It is a weird feeling. You open up Persona 3 Reload, the lighting is gorgeous, the music hits those nostalgic lo-fi notes, and the combat feels smoother than it ever did on the PS2. But for a specific, very vocal part of the fanbase, something is missing. Actually, someone is missing. Kotone Shiomi. The female protagonist. The FeMC.
She isn't there.
If you’ve spent any time on Reddit or ResetEra since the game was announced, you know this isn't just a minor gripe. It’s a whole thing. Fans have been modding her in, writing manifestos about her exclusion, and dissecting every interview with ATLUS producer Ryota Niitsuma to find out why the "definitive" version of this classic RPG left out half of its legacy. Honestly, it’s a bit of a mess.
The FeMC Persona 3 Reload Erasure: Why It Hurts So Much
When ATLUS released Persona 3 Portable (P3P) back in 2009 for the PSP, they weren't just porting a game. They were reimagining it. Because the handheld couldn't handle the full 3D environments of the original, they added a female protagonist option to make the package feel fresh. But she wasn't just a skin swap.
Kotone brought a totally different vibe.
Where the original male protagonist (Makoto Yuki) is famously "blue"—detached, nihilistic, and quiet—the FeMC was "pink." She was bubbly, outwardly cheerful, and high-energy. It changed the entire context of the story. If a depressed kid says life is fleeting, you expect it. When a girl who is constantly smiling and making friends says it? That hits different. It's a tragic irony that resonated with a lot of people.
Then FeMC Persona 3 Reload became a topic of debate because the remake chose to stick strictly to the "Journey" from the original PS2 release. No FES "Answer" at launch (though that came later as DLC), and definitely no female route.
It feels like a step back for many.
Think about the Social Links. In the male route, you can’t even hang out with your male teammates like Junpei, Akihiko, or Ken in a meaningful way outside of "Linked Episodes." In the FeMC route from Portable, they were full-blown Social Links. You could actually befriend the guys. You could even save Shinjiro Aragaki from his scripted fate, a move that still divides the community to this day because it arguably messes with the game's core theme of "memento mori."
📖 Related: Steal a Brainrot: How to Get the Secret Brainrot and Why You Keep Missing It
But that's the point. She offered a different perspective on death and bonds. By removing her, Reload feels, to some, like it's missing a limb.
Technical Debt or Design Choice?
ATLUS has been pretty upfront about the workload. Remaking a game of this scale in Unreal Engine 4 isn't just about changing a character model. If they included FeMC Persona 3 Reload content, they would essentially have to rewrite half the script.
Every NPC interaction would need a second pass.
New voice acting.
New UI elements.
A whole new soundtrack.
Remember, Shoji Meguro composed specific tracks for her route, like "Wiping All Out," which sounds nothing like the male protagonist’s "Mass Destruction." You can't just slap a pink coat of paint on Makoto’s story and call it a day. It’s an "all or nothing" situation. ATLUS chose "nothing," focusing instead on making the core experience as polished as humanly possible.
They succeeded there. The game looks incredible. But the shadow of the PSP version hangs heavy over it.
The Modding Scene is Doing God's Work
Since the developers didn't do it, the fans started. Within weeks of the Reload release, the "FeMC Reloaded" project took off. It’s one of the most ambitious modding undertakings in modern JRPGs. They aren't just swapping the model; they are trying to fix the UI, the text prompts, and even the music.
It’s a testament to how much people love Kotone.
Usually, when a remake comes out, the old version dies. Not here. Persona 3 Portable is still selling on Steam and modern consoles specifically because it’s the only place to play as the girl. It creates this weird fragmented reality where you have to choose between "the best looking version" and "the version with the character I actually like."
👉 See also: S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 Unhealthy Competition: Why the Zone's Biggest Threat Isn't a Mutant
What Most People Get Wrong About the Exclusion
There is a common misconception that ATLUS "hates" the female protagonist. That’s probably not true. She’s appeared in Persona Q2: New Cinema Labyrinth. She has tons of merchandise.
The reality is likely much more boring: money and time.
Persona games are massive. Reload is a 70-to-100-hour experience. Doubling the protagonist options means doubling a huge chunk of the production assets. When you're trying to hit a global simultaneous launch date, something has to give. Unfortunately, it was the pink-haired heroine.
The Social Link Problem in Reload
One of the biggest arguments for the FeMC Persona 3 Reload inclusion is how she handled the SEES members.
In the original male route, you spend your time hanging out with the track team, a gourmet king, and an old couple at a bookstore. They’re fine. But you don't really get deep with your actual battle partners unless they happen to be romanceable girls.
The FeMC route fixed this.
She could talk to Akihiko about his grief.
She could mentor Ken.
She could actually befriend Junpei without it being weird.
Reload tries to fix this with "Linked Episodes," which are great, but they aren't Social Links. They don't give you that same sense of mechanical progression. Kotone’s route felt more like a "team" game, whereas Makoto’s route often feels like a "lonely boy and his acquaintances" game.
Does it actually matter for the "Canon"?
"Canon" is a dirty word in the Persona community.
✨ Don't miss: Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time is Still the Series' Most Controversial Gamble
Some people say she isn't canon because she isn't in the main line. Others point to the multiverse themes in Persona Q2 to prove she is just as real as Makoto. At the end of the day, it's a single-player RPG. Your experience is what matters. If you feel like the story is better through her eyes, then for you, she’s the protagonist.
But for the "definitive" remake to ignore that perspective entirely? It leaves a sour taste for fans who started with the PSP version.
Looking Ahead: Will We Ever See Her?
Fans keep hoping for a "Persona 3 Reload: Pink" or some kind of massive expansion. Honestly? Don't hold your breath.
The Episode Aigis DLC (The Answer) was already a huge undertaking, and that only covers the epilogue. Re-adding an entire second protagonist route would be almost like making a whole new game. It’s more likely that ATLUS will take these lessons into Persona 6.
There is a massive demand for a female protagonist.
The success of the FeMC mods proves it.
The constant social media noise proves it.
If Persona 6 doesn't have a dual-protagonist system, or at least a choice, ATLUS is leaving money on the table. People want to see themselves in these stories, or at least see the story through a different lens.
Actionable Steps for the Disappointed Fan
If you’re bummed out about the lack of Kotone in the remake, you actually have a few choices rather than just venting on Twitter.
- Check out the Modding Community: If you're playing on PC, the "FeMC Reloaded Project" is the way to go. It’s a work in progress, but it’s the closest you’ll get to a native experience. They’ve already made huge strides in model replacement and dialogue fixes.
- Play Persona 3 Portable: It’s available on Steam, Switch, PS4, and Xbox. Yes, it looks like a visual novel most of the time. Yes, the "point and click" exploration is a downgrade. But the writing is still top-tier, and the FeMC exclusive Social Links are some of the best in the series.
- Voice Your Feedback (Respectfully): ATLUS actually listens to player surveys more than most Japanese developers. When they put out their annual consumer survey, make sure to mention the desire for protagonist options. It’s how we got the PC ports in the first place.
- Engage with the Linked Episodes: If you are playing Reload, don't skip the new character scenes for the male cast. It’s not a full Social Link, but it’s the developers' way of trying to bridge the gap left by the missing FeMC content.
The absence of FeMC Persona 3 Reload content doesn't make Reload a bad game. It’s still a masterpiece of the genre. But it does make it a "partial" remake in the eyes of many. It’s a brilliant retelling of one version of the story, while another version remains trapped in the low-res textures of the 2000s.
Maybe one day we'll get a version that truly has it all. Until then, we have the mods, the memories, and the portable version that started it all.