If you spent any time watching NBC in the early nineties, you probably have a specific, claustrophobic memory involving a coffin and a ventilation pipe. It was 1993. Most soap operas were doing the usual "who's the daddy" or "evil twin" tropes, but Days of Our Lives decided to traumatize a generation by burying a lead character alive. That character was Carly Manning, played by the incomparable Crystal Chappell. Honestly, if you mention the name Carly Manning to any long-time soap fan today, they don't think about her medical degree or her complicated European lineage first. They think about her screaming into a walkie-talkie while Vivian Alamain cackled from above ground.
It’s been decades since that storyline peaked. Yet, the character remains a cornerstone of what made the "golden era" of 90s soaps so addictive. She wasn't just a damsel in distress; she was a brilliant surgeon with a messy heart.
The Arrival of Katerina von Leuschner
When Carly first showed up in Salem back in 1990, she wasn't actually Carly. Well, she was, but she was hiding. She arrived as a rebel with a secret identity, eventually revealed to be Katerina von Leuschner. This wasn't some minor plot point. It tied her directly into the deep, often convoluted lore of the Alamain family.
Bo Brady was her first major spark. Their chemistry? Off the charts. It was that classic "tough guy meets sophisticated woman with a dark past" vibe that writers love. But the real meat of her story wasn't just about who she was dating. It was about her friction with the establishment. She was a doctor who actually cared, which, in Salem, usually means you’re about to have a very bad week.
She represented a shift in how female leads were written. She was capable. She had agency. Even when she was being hunted by international criminals or dealing with her brother Frankie’s drama, she felt like the smartest person in the room. Most of the time, anyway.
That Infamous Burial: Why Carly Manning on Days of Our Lives Became an Icon
We have to talk about Vivian Alamain. Louise Sorel and Crystal Chappell together were lightning in a bottle. Vivian’s hatred for Carly was visceral, fueled by the death of Vivian’s brother, Nicky. It led to the most famous—or infamous—plotline in daytime history.
📖 Related: Al Pacino Angels in America: Why His Roy Cohn Still Terrifies Us
Vivian drugged Carly with a herb that mimicked death. The doctors pronounced her. The town mourned. And then, Vivian had her buried in a casket equipped with a light, oxygen, and a radio.
Cruel. It was peak camp, but played with such terrifying sincerity that it worked. For weeks, viewers watched Carly struggle in that box. It tapped into a universal phobia. The brilliance of the writing here was the pacing. They didn't rush it. They let the audience sit with that discomfort. When Lawrence Alamain finally realized she was alive and started digging, the collective sigh of relief from the American public could have powered a small city.
The Complex Love Triangle with Bo and Billie
After the burial, things didn't exactly get easier. This is a soap, after all. The dynamic between Carly Manning, Bo Brady, and Billie Reed is still debated on fan forums today. You have the "Barly" shippers and the "Bo and Billie" purists.
It was messy.
Bo and Carly felt like destiny to some, but the arrival of Lisa Rinna’s Billie Reed threw a massive wrench into that. It wasn't just a simple "who will he choose" scenario. It was about Bo’s own identity. Carly represented a world of elegance and high-stakes drama, while Billie was the gritty, relatable underdog.
👉 See also: Adam Scott in Step Brothers: Why Derek is Still the Funniest Part of the Movie
When Carly eventually left Salem in 1993, it felt like the end of an era. She went to Europe. She stayed away for a long, long time. In the real world, Crystal Chappell went on to become a powerhouse on other shows like Guiding Light and One Life to Live, but the shadow of Carly Manning always loomed over her career in the best way possible.
The 2009 Return: A Different Kind of Drama
When Carly Manning finally returned to Days of Our Lives in 2009, the landscape of Salem had changed. The return was sparked by the murder of Lawrence Alamain—by Carly’s own hand.
Talk about an entrance.
This wasn't the same woman who left in the nineties. She was weathered. She was carrying the weight of a secret daughter, Melanie Jonas. The transition from "romantic lead" to "mother struggling with her past" was handled with a lot of nuance. It gave the character a fresh layer of relevance.
Seeing her interact with a grown-up Bo Brady was bittersweet for fans. The spark was there, but the world had moved on. Her struggle with substance abuse (specifically painkillers) during this run was a controversial choice by the writers, but Chappell acted the hell out of it. It showed the human cost of all those years of trauma. You can't be buried alive and hunted by assassins without it leaving some scars, right?
✨ Don't miss: Actor Most Academy Awards: The Record Nobody Is Breaking Anytime Soon
Why the Character Still Matters in the Streaming Era
Soap operas are a dying breed in some ways, moving to platforms like Peacock, but characters like Carly Manning are why people still tune in. She wasn't a caricature.
- She bridged the gap between the "supercouple" era and the modern, more character-driven era.
- She provided a foil for one of the greatest villains of all time (Vivian).
- Her medical background allowed for stories that weren't just about romance.
Honestly, the way fans reacted to her 2011 departure showed she still had "it." People weren't ready to let go. She represents a time when soaps were the primary watercooler conversation.
What You Should Do Next if You're a Fan
If you're feeling nostalgic for the Manning era, there are a few ways to dive back in without getting lost in the thousands of episodes.
- Hunt down the 1993 "Buried Alive" clips. Most are available in fan archives or on YouTube. Watching them as an adult gives you a much greater appreciation for the technical acting involved in performing in a confined space.
- Check out Crystal Chappell’s digital work. After leaving Days, she became a pioneer in web series like Venice, which carries a lot of the same emotional depth she brought to Carly.
- Follow the Alamain family tree. If you’re a new viewer, understanding the Alamain/von Leuschner history is essential for making sense of current Salem power struggles.
The legacy of Carly Manning isn't just about a woman in a box. It's about a character who survived the impossible and came out the other side, flawed but still standing. That’s why we’re still talking about her thirty years later.