You’re wandering the Mojave, probably over-encumbered with bent tin cans and Mojave yucca fruit, and you stumble into a companion named Veronica Santangelo. She’s a scribe for the Brotherhood of Steel with a sarcastic streak and a power fist. Eventually, she gives you a quest. It’s called Fallout New Vegas I Could Make You Care. On the surface, it’s just another "go here, fetch that" mission. But if you actually pay attention to the subtext, it’s one of the most heartbreaking pieces of writing in RPG history.
It’s about a dying world trying to hold onto a dead past.
Most people play New Vegas and just see the guns and the factions. They see Caesar’s Legion being Roman cosplayers or the NCR being bureaucratic nightmares. But "I Could Make You Care" is small. It’s personal. It’s about one woman trying to save her family from their own stubbornness, and failing miserably.
The Philosophy of Dead Ends
The quest triggers after you’ve spent some time with Veronica. She starts seeing the world outside the Brotherhood's "Hidden Valley" bunker. She sees that the Brotherhood is stagnating. They’re obsessed with hoarding technology while the rest of the world is actually living. They’re a museum that thinks it’s an army.
Veronica wants to prove to Elder McNamara (or Elder Hardin, depending on your choices) that the Brotherhood needs to adapt or die. To do this, she needs technology that will blow their minds. You have three choices for the "proof": the Rangefinder from the Archimedes II orbital laser, some high-tech farming data from Vault 22, or a pulse gun from Vault 34.
Vault 22 is a nightmare. It’s full of "Spore Carriers"—basically people who have been turned into plant monsters by an experimental fungus. If you bring the farming data back, it’s a direct slap in the face to the Brotherhood’s philosophy. It’s tech that creates life, not tech that destroys it.
Why the Choice Matters
I’ve always felt that the Vault 22 data is the most poignant choice for Fallout New Vegas I Could Make You Care. The Brotherhood is so focused on weapons that they can't even fathom using their intellect to grow food. They’re terrified of the surface, yet they’re starving in a hole. When you present this data to McNamara, he shuts it down. He doesn't want it. It’s too "dangerous."
It isn't about the data. It's about control.
If the Brotherhood starts farming, they become part of the world. If they become part of the world, they lose their status as "protectors of the old world." They’d rather starve as elite soldiers than thrive as common farmers.
🔗 Read more: Florida Pick 5 Midday: Why Most Players Chase the Wrong Patterns
The Tragedy of Elijah and Christine
You can’t talk about this quest without mentioning the ghosts. If you’ve played the Dead Money DLC, you know the backstory here, even if the base game doesn't explicitly spell it out in your face. Veronica was in love with another woman named Christine. Father Elijah, the previous Elder, broke them up because it was "against the rules" to have a relationship that didn't produce children for the Brotherhood.
Elijah is the shadow hanging over Fallout New Vegas I Could Make You Care. He’s the one who taught Veronica everything, and he’s the one who abandoned his people to chase ghosts in the Sierra Madre.
When you’re doing this quest, you’re basically trying to fix the mess Elijah left behind. You’re trying to give Veronica the home she deserves. But the game doesn’t give you a "happy" ending. No matter what tech you bring back, the Elder says no. He refuses to change.
The Brotherhood stays in the bunker.
The Fallout of Choice
Once the Elder rejects your proof, Veronica is at a crossroads. This is where the quest gets really heavy. She asks you what she should do. Should she stay with her family, knowing they are doomed to fade into obscurity? Or should she leave and try to make a life for herself on the surface?
If she stays, she remains a scribe, but she’s miserable. If she leaves, a group of Brotherhood "Paladins" (mostly just thugs in power armor) ambushes her. They murder a group of peaceful Followers of the Apocalypse just to send a message to her.
It’s brutal.
Honestly, it’s one of the few times a video game made me genuinely angry at a faction I usually liked. The Brotherhood aren't the good guys here. They’re a cult.
💡 You might also like: Finding Your True Partner: Why That Quiz to See What Pokemon You Are Actually Matters
Technical Hurdles: Getting the Quest to Trigger
Look, New Vegas is a masterpiece, but it’s also held together by duct tape and hope. Sometimes Fallout New Vegas I Could Make You Care just... won't start.
You need to take Veronica to specific "trigger points" around the Mojave. These are places where she comments on the state of the world. Common spots include:
- The Casa Madrid Apartments in Westside (talking to Tom Anderson).
- The Mormon Fort in Freeside (talking to Julie Farkas).
- The Nelson or Cottonwood Cove (seeing the Legion’s brutality).
- The Silver Rush in Freeside.
- The Nellis Air Force Base (talking to the Boomers).
You need to trigger three of these conversations. Sometimes the scripts get stuck. If you’ve already finished the quests associated with these locations, you might find yourself stuck. A common fix is to dismiss her and re-recruit her, or simply travel to a completely different part of the map and wait 24 hours.
The Real-World Weight of Sunk Cost
The reason this quest resonates so much with players in 2026 is that it’s a perfect illustration of the Sunk Cost Fallacy. The Brotherhood has spent centuries hoarding tech. They’ve lost thousands of lives. To admit they were wrong now would be to admit that all those lives were lost for nothing.
So, they keep doing the same thing. They keep failing.
We see this everywhere. In businesses that won’t pivot, in relationships that are long dead, and in political systems that refuse to modernize. Veronica is the voice of reason that gets shouted down by "tradition."
The Fate of the Followers
If you choose to have Veronica leave the Brotherhood, you go to a Followers of the Apocalypse outpost. She wants to use her skills to help people. It’s a noble goal. But the Brotherhood Paladins show up and slaughter everyone at the outpost.
They don't kill Veronica. They just kill everyone she tries to help.
📖 Related: Finding the Rusty Cryptic Vessel in Lies of P and Why You Actually Need It
It’s a psychological prison. They are telling her: "You can never leave us, because anyone you touch will die." It makes the Brotherhood one of the most villainous factions in the game, despite their shiny armor and cool gadgets.
How to Maximize the Quest Rewards
If you’re purely a min-maxer and don't care about the emotional trauma, here’s the breakdown.
Choosing to stay with the Brotherhood grants Veronica the Bonds of Steel perk, which increases her Damage Threshold (DT). It makes her a better tank.
Choosing to leave grants her the Causeless Rebel perk, which increases her unarmed attack rate.
If you want her to be a powerhouse with a ballistic fist, have her leave. If you want her to survive longer in a firefight, have her stay. But keep in mind, if she stays, her ending slide is pretty depressing. She watches her family slowly die out while she remains a loyal scribe of a dead order.
Final Thoughts on the Mojave’s Most Depressing Quest
Fallout New Vegas I Could Make You Care is a masterclass in narrative design. It takes a massive, world-ending conflict and shrinks it down to the size of a single person’s heartbreak. It shows that sometimes, you can do everything right—you can find the lost tech, you can make the perfect argument, you can provide the data—and the world still won't change.
It’s a lesson in the limits of influence.
You can’t make someone care if they’ve already decided that their pride is worth more than their survival.
Actionable Next Steps for Players
- Trigger the Quest Early: Don't wait until the end of the game. Get Veronica as soon as you hit 188 Trading Post. The earlier you do this, the more her dialogue will flavor your journey.
- Play Dead Money First: Or at least after. Understanding who Elijah was makes the betrayal in this quest hit ten times harder.
- Check Your Reputation: If you are vilified by the Brotherhood before finishing this quest, it will likely break or lead to a quick combat encounter that ends the quest prematurely.
- Save Often: Because of the scripted triggers, this quest is notorious for bugging out. Save before you enter any of the trigger locations like Vault 34 or Nellis.
- Watch the Ending Slides: Pay attention to how your choice for Veronica affects the end of the game. New Vegas is famous for showing you the long-term consequences of your "help."