If you’ve ever tried to book a summer morning at Farm Neck Golf Club in Oak Bluffs, you already know the frustration. It’s basically the equivalent of trying to get front-row seats to a surprise Taylor Swift set at a dive bar. You click, you refresh, you sigh. Honestly, the place has a reputation that precedes it, and it’s not just because a couple of former Presidents—Clinton and Obama—have spent their vacations hacking out of its primary rough. It's about the land.
Martha’s Vineyard is full of exclusive corners. Private hedges hide massive estates, and high-end clubs usually require a blood oath or a seven-figure bank statement just to look at the scorecard. Farm Neck is different. It’s "semi-private." That means while there are members who pay their dues and enjoy the perks, the rest of us—the seasonal visitors and the year-round locals—actually have a shot at playing it.
The course sits on a peninsula. You have the Sengekontacket Pond on one side and the salty air of the Nantucket Sound everywhere else. It’s beautiful. But don't let the views of the water distract you. This is a legitimate championship-caliber layout designed by Geoffrey Cornish, Bill Robinson, and Patrick Mullane. It’s a par-72 that can play surprisingly long when the wind starts whipping off the pond, which, let’s be real, is almost always.
What People Get Wrong About the "Presidential" Hype
People talk about the Presidents like they designed the place. They didn't. They just happen to have good taste in views. When Bill Clinton played here back in the 90s, it put Farm Neck Golf Club in Oak Bluffs on the global map. Then Barack Obama showed up, and the legend grew. You’ll still see people scanning the fairways for Secret Service detail.
But here’s the thing: the club existed long before it became a political backdrop. It was established in 1979. Back then, it was just a bold idea to turn 500 acres of prime coastal real estate into something that balanced recreation with serious conservation. That's why you see so much native vegetation. They didn't just clear-cut the woods to make a golf course; they tucked the holes into the existing landscape.
The difficulty isn't just the wind. It's the psychological pressure of the back nine. You come off the turn and you’re hit with some of the most scenic, and punishing, golf in New England. The 14th hole? It’s a monster. You’re hitting toward the water, and if your slice is working that day, you might as well just drop a new ball before you even finish your follow-through. It’s gorgeous, but it’s mean.
💡 You might also like: Weather in Lexington Park: What Most People Get Wrong
Getting a Tee Time Without Losing Your Mind
If you want to play here during the "high season" (July and August), you need a strategy. You can't just roll up and expect a spot. The public can typically book three days in advance.
You have to be on the website the second those times go live. Seriously. It’s competitive. If you miss the window, your only real hope is a cancellation or playing during the shoulder season. September on the Vineyard is actually better anyway. The water is still warm, the humidity has dropped, and the crowds at the Farm Neck Cafe have thinned out.
Speaking of the Cafe—it’s actually one of the best-kept secrets for non-golfers. You don't need a tee time to eat there. You can sit on the porch, look out over the 1st tee, and watch people embarrass themselves while you eat a lobster roll. It’s surprisingly casual. No one is going to look at you sideways if you aren't wearing a $100 polo shirt.
The Layout: A Tale of Two Landscapes
The front nine and the back nine feel like different worlds.
The front is more "woodsy." You’re playing through clusters of oak trees and maples. It feels private. Then you hit the back nine and the sky just opens up. Suddenly, you’re looking at the marshes. The 15th is a par-5 that will break your heart if you try to be a hero.
📖 Related: Weather in Kirkwood Missouri Explained (Simply)
- The 4th Hole: A tricky par-4 that requires a precise drive. If you're long and left, you're dead.
- The 8th Hole: This is where the elevation changes start to get interesting.
- The 14th Hole: The "signature" hole. It’s a par-4 that hugs the water. If the wind is coming off the pond, you're hitting two clubs more than you think.
- The 18th Hole: A solid finishing hole that brings you right back to the clubhouse where the beer is cold.
Most people think the course is flat because it’s on the coast. It’s not. There are subtle rolls and ridges that make green reading a nightmare. The greens are notoriously fast and true, maintained by a crew that clearly takes a lot of pride in their work.
Beyond the Fairways: Conservation and Community
One thing the brochures don't always emphasize is the Farm Neck Foundation. The club actually gives back a significant amount of money to Vineyard charities. It’s not just a playground for the wealthy; it’s a major part of the island’s social fabric. They’ve funded everything from affordable housing initiatives to local schools.
The land itself is protected by various easements. This ensures that the 500 acres won't eventually become a sprawling subdivision of McMansions. When you’re walking the fairways, you’re basically walking through a nature preserve that just happens to have flagsticks in it. You’ll see ospreys, deer, and maybe the occasional fox.
It’s also worth mentioning the tennis program. They have some of the best clay courts on the island. People forget that because the golf is so famous, but the tennis community at Farm Neck is just as vibrant. If your golf game is in the toilet, you can always go take out your aggression on a tennis ball.
Survival Tips for Your First Round
Don't be a hero. That’s the best advice for Farm Neck Golf Club in Oak Bluffs.
👉 See also: Weather in Fairbanks Alaska: What Most People Get Wrong
The temptation is to try and drive the green on the shorter par-4s or go for the par-5s in two. Unless you’re a scratch golfer, don't do it. The rough is thick, and the hazards are unforgiving. Play for the fat part of the green. Take an extra club on the holes near the water.
And for heaven's sake, keep up the pace of play. Island time is a real thing, but it doesn't apply to the golf course. The marshals are friendly, but they will keep you moving. Nobody wants to spend six hours in the sun, no matter how good the view is.
Essential Logistics
- Rental Clubs: They have them, and they’re usually high-quality Titleist or TaylorMade sets. You don't need to drag your bag on the ferry if you're only playing one round.
- The Pro Shop: It’s well-stocked. If you forgot your SPF or your favorite glove, they’ve got you covered.
- Transportation: If you're staying in Oak Bluffs, it’s a short bike ride or a quick Uber. If you’re coming from Edgartown, give yourself 20 minutes because Beach Road traffic in the summer is a nightmare.
- Attire: Standard golf attire. Collared shirts are a must. No denim.
Final Insights for the Island Golfer
Farm Neck is special because it manages to be elite without being elitist. It’s expensive—let’s not pretend it isn’t—but it feels like a treat rather than a rip-off. You’re paying for the maintenance, the views, and the history.
If you’re planning a trip, try to aim for late May or early June. The island is waking up, everything is green, and the pressure on the tee sheet is much lower. You might even find a same-day opening if someone’s boat gets delayed.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit:
- Set an alarm for 7:00 AM three days before your intended play date to secure a tee time online.
- Pack a windbreaker even if the forecast says 80 degrees; the coastal breeze at Oak Bluffs is unpredictable.
- Budget for a post-round meal at the Cafe—the views of the 1st and 10th tees are worth the price of a burger alone.
- Check the local ferry schedules if you are coming from the mainland specifically for a tee time; the Woods Hole to Oak Bluffs route is the most direct.