Why Everyone Thinks the Stock Market Will Crash—and What History Actually Says

Why Everyone Thinks the Stock Market Will Crash—and What History Actually Says

You’ve seen the headlines. Probably every single morning for the last six months. They scream about "Black Swans," "The Great Reset," or how some obscure indicator from the 1920s is flashing red. Honestly, it feels like half the internet is just waiting for the day the stock market will crash so they can finally say, "I told you so." But if you’ve been sitting on the sidelines in cash because some guy on X (formerly Twitter) posted a chart of the M2 money supply looking scary, you’ve already lost money. Inflation saw to that.

The truth is markets are weird. They don't always go down when things are bad, and they don't always go up when things are good. Right now, we are dealing with a cocktail of high interest rates, geopolitical tension in the Middle East and Eastern Europe, and an AI boom that feels a little too much like 1999 for some people’s comfort. Is a crash coming? Maybe. Is it guaranteed? Absolutely not.

The Math Behind the Fear

When people talk about why the stock market will crash, they usually point to the P/E ratio. Specifically, the Shiller PE (CAPE ratio). It’s basically a way of looking at whether stocks are "expensive" compared to their historical earnings. Historically, the average is around 17. Lately, we’ve been hovering well above 30.

Does that mean a collapse is imminent? Not necessarily. It just means you’re paying more for every dollar of company profit than your grandfather did. High valuations can stay high for years. Decades, even. Just look at the "Lost Decade" in Japan or the late 90s in the US. People called the dot-com bubble years before it actually popped. If you sold in 1996 because Alan Greenspan talked about "irrational exuberance," you missed out on three of the greatest years in market history. You felt smart for a minute, then you felt poor.

Why 2026 Feels Different (And Why It Might Not Be)

We’re currently navigating a landscape where the Federal Reserve has been playing a high-stakes game of "chicken" with inflation. Jerome Powell has been remarkably consistent: they want 2%. We aren't quite there, but the "soft landing" narrative—the idea that we can cool the economy without breaking it—has become the consensus.

🔗 Read more: U.S. Small Business News: What Most People Get Wrong About 2026

When everyone agrees on something, that’s usually when you should worry.

Most market crashes don't happen because of the things we’re all watching. They happen because of the thing no one saw coming. In 2008, it wasn't just "houses are expensive"; it was the fact that the underlying plumbing of the global financial system was rotted out by subprime derivatives. In 2020, it was a virus. Today, the risks are often cited as:

  • Commercial Real Estate: Empty office buildings in cities like San Francisco and Chicago are "zombie" assets.
  • Private Credit: A massive, unregulated market that hasn't been tested in a real recession.
  • Concentration Risk: The "Magnificent Seven" or whatever we're calling the big tech giants this week. If Nvidia or Microsoft sneezes, the whole S&P 500 catches a cold.

Looking at the "Buffett Indicator"

Warren Buffett has a favorite metric: the total market cap of all US stocks divided by the country's GDP. When it's over 100%, he gets nervous. Right now, it’s significantly higher than that.

But here’s the counter-argument. The US economy is more capital-light than it used to be. Software companies don’t need to build massive factories or buy thousands of tons of steel to grow. Their margins are insane. So, comparing a 2026 tech-heavy economy to a 1970s manufacturing economy using the same ratio is sorta like comparing apples to... well, microchips. It doesn't quite fit perfectly.

✨ Don't miss: Netflix Earnings Date 2025: Why This Year Changed Everything for Investors

What to Actually Do If You're Scared

If you are genuinely convinced the stock market will crash, the worst thing you can do is panic-sell everything on a Tuesday morning. Timing the bottom is impossible. Even the pros at Goldman Sachs or BlackRock miss it.

Instead of trying to predict the end of the world, focus on your "Sleep at Night" factor. If a 20% drop in your portfolio makes you want to vomit, you have too much in stocks. Simple as that.

✨ Don't miss: Who Owns Buc-ee's Gas Stations: What Most People Get Wrong

  1. Rebalance, don't retreat. If your tech stocks have grown so much they now make up 80% of your money, sell some. Move it to boring stuff. Bonds, value stocks, or even just a high-yield savings account.
  2. Check your leverage. Crashes only kill the people who owe money. If you’re trading on margin or have massive high-interest debt, fix that first.
  3. Dividend Aristocrats. Look for companies that have paid dividends for 25+ years straight. They’ve survived the 2000 pop, the 2008 crisis, and the pandemic. They’re boring. Boring is good when things get spicy.
  4. Keep "Dry Powder." Have some cash ready. The best way to view a crash isn't as a tragedy, but as a giant "50% Off" sale at your favorite store.

The market spends about 70% of its time going up. Betting on a crash is betting against human ingenuity and the collective drive of every CEO on earth to make their stock price go higher. It's a losing bet over the long term, even if it feels like a winning one for a few scary months. Stop checking the tickers every ten minutes. Go for a walk. The world has ended many times on paper, yet here we are, still trading.

Actionable Next Steps:

  • Audit your current allocation to see if you are over-exposed to "growth" and "AI" sectors.
  • Automate your investments through Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) to remove the emotional burden of "picking the right time."
  • Build an emergency fund covering 6-12 months of expenses outside of the brokerage market to ensure you never have to sell at the bottom.