment he makes.
📖 Related: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
How to Approach the Reading Order
If you're new to the series, don't start here. You need the mystery of the first book to make the revelations in this collection feel earned. However, if you've already finished Divergent, this is the perfect palate cleanser before you head into the heavier themes of Insurgent and Allegiant.
- Read Divergent first.
- Dive into Four: A Divergent Story Collection to get the backstory.
- Finish the trilogy.
This order keeps the tension high. You'll understand the politics of the Dauntless leaders—Max and Eric—much better if you've seen them through Tobias’s eyes early on. It turns them from cartoon villains into genuine threats who have been breathing down his neck for years.
The Lasting Legacy of the Divergent World
Look, the dystopian craze of the 2010s eventually cooled off. We moved on to other tropes. But the reason people still talk about Four: A Divergent Story Collection in 2026 is that it deals with something universal: the fear of being defined by your past.
Tobias wants to be more than his father’s son. He wants to be more than a "divergent" anomaly. He wants to be a person. That’s a human story, not just a sci-fi one. The collection holds up because it’s character-driven. It doesn't rely on world-ending stakes; it relies on the internal stakes of a young man trying to find a spine in a world that wants to break it.
Actionable Insights for Fans and New Readers
If you're planning to revisit the series or pick it up for the first time, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:
- Pay attention to the fear landscapes. They aren't just cool action sequences; they are literal psychological maps of the characters. Notice how Tobias's fears change (or don't) throughout the stories.
- Watch the background characters. Names that seem like "extras" in the first book often show up here with their own agendas. It makes the world feel inhabited.
- Focus on the faction philosophy. Instead of just seeing the "cool" parts of Dauntless, look at how the ideology is manipulated by the leaders. It's a masterclass in how societies can go sideways.
- Compare the voices. Read a chapter of Tris's POV and then a chapter of Tobias's. Notice how Roth changes the sentence structure and vocabulary to reflect their different upbringings.
The Divergent world is more than just a girl jumping off a building. It's a study of choice. And through the eyes of Four, we see that sometimes the hardest choice isn't leaving home—it's deciding who you're going to be once you're gone.