It starts with something small. Maybe you wanted to collect rainwater in your backyard to water your prize-winning tomatoes, or perhaps you thought about selling a few homemade sourdough loaves to the neighbors down the street. Then you go online and realize that in many jurisdictions, you’re technically a criminal for doing either. Everything I want to do is illegal isn't just a hyperbolic meme or a catchy song lyric anymore; for many people living in highly regulated urban and suburban environments, it’s a genuine daily frustration.
Why does it feel like the world is wrapped in caution tape?
The sheer volume of administrative law has exploded over the last fifty years. In the United States, for instance, the Federal Register—the daily journal of government rules—regularly tops 70,000 to 80,000 pages annually. That doesn't even count the Byzantine maze of municipal codes, HOA bylaws, and county ordinances that dictate whether you can paint your front door a specific shade of teal or keep a few chickens in a coop behind the garage.
The "Death by a Thousand Cuts" of Personal Freedom
We live in an era of "permission-based living." Honestly, it’s exhausting. Most of these laws were written with good intentions. Building codes prevent your house from collapsing. Health codes keep you from getting salmonella at the local diner. But somewhere along the way, the scale tipped from "protecting the public" to "preventing anyone from doing anything without a permit."
Take the "cottage food" industry. If you want to start a small business from your kitchen, you’re often met with a wall of bureaucracy that requires commercial-grade sinks, specific floor tiling, and expensive inspections that cost more than your first year of projected revenue. It kills the American dream before it even gets a chance to wake up.
Is it safety? Or is it revenue?
Often, it's a mix of both, seasoned with a heavy dose of liability fear. Cities are terrified of lawsuits, so they ban everything from park benches without armrests (to prevent sleeping) to kids' lemonade stands (to prevent "unlicensed vending"). When people say everything I want to do is illegal, they’re usually talking about these micro-infractions that make life feel less like an adventure and more like a guided tour through a high-security facility.
The Problem with "Over-Criminalization"
Legal scholars like Harvey Silverglate, author of Three Felonies A Day, argue that the average professional unknowingly commits multiple crimes every single day simply because the laws are too vague and numerous for any human to actually know. You might be violating the Lacey Act by importing a product with a specific type of wood, or you might be breaking a telecommunications law by using a neighbor's Wi-Fi with their permission but against the ISP's Terms of Service.
💡 You might also like: Converting 50 Degrees Fahrenheit to Celsius: Why This Number Matters More Than You Think
It’s a trap.
The complexity of the law creates a "selective enforcement" environment. Since the police can’t arrest everyone for everything, they have the power to pick and choose who to go after. That's a dangerous level of discretion. It turns the law from a shield into a weapon.
Why Even Simple Hobbies Feel Like Crimes
Let's look at the "off-grid" movement. Many people want to disconnect from the municipal water and power lines to live sustainably. Sounds noble, right? In many parts of Florida and California, it’s actually illegal to live in a house that isn't connected to the grid. You can be evicted from a home you own outright for the crime of being self-sufficient.
Urban foraging is another one. You see a beautiful patch of wild blackberries on public land. You pick them. In many municipal parks, that is technically "theft of city property" or "destruction of natural resources."
Even the way we move is regulated. Jaywalking laws, while slowly being repealed in places like Virginia and California, were originally pushed by the auto industry in the 1920s to shift the blame for accidents from drivers to pedestrians. It turned the simple act of crossing a street into a fineable offense. It’s a classic example of how "illegal" behavior is often just behavior that inconveniences a powerful lobby.
The Shadow of Zoning Laws
If you’ve ever wondered why you can’t build a tiny house in your own backyard for an aging parent, look at R1 zoning. These laws were designed to keep neighborhoods looking a specific way—usually to maintain property values. But they also make it illegal to live "differently."
If your version of a good life involves a 300-square-foot home on wheels, the law often views you as a vagrant rather than a homeowner. This mismatch between modern needs and 1950s-era zoning is exactly why people feel like everything I want to do is illegal. The law is a lagging indicator; it moves much slower than culture or technology.
📖 Related: Clothes hampers with lids: Why your laundry room setup is probably failing you
The Digital Frontier and "Illegal" Innovation
Technology moves at the speed of light; the law moves at the speed of a tired snail.
Remember the early days of Napster? Or more recently, the "grey market" of cryptocurrency? Innovation almost always starts in the "illegal" or "unregulated" zone because the existing laws didn't anticipate it.
- Drones: For years, flying a drone for fun was a legal grey area. Now, you need FAA registration and, in many cases, a remote pilot certificate.
- Biohacking: People experimenting with Nootropics or DIY gene editing often find themselves running afoul of FDA regulations meant for giant pharmaceutical companies.
- Right to Repair: Trying to fix your own iPhone or John Deere tractor was—and in some ways still is—a legal minefield due to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).
We’ve reached a point where the default answer to "Can I do this?" is "Probably not without a lawyer." That stifles creativity. It makes people afraid to try new things. It creates a culture of "ask for permission" rather than "seek for forgiveness," and that's a boring way to run a civilization.
The Psychological Toll of Constant Regulation
When you feel like you're constantly breaking rules, you stop respecting the law altogether. This is a concept known as "legal estrangement." If the law forbids you from feeding the homeless in a public park (which is illegal in several US cities), you don't think "Oh, I'm a bad person." You think "The law is a joke."
This erosion of trust is hard to fix.
When people say everything I want to do is illegal, they are expressing a sense of alienation from their own government. They feel like the rules weren't made for them, but against them. This is especially true for the younger generation who see the housing market, the job market, and the literal land around them fenced off by regulations they never voted for.
Case Study: The Lemonade Stand
It sounds like a cliché, but it happens every summer. A kid sets up a stand. A neighbor calls the cops. The cops shut it down because the kid doesn't have a $500 temporary food service permit and a business license.
👉 See also: Christmas Treat Bag Ideas That Actually Look Good (And Won't Break Your Budget)
What does that teach the kid?
It teaches them that entrepreneurship is a hassle and that the state is an obstacle to be avoided. Thankfully, some states like Utah and Texas have passed "Lemonade Stand Laws" to exempt minors from these requirements, but the fact that we needed actual laws to allow children to sell sugar water is an indictment of the system's overreach.
Navigating a World Where "Everything is Illegal"
So, what do you actually do when you feel boxed in by the law? You can’t just ignore everything and end up in a cell. But you also shouldn't let the weight of bureaucracy crush your spirit.
First, distinguish between "malum in se" (things that are wrong in themselves, like hurting people) and "malum prohibitum" (things that are illegal only because a statute says so, like having a fence that's six inches too high).
Most of the things people complain about fall into the second category. These are administrative hurdles.
Actionable Steps for the "Illegally" Inclined
If you want to live a life that pushes against these boundaries, you have to be smart about it. You don't have to be a rebel without a cause; be a rebel with a permit—or at least a very good understanding of the loopholes.
- Join Your Local Planning Commission. Seriously. This is where the "everything I want to do is illegal" stuff starts. Zoning meetings are usually empty. If you show up, you have an outsized influence on whether your city allows ADUs (Accessory Dwelling Units) or urban gardens.
- Look for "Right to Farm" or "Cottage Food" Laws. Many states have recently expanded these. You might find that the thing you thought was illegal is actually protected under a new "food freedom" act.
- The 14-Day Rule. In many national forests, you can live for free (dispersed camping) for 14 days at a time. It’s a legal way to live "off-grid" without violating local vagrancy laws.
- Advocate for "Permit-Exempt" Tiers. Instead of fighting to abolish all rules, fight for tiers. A billion-dollar factory needs a different set of rules than a guy making wooden spoons in his garage.
The goal shouldn't be a lawless society, but a legible one. A society where the rules are few, clear, and actually protect people rather than just protecting the status quo. Until then, keep an eye on your local ordinances, and maybe keep those backyard chickens a little bit quieter.
The feeling that everything I want to do is illegal is a signal that our legal system has become detached from the lived reality of common sense. But laws are just words written by people, and people can change them. Start small, stay informed, and don't let the Red Tape win.
Move forward by identifying one specific local ordinance that prevents you from doing something productive—be it a home business or a garden—and find a local advocacy group (like the Institute for Justice) that specializes in fighting "petty" bureaucracy. Real change happens when people stop rolling their eyes at the "illegal" nature of their lives and start demanding a return to common-sense freedom.