You walk in and the smell hits you. It isn’t that clinical, new-car scent of a corporate chain. It’s old paper. It’s dust. It’s the faint, lingering aroma of vinyl sleeves that have sat in basements for forty years. Fenwick Street Used Books & Music doesn’t feel like a store. Not really. It feels like a living room where the owner just happened to leave five thousand books and a couple thousand records laying around for you to browse.
Located right in the heart of Leonardtown, Maryland, this place is a bit of an anomaly. In an era where most people just tap a screen to get a digital file, this shop thrives on the physical. People come here to touch things. They come to flip through bins. They come because they want to find something they didn't know they were looking for.
The Chaos is the Point
If you’re looking for a perfectly sanitized, alphabetized-to-the-millimeter experience, you might get a little overwhelmed at first. But honestly, that’s the charm. Fenwick Street Used Books & Music is packed. The shelves are tall. The aisles are narrow. You have to turn your shoulders sometimes to let someone pass.
It’s tactile.
You’ll find a first-edition hardcover of a 1970s thriller sitting right next to a pristine copy of a modern bestseller. The music section is just as eclectic. One minute you’re looking at a beat-up copy of Rumours—because everyone needs a copy of Rumours—and the next, you’re staring at a rare jazz pressing from a label that went bust in 1964. There is a sense of discovery here that an algorithm simply cannot replicate. An algorithm shows you what you already like. This shop shows you what you might love if you just gave it a chance.
Why Small Towns Need Shops Like This
Leonardtown has changed a lot over the last decade. It’s gotten shinier. There are more boutiques, more upscale dining, and more "curated" experiences. Amidst all that polish, Fenwick Street Used Books & Music remains remarkably authentic. It’s a grounded space.
Local bookstores are often the "third place"—that spot that isn't home and isn't work, where you can just be. You see people here who have been coming for years. They know the staff. They know which corner holds the weird sci-fi paperbacks with the psychedelic covers. It’s a community hub disguised as a retail business.
📖 Related: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
There’s a specific kind of magic in the "Used" part of the name. Every book in there has a history. Maybe there’s a grocery list used as a bookmark from 1992 left inside. Maybe there’s a birthday inscription on the inside cover from a grandmother to a grandson. When you buy a book here, you’re joining a chain of ownership. You aren't just the consumer; you’re the next caretaker.
The Vinyl Resurgence is Real Here
Let’s talk about the music. For a long time, used CD bins were the graveyard of the music industry. Not anymore. At Fenwick Street Used Books & Music, the vinyl section is a major draw. It isn't just for hipsters or "audiophiles" who spend $5,000 on speaker wire. It’s for kids discovering Led Zeppelin for the first time and older folks trying to replace the collections they foolishly sold at yard sales in the 90s.
The prices are fair. That’s a big deal. In some city shops, you’ll see "vintage" records marked up to astronomical prices just because of the cover art. Here, it feels like the pricing is done by people who actually want you to listen to the music, not just frame the jacket.
- Check the "New Arrivals" bin first. Always.
- Don't be afraid to look at the bottom shelves. That’s where the weird stuff hides.
- Bring in your own stuff to trade, but be realistic about condition. Nobody wants your scratched-to-death Polka records.
Dealing with the "Death of Print" Myth
We’ve been hearing that physical media is dead for twenty years. E-readers were supposed to kill books. Streaming was supposed to kill records. And yet, places like Fenwick Street Used Books & Music are still standing. Why?
Because screens are exhausting.
Spending eight hours a day staring at a monitor for work makes you crave something that doesn't have a backlight. There is a psychological weight to a physical book. You can see your progress as you move the bookmark. You can feel the texture of the paper. It’s an analog escape from a digital world.
👉 See also: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
The shop also serves as a filter. In a world of infinite choice, choice becomes a burden. When you walk into a store with a finite number of books, the decision-making process becomes easier. You aren't choosing from every book ever written; you're choosing from what’s on the shelf today. That limitation is actually a relief.
What to Expect on Your First Visit
If you’re heading down to Leonardtown, park near the square and just walk. The shop is easy to find, but don't rush in. Take a second to look at the window displays. They usually tell you a lot about what the staff is into that week.
Once you’re inside, give yourself at least forty-five minutes. This isn't a "grab and go" type of place. You need time for your eyes to adjust to the sheer volume of titles.
- The Staff: They actually read. It sounds like a joke, but in big box stores, the employees are often just shelf-stockers. Here, if you ask for a recommendation in a specific genre, you’re going to get a real answer, not just a pointer toward the bestseller wall.
- The Pricing: Most items are a fraction of the original retail price. It’s the most affordable way to build a library or a record collection.
- The Vibe: Quiet, but not library-quiet. There’s usually music playing (obviously) and the low hum of conversation.
Supporting the Local Economy
When you spend twenty dollars at a giant online retailer, that money vanishes into a corporate vacuum. When you spend it at Fenwick Street Used Books & Music, it stays in St. Mary’s County. It pays the rent for a local building. It supports the people living in your neighborhood.
Beyond the economics, there’s the cultural value. A town with a bookstore is a town with an intellectual heartbeat. It shows that the community values ideas, history, and art. Leonardtown would be a much duller place without this corner of chaos and ink.
How to Get the Most Out of Your Visit
To truly appreciate what’s happening at Fenwick Street, you have to change your mindset. Don't go in with a strict shopping list. If you absolutely must have one specific obscure book, you might be disappointed. But if you go in with an open mind, you’ll leave with three things you never knew existed.
✨ Don't miss: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Check the local events calendar too. Leonardtown has "First Fridays" and other town-wide events where the shop stays open later or has special energy. It’s the best time to visit if you want to feel the pulse of the town, though it can get crowded.
Practical Steps for the Savvy Collector
If you're serious about building a collection through this shop, consistency is your best friend. The inventory changes daily. People are constantly dropping off boxes of trades. What wasn't there on Tuesday might be sitting on the "just processed" cart on Friday.
- Visit often, but briefly. Pop in for ten minutes once a week rather than two hours once a month.
- Talk to the owners. If you have a specific niche—say, 1950s pulp sci-fi or local Maryland history—let them know. They have a mental map of the inventory that no computer can match.
- Check the condition. Remember, these are used goods. Check for missing pages or deep scratches on vinyl. The shop does a great job of vetting, but it’s always good to be an informed buyer.
Fenwick Street Used Books & Music represents a refusal to let everything become a digital commodity. It’s a messy, wonderful, crowded testament to the fact that we still love stuff. We love the weight of a book. We love the crackle of a record. We love the feeling of finding a treasure in a pile of ordinary things.
Next time you’re in Southern Maryland, skip the big box stores. Go to Fenwick Street. Bring a tote bag. You’re going to need it.
Actionable Insights for Your Visit
To make your trip to Leonardtown productive, start by clearing some space on your shelves at home. Bring a box of books or records you no longer want and ask about their trade-in policy; it's the best way to keep your hobby sustainable. Plan your visit for a weekday morning if you want the quietest experience, or aim for a weekend afternoon if you enjoy the hustle of a busy small-town atmosphere. Afterward, grab a coffee at one of the nearby cafes on the square—there is no better pairing for a newly purchased used book. Don't forget to follow their social media or check their window signs for updates on new large collections they've recently acquired, as these "estate buys" are usually where the real gems are hidden.