Drafting a kicker is basically the equivalent of doing your taxes. Nobody actually wants to do it. We all wait until the second to last round, look at some generic list, and click the name with the highest projected point total. It’s a chore. But honestly, if you're looking at fantasy football rankings kickers as a static list of "who is the best at kicking a ball," you’re already losing points.
Most people think Justin Tucker is the default #1 because he’s the GOAT. He is. But being the best real-life kicker doesn't always translate to being the best fantasy asset. In 2023, Brandon Aubrey came out of nowhere—straight from the USFL—to lead the league. If you followed the "standard" rankings back in August of that year, you didn't even know his name.
The secret isn't finding the strongest leg. It’s finding the right environment.
The Big Lie in Most Fantasy Football Rankings Kickers
We need to stop ranking these guys by talent alone. It’s a trap. A kicker's success is about 30% their own skill and 70% their head coach’s level of cowardice. You want a coach who gets "stuck" in that dead zone between the opponent's 35 and 20-yard lines. You want the guy who looks at a 4th and 3 and says, "Nah, let's just take the three points."
High-powered offenses like the Kansas City Chiefs or the San Francisco 49ers are actually a double-edged sword. Harrison Butker and Jake Moody get plenty of work, sure. But they also kick a ton of extra points. An extra point is worth 1. A 50-yard field goal is worth 5. You do the math.
I’d rather have a kicker on a team that moves the ball well but struggles in the Red Zone. Think about the 2023 Dallas Cowboys or the Houston Texans. They could march down the field, but when the windows got tight near the goal line, they stalled. That is the gold mine for fantasy football rankings kickers.
Weather, Domes, and the "Coors Field" Effect
If you’re drafting a kicker who plays eight games in a windy, snowy outdoor stadium in November, you're hurting your ceiling. It’s physics.
📖 Related: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Look at the schedule. The AFC North is a nightmare for kickers late in the year. Justin Tucker is a legend, but even he has to fight the swirling winds in Baltimore and Cleveland. Meanwhile, guys like Ka’imi Fairbairn or whoever is kicking for the Colts are chilling in a temperature-controlled dome. No wind. No rain. Just pure, clean ball flight.
The altitude in Denver is real, too. It’s the closest thing football has to Coors Field. A 55-yarder in Denver feels like a 48-yarder anywhere else. If the Broncos ever get a competent offense again, their kicker becomes an immediate top-five play regardless of "talent."
Why Efficiency is Overrated
You’ll see some fantasy football rankings kickers that prioritize Field Goal Percentage. This is a mistake for fantasy purposes. I don't care if a kicker is 100% on the year if he only attempts 15 field goals.
I want volume.
Give me the guy who misses three or four kicks but leads the league in attempts. Volume is a product of "Script." If a team is consistently trailing or playing in close games, they are forced to take the points. If a team is winning by 30, they might start going for it on 4th down just to practice or run out the clock. You want the kickers on teams that are perpetually in "one-score" dogfights.
The Rookie Kicker Myth
Every year, a team drafts a kicker in the 4th or 5th round (looking at you, San Francisco and New England). Everyone rushes to put them in the top 10 of their fantasy football rankings kickers.
👉 See also: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
Don't do it.
Rookie kickers are notoriously shaky. The pressure of the NFL is different than Saturday nights in the SEC. Remember Roberto Aguayo? Most accurate kicker in NCAA history, second-round pick, and he was out of the league in a heartbeat. Let someone else take the risk on the "prospect." You take the veteran who has been through the fire.
Strategy: The "Streaming" Revolution
The best way to handle kickers isn't to draft one and hold them all year. It’s to stream.
Look at the Vegas totals. Every week, oddsmakers put out over/under totals and spreads. You want a kicker on a team that is a favorite (so they’ll be scoring) but has a high implied point total. If the Raiders are 3-point favorites in a game with a 48-point total, Daniel Carlson is a great play.
- Dome Games: Always prioritize indoor kickers.
- Weak Defenses: Target kickers facing teams that have a "bend but don't break" defense. These defenses allow yards but tighten up in the Red Zone.
- The Revenge Narrative: It sounds silly, but kickers often perform well against former teams. They know the turf, they know the wind, and they have a chip on their shoulder.
People will tell you it's all luck. It's not. It's probability.
If you draft Brandon Aubrey because the Cowboys offense is a juggernaut that occasionally stalls, you're playing the odds. If you draft Justin Tucker because he’s the "best," you're playing the name. In fantasy, the name doesn't get you points. The uprights do.
✨ Don't miss: Navy Notre Dame Football: Why This Rivalry Still Hits Different
Stop Ignoring the Waiver Wire
By Week 4, the fantasy football rankings kickers you saw in August are irrelevant. Injuries happen to offensive lines, which kills a team's ability to punch it in for touchdowns. That actually helps kickers.
If a star quarterback goes down and is replaced by a game-manager, that kicker's value might actually go up. The team will play more conservatively. They’ll take the points. They’ll play for field position.
Watch the usage. If a guy is getting 3+ attempts per game, he needs to be on your roster, regardless of what his "rank" was during the draft.
Actionable Insights for Your Season
To actually win the kicker spot, you need to move away from the "set it and forget it" mindset. It's about constant adjustment.
- Draft your kicker last. Period. There is zero reason to reach for one. The difference between the K3 and the K12 is usually less than two points per week.
- Monitor the Vegas lines. Each Tuesday, check the upcoming spreads. Target kickers on teams favored by 3 to 7 points in high-scoring games.
- Check the weather reports. Sunday morning, if there’s a 20mph crosswind in Buffalo, drop that kicker. It doesn't matter how good he is.
- Prioritize the "Red Zone Stalls." Use sites like TeamRankings to see which teams have the lowest Red Zone TD conversion rate. Those teams are kicker factories.
- Don't be loyal. If your kicker has a bye week, don't waste a bench spot unless it's a truly elite outlier season. Just drop them and grab the best available streaming option.
Winning your league requires an edge in every category. While your opponents are blindly following outdated fantasy football rankings kickers, you can gain a 2-3 point advantage every week just by playing the environment. Over a 14-week season, that's 30-40 points. That is often the difference between making the playoffs and watching from the sidelines.