If you grew up in a house where Christmas Eve smelled more like fried calamari and baccalà than gingerbread and peppermint, you already know the vibe. Most holiday movies are about magical trains or falling in love with a prince in a fictional European country. But Feast of the Seven Fishes is different. It’s loud. It’s crowded. It feels like a memory you actually had, even if you aren't Italian.
Released in 2019 and directed by Robert Tinnell—who adapted it from his own graphic novel—this movie captures a very specific slice of 1983 Pennsylvania. It’s not just a "food movie." It’s a movie about the anxiety of bringing a new person into your chaotic family ecosystem. Honestly, it’s one of the few films that understands that the holidays aren't just about joy; they're about the grueling labor of tradition and the fear of things changing.
The Raw Reality of Feast of the Seven Fishes
The plot is deceptively simple. Tony, played by Skyler Gisondo, is a nice guy with an artistic streak who brings a "non-Italian" girl, Beth (Madison Iseman), home for the big Christmas Eve dinner. It sounds like a rom-com setup. It isn't. Not really. The romance is the catalyst, but the family is the protagonist.
You’ve got a cast that feels like they’ve lived in that house for thirty years. Joe Pantoliano and Ray Abruzzo bring a level of authenticity that you just can't fake. They aren't "movie" Italians with exaggerated accents and catchphrases. They are working-class guys in the Rust Belt. They bicker about how to clean the eels. They drink beer in the kitchen. They argue about history and neighborhood gossip while they’re elbow-deep in flour and fish guts.
What makes Feast of the Seven Fishes stand out is the texture. You can almost smell the frying oil. The production design doesn't feel like a Hollywood set; it feels like your grandmother’s basement. It’s wood-paneled walls, tight hallways, and too many people sitting around a table that’s slightly too small for all the dishes being served.
Why the "Seven Fishes" Tradition Matters
The tradition itself, La Vigilia, is the backbone of the film. For those who didn't grow up with it, the idea is to abstain from meat on Christmas Eve, replacing it with a massive multi-course seafood feast. Why seven? Some say it’s for the seven sacraments. Others say the seven days of creation. Some families do nine, or eleven, or thirteen.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
In the movie, the fish isn't just food. It’s a burden and a blessing. It represents the work required to keep a culture alive in a place like Fairmont, West Virginia. When you see the men in the family heading to the market or prepping the kitchen, you’re seeing a ritual that connects them to ancestors they never met. It’s about labor as a form of love.
The film captures the specific stress of the "outsider" perspective through Beth. She isn't mocked for not being Italian, but she is definitely a spectator to a very intense sport. Watching her navigate the unspoken rules of the household provides the audience with a way in. We see the absurdity of the arguments through her eyes, but we also see the warmth that makes Tony want to stay.
A Cast That Actually Fits
Let's talk about the performances for a second. Skyler Gisondo is great because he has this permanent "I'm slightly overwhelmed but I'm trying my best" face. He’s the perfect foil for the louder personalities. And then there's Joe Pantoliano (Uncle Frankie). If you only know him as Cypher from The Matrix or Ralph Cifaretto from The Sopranos, you’re in for a treat. He’s the heart of the kitchen here. He’s funny, he’s sharp, and he feels like the uncle everyone has—the one who knows exactly how everything should be done and will tell you you’re doing it wrong while he’s laughing at you.
Then you have Robert Piccolo and Paul Ben-Victor. The chemistry between these actors suggests a shorthand that usually takes years to develop. They interrupt each other. They finish each other’s thoughts. They argue about the "correct" way to prepare smelts. It’s these small, granular details that make Feast of the Seven Fishes feel like a documentary of a specific time and place.
The 1980s Without the Neon
Most movies set in the 80s lean hard into the "Stranger Things" aesthetic. Leg warmers, synth-pop, and neon lights everywhere. This movie avoids that trap. The 1983 of this film is brown, grey, and lived-in. It’s the 80s of the working class. The clothes are slightly ill-fitting. The cars are heavy American steel. The music—while featuring some era-appropriate tracks—doesn't feel like a "Best of the 80s" playlist.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
This grounded approach makes the emotional beats land harder. When Tony and Beth talk about their futures, it doesn't feel like a scripted movie moment. It feels like two kids in a dying coal town wondering if they’re allowed to want something more than what their parents had.
Common Misconceptions About the Movie
People often go into this thinking it’s a broad comedy, something like My Big Fat Greek Wedding. It’s not. It has funny moments, sure, but it’s more of a "slice of life" drama. It’s quiet. It’s observational. If you’re looking for high-stakes plot twists or slapstick humor, you’ll be disappointed.
Another misconception is that it’s only for Italian-Americans. While the specific cultural markers are Italian, the themes are universal. It’s about the tension between the individual and the tribe. It’s about that weird period in your early 20s when you’re starting to see your parents as actual people instead of just authority figures. Anyone who has ever felt like they were "performing" their family identity for a new partner will find something to love here.
How to Watch It the "Right" Way
You shouldn't just put this on in the background while you’re scrolling on your phone. It’s a movie of small moments. Watch it with a snack. Better yet, watch it while you’re actually cooking.
The film is available on most major streaming platforms (it frequently pops up on Amazon Prime and Tubi). It’s become a cult classic for a reason. Every year around December, the search volume for the film spikes because people treat it as part of their own holiday ritual. It’s the kind of movie you share with people. You send it to your siblings with a text saying, "Doesn't Uncle Carmine act exactly like this?"
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
The Impact of Robert Tinnell’s Vision
Robert Tinnell didn't just write a script; he recreated his life. This is a passion project in the truest sense. Because it was based on his graphic novel, there’s a visual specificity to the shots. He knows where the light hits the kitchen table at 4:00 PM. He knows how the steam from the pasta pot fogged up the windows.
This level of detail is what earns the film its E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) in the eyes of viewers. It’s authoritative because it’s lived. You can’t research your way into writing a scene about the "correct" way to eat a fried eel; you have to have lived it.
Key Takeaways for Your Next Movie Night
If you're planning to watch Feast of the Seven Fishes this season, keep a few things in mind to get the most out of it:
- Pay attention to the background. A lot of the best character work happens in the corners of the frame—the way the women in the family interact in the kitchen versus how the men behave in the yard.
- Don't expect a tidy ending. Like real life, not every conflict is resolved with a bow. The movie is about a single day, and it ends with the feeling that life just... keeps going.
- Look for the food. If you aren't hungry by the end of the first act, you might want to check your pulse. The cinematography of the cooking process is legitimately top-tier.
- Check out the graphic novel. If you love the movie, Tinnell’s original work provides even more context and stories that didn't make it into the 90-minute runtime.
The film serves as a reminder that traditions aren't just things we do; they are the things that hold us together when everything else is changing. Whether you’re an artist like Tony or a newcomer like Beth, there’s a seat at the table for you. Just make sure you like seafood.
Actionable Steps for Fans of the Film
If you've watched the movie and want to dive deeper into the culture or the craft behind it, here is what you should do next:
- Host your own (simplified) feast. You don't need seven fishes. Start with two or three. The point of the movie is the gathering, not the complexity of the menu.
- Explore the Rust Belt cinema subgenre. If you liked the atmosphere of this film, look into other movies that capture the American Northeast and Midwest without the Hollywood gloss, such as The Deer Hunter (for the atmosphere) or Adventureland (for the 80s vibe).
- Research the music. The soundtrack is a hidden gem. Look up the tracks used during the party scenes to get a real feel for the early 80s "working-class" sound.
- Support indie creators. Robert Tinnell continues to work on projects that highlight the history and culture of West Virginia and the surrounding areas. Following his work is a great way to see more "human" stories get told.
This isn't a movie that tries to change the world. It just tries to show you one house, one family, and one very long, very fishy day. And honestly? Sometimes that’s exactly what a holiday movie should do. It’s a small, perfect window into a world that feels both incredibly specific and completely universal. If you haven't added it to your rotation yet, this is the year to do it. Just don't forget the lemons.