Fantasy football is basically a game of managing chaos. You spend all summer looking at spreadsheets, watching training camp highlights of a guy who will eventually be "inactive" by Week 4, and convincing yourself that your RB1 is invincible. But then the inevitable happens. Your star running back clutches his hamstring in the second quarter. Your season flashes before your eyes. This is why people talk about handcuffs—that backup running back sitting on your bench, waiting to inherit the workload. It feels like insurance. It feels safe. Honestly, though? Most of the time, you're just lighting a roster spot on fire.
The logic seems sound on the surface. If you draft Christian McCaffrey, you "must" draft his backup. If McCaffrey goes down, you have the replacement ready to go, and your team doesn't skip a beat. Except, that’s almost never how it actually plays out in the modern NFL. The "bell-cow" back is a dying breed, and the "plug-and-play" backup is even rarer.
The Myth of the RB1 Replacement
We’ve all been told that if a starter goes down, the backup just steps into that exact same role. That is a lie. Well, maybe not a lie, but a massive oversimplification. When a superstar like Saquon Barkley or Breece Hall exits a game, the coaching staff doesn't usually look at the RB2 and say, "Okay, do everything he did." They can't. If the backup were as good as the starter, it would be a 50/50 committee already.
What actually happens is a messy transition to a "running back by committee" (RBCC). You thought you had a direct replacement, but instead, the team signs a veteran off the street, promotes a practice squad guy for third downs, and your "handcuff" suddenly only gets 35% of the snaps. You spent a 9th-round pick on a guy who provides 6 points a week when you finally need him. It’s frustrating. It’s also predictable if you look at how coaches like Kyle Shanahan or Sean McVay operate. They prioritize the system over the individual, often rotating bodies to keep everyone fresh.
When Handcuffing Actually Makes Sense
I'm not saying you should never do it. There are specific scenarios where a backup is actually worth the investment. Think about the "Elite Handcuff." These are players who have standalone value even when the starter is healthy, or they are in an offense so prolific that any warm body with a pulse will produce.
Take a look at the history of the Dallas Cowboys or the San Francisco 49ers. When Tony Pollard was backing up Ezekiel Elliott, he was actually outperforming him on a per-touch basis. That wasn't just a handcuff; that was a "lottery ticket" with a floor. If you're holding a guy who is one injury away from being a top-5 fantasy asset, that’s a smart play. But holding the backup to a mediocre starter on a bad offense? That’s just hoarding garbage. Why would you want the backup to a running back on the New England Patriots or the Carolina Panthers? If the starter is struggling to get 10 points, the backup isn't going to save your season.
The Opportunity Cost Nobody Mentions
Every time you stash a pure handcuff—someone who literally does nothing for your team unless an injury occurs—you are passing up on "league winners." This is the biggest mistake I see in home leagues. While you're holding the backup to your own starter "just in case," your league-mate is picking up the next breakout rookie wide receiver or a running back on a rising offense.
🔗 Read more: When is Georgia's next game: The 2026 Bulldog schedule and what to expect
Winning fantasy football isn't about not losing; it's about maximizing your ceiling. You want players who can explode.
- The Bench Clog: A pure handcuff is a bench clogger.
- Waiver Wire Misses: You can't bid on the hot new thing because you're "scared" to drop your insurance policy.
- The Upside Play: Taking a swing on a high-upside rookie is almost always better than a low-ceiling backup.
Think about it this way. If your RB1 stays healthy all year, that handcuff provided zero value. If your RB1 gets hurt and the backup is mediocre, he still provided almost zero value. You are betting on a very specific, narrow outcome. Meanwhile, the guy who drafted a third-stringer with elite speed just watched that player take over a backfield by Week 6.
Predicting the Unpredictable Backfield
If you really want to play the handcuffs game, you have to be a bit of a detective. You have to look at depth charts, but more importantly, you have to look at contract structures and coaching tendencies. For example, if a team has a veteran starter on a one-year deal and a high-draft-pick rookie sitting behind him, that rookie isn't a "handcuff." He’s a "takeover candidate." That is a massive distinction.
Breece Hall’s recovery from an ACL tear a couple of seasons ago is a perfect example. People were drafting Dalvin Cook as a "handcuff" or "insurance," but the reality was a split backfield where neither lived up to the ADP (Average Draft Position) for a long stretch. The situation was murky, the offensive line was struggling, and the "safety net" ended up being a hole in the roster.
You also have to account for the "Ambiguous Backfield." These are teams where we don't really know who the starter is going into Week 1. Think about the 2023 Miami Dolphins with Raheem Mostert and De'Von Achane. If you drafted Mostert, was Achane the handcuff? Or was it the other way around? In these cases, you don't draft for insurance; you draft for the talent. Achane’s efficiency was so high that it didn't matter if he was the "backup."
The "Other Person's Handcuff" Strategy
Here is a pro tip: Stop drafting your own backups. If you want to use a roster spot on a backup running back, draft the backup to someone else's star.
💡 You might also like: Vince Carter Meme I Got One More: The Story Behind the Internet's Favorite Comeback
Why? Because if your star gets hurt and you have the handcuff, you've basically just stayed level. You haven't improved your team; you've just mitigated a disaster. But if your star stays healthy and your opponent's star gets hurt, and you have their backup? Now you have two RB1s. You've just created a massive advantage out of thin air. That is how you win championships. It’s aggressive, it’s a bit mean, and it’s statistically much more likely to result in a dominant roster.
Real-World Examples of Handcuff Failures
We tend to remember the successes, like when Alexander Mattison used to fill in for Dalvin Cook and put up 20 points. But we forget the times it blew up in our faces. Remember when Mike Davis was the "must-have" backup for Christian McCaffrey? The first year it worked great. The second time? He was just a guy. He was inefficient, the offense stalled, and he eventually lost touches to other players.
Or look at the Pittsburgh Steelers. For years, whoever started at RB for Mike Tomlin was a fantasy goldmine. Then, the talent level dropped, the offensive line regressed, and suddenly, the "next man up" philosophy didn't mean a guaranteed 15 points. It meant a frustrated fantasy manager starting a guy who averaged 3.2 yards per carry.
The NFL is moving toward specialized roles. You have your "bruiser" for short yardage, your "satellite back" for third downs, and your "starter" who does a bit of both. When the starter goes down, teams rarely ask one person to do both roles again. They split them. You end up with two players who are both unstartable in fantasy.
Strategies for a Better Bench
Instead of hoarding backups, focus on "Tier 2" starters. These are guys who are currently in a committee but have the talent to take over. Look for players on high-scoring offenses. A backup on the Chiefs or Lions is worth ten times more than a backup on the Giants.
- Prioritize Talent Over Proximity: Don't draft a bad player just because he's second on the depth chart. Draft the talented player who might force his way into more touches.
- Watch the Practice Squad: Often, the "handcuff" listed on the official website isn't the guy the coaches actually trust. Pay attention to beat writers during training camp.
- Be Ready to Churn: Your bench should be a revolving door. If a backup doesn't show flashes by Week 3, drop him for the next big thing on the waiver wire. Don't be loyal to a player who isn't playing.
The game has changed. The old-school advice of "always draft your handcuff" is outdated. It's a security blanket that actually makes your team weaker by limiting your flexibility. You’re playing to win, not playing to avoid losing.
📖 Related: Finding the Best Texas Longhorns iPhone Wallpaper Without the Low-Res Junk
The Math of the Late-Season Surge
Late in the season, the value of handcuffs does shift slightly. In Weeks 14-17 (the fantasy playoffs), the waiver wire is usually picked clean. At that point, roster flexibility matters less because there are no "breakout rookies" left to find. This is the only time I recommend loading up on backups. If you are locked into a playoff spot in Week 12, drop your 5th wide receiver and grab the backup to your RB1. At that specific moment, the "insurance" value outweighs the "upside" value because the upside players are already on other teams.
But in September? Keep your bench open for the next Kyren Williams or Puka Nacua. Those are the players who change your season's trajectory, not a backup who might give you 70% of your starter's production if a catastrophe occurs.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Draft
Stop looking at the depth chart as a static list. It's a fluid, living thing. When you're in the double-digit rounds of your draft, ask yourself: "If this player’s teammate gets injured, is this guy actually good enough to win me my week?" If the answer is "maybe, I guess," then move on.
Look for high-velocity offenses. Target backups who catch passes, as that provides a "PPR floor" even if they don't get 20 carries. Most importantly, don't be afraid to leave your star "unprotected." The roster spot you save by not drafting a mediocre backup is the spot you'll use to claim the league's next superstar off the waiver wire on Tuesday night.
Focus on building a roster of "starters-in-waiting" rather than "replacements-in-waiting." There is a massive difference between the two. One wins you games; the other just helps you lose more slowly.
Next Steps for Success:
- Audit your current roster: Identify any "pure handcuffs" who have no path to touches without an injury.
- Scan the waiver wire: Look for "supplemental" backs on high-scoring teams rather than direct backups on poor ones.
- Evaluate the "Third-Down" guys: In PPR leagues, these players often have more value than the direct backup because they play regardless of the score.
- Don't panic: If your starter gets hurt and you don't have the backup, the world isn't over. FAAB (Free Agent Acquisition Budget) exists for a reason. Be aggressive on the wire rather than defensive in the draft.