You're sitting in a circle. Maybe it’s a stiff corporate retreat in a windowless Marriott conference room, or perhaps it’s just a housewarming party where you only know the host. Then someone says it. The dreaded icebreaker: "Let’s play Two Truths and a Lie." Suddenly, your mind goes blank. You’ve lived for decades, yet you can’t remember a single interesting thing you’ve ever done, and you certainly can’t think of a convincing lie. Most people panic and blurt out something like "I have a third toe," which, honestly, nobody wants to verify anyway.
The secret to winning—or at least not being the boring one—is understanding that good lies for two truths and a lie aren't actually about being a great liar. They’re about understanding human psychology and how we perceive "normal" lives.
The Psychology of the Believable Lie
Why do we fail at this game? Usually, it’s because we try too hard. We think a lie needs to be flashy. In reality, the most effective lies are the ones that are slightly mundane but specific. If you say, "I once met Tom Cruise at a grocery store," people are immediately on high alert. That’s a "movie" lie. But if you say, "I once waited in line behind a C-list reality star at a CVS in Burbank," it feels grounded. It has texture. It feels like the kind of boring reality we all inhabit.
Psychologists often talk about "truth bias." This is the tendency of humans to believe what they are told by default unless they have a reason not to. When you play this game, you are intentionally breaking that social contract. To win, you have to lean into the "Expected Average." Most people's lives follow a predictable bell curve of experiences. If your truths are outliers—maybe you actually did climb Kilimanjaro—your lie needs to be positioned right in the middle of the bell curve to act as a decoy.
Strategies for Crafting Good Lies for Two Truths and a Lie
Let’s get tactical. You need a lie that doesn't just sound true; it needs to sound like the most true thing out of the three options.
📖 Related: Double Sided Ribbon Satin: Why the Pro Crafters Always Reach for the Good Stuff
The "Close Call" Technique
This is a favorite among people who hate lying. Take something that almost happened to you and change the ending. Did you make it to the final round of an interview for a famous tech company but didn't get the job? Your lie is that you worked there for three months as an intern. Because you actually know the building layout and the interview process, your body language will remain relaxed when people ask follow-up questions. You aren't inventing a world; you're just slightly tilting the one you already know.
The "Boring Detail" Strategy
Lies usually fail because they are too "cool." If you tell a group of friends, "I have a pilot's license," and you don't even own a car, they’re going to smell the BS. Instead, try something mildly inconvenient. "I am allergic to kiwi" is a fantastic lie. It’s specific. It’s weirdly random. It’s also incredibly hard to disprove without a medical kit.
The Reverse Pivot
Sometimes the best way to hide a lie is to make your truths sound like lies. If you have a genuinely insane true story—like the time you accidentally ended up on stage with a band—tell it with very little emotion. Then, tell your lie with a bit more "struggle" to remember the details. Humans often associate "searching for a memory" with truth-telling, so if you perform that search while telling the lie, you'll trick the group's internal lie detectors.
Real-World Examples vs. Common Mistakes
Most people go for the "I’ve never broken a bone" or "I’ve never traveled outside the country" tropes. Those are fine for middle school, but for adults, they’re transparent. They are the default settings of the game.
👉 See also: Dining room layout ideas that actually work for real life
What to Avoid:
- The Celebrity Lie: Unless you actually live in LA or NYC, saying you met a superstar is a neon sign for a lie.
- The "Gross Out" Factor: "I ate a bug once." Nobody cares, and it’s usually true anyway because everyone has accidentally swallowed a gnat.
- The Negative Lie: "I don't like chocolate." It’s a boring lie that leads to a boring conversation.
Instead, look for things that highlight a personality trait people think you have. If people think you’re a bit of a nerd, a good lie might be that you once won a regional chess tournament. If you’re known for being outdoorsy, say you’ve never been camping in your life. Use their existing bias against them.
Handling the Interrogation
In many versions of the game, the group gets to ask one or two questions. This is where most people crumble. If your lie is "I lived in Japan for six months," and someone asks, "What was the name of the neighborhood?" you’re cooked if you haven't done your homework.
When you’re picking good lies for two truths and a lie, always pick a subject you actually know something about. If you’re a coffee snob, make your lie about coffee. If you know everything about 90s hip-hop, make your lie about a concert you "attended." You’ll be able to improvise the small talk because the "vibe" of the lie is supported by your actual expertise.
✨ Don't miss: Different Kinds of Dreads: What Your Stylist Probably Won't Tell You
Why This Game Even Matters
It’s not just about winning a plastic trophy or getting a "cool" reputation in the office. This game is a micro-study in storytelling and personal branding. How do you want people to see you? The truths you choose tell people what you value about your history. The lie you choose tells people what you think is plausible for someone like you.
Research into social dynamics suggests that these small moments of vulnerability—even when one is a falsehood—help build "familiarity markers." We feel closer to people when we know their "secrets," even if we have to guess which ones are fake. It’s a low-stakes way to build rapport in a high-friction world.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Game
Don't wait until you're in the hot seat. Prepare a "bank" of options so you aren't sweating when the spotlight hits you.
- Audit your "weird" truths. Write down three things you’ve done that people don’t believe. These are your anchors. Maybe you were an extra in a movie, or you can speak a dead language, or you have a massive collection of vintage stamps.
- Create a "mirror" lie for each. If your truth is that you have a stamp collection, your lie should be about another "nerdy" hobby, like being a competitive bridge player.
- Test the "specifics." If your lie is "I can't whistle," try to whistle. If you can, make sure you can "fake" a bad whistle convincingly.
- Watch the eyes. When you deliver your three statements, look people in the eye for the first truth, look away for the second (the lie), and look back for the third. Or better yet, look away for all of them. Consistency is what masks the deception.
The next time you're asked for good lies for two truths and a lie, remember: the most believable lies are just truths that haven't happened to you yet. Keep it simple, keep it grounded, and for heaven's sake, don't say you have a third toe.
Check your local social groups or office Slack channels to see if anyone is planning a "get to know you" session. Practice your delivery in the mirror if you're truly dedicated. Most importantly, use the follow-up questions to learn more about your friends' real lives—that's where the actual value of the game lies anyway.