Music is weird. You take a song that everyone knows, hand it to a different artist, and usually, it falls flat. It’s a gamble. But when we talk about a Since You’ve Been Gone cover, we aren't just talking about a pop song; we are talking about a vocal obstacle course that has humbled some of the best singers in the business.
Kelly Clarkson’s 2004 smash is the gold standard of "power pop." Written by Max Martin and Lukasz "Dr. Luke" Gottwald, it was actually rejected by Pink and Hilary Duff before Kelly turned it into a Grammy-winning anthem. Since then, everyone from indie rockers to heavy metal bands has tried to claim it. Most fail.
Why? Because the song is deceptive. It starts in a lower register that feels manageable, then explodes into a chorus that requires massive lung capacity and a specific kind of "grit" that isn't easy to manufacture.
The Day A Day To Remember Made It Metal
If you were on the internet in 2007, you couldn't escape the A Day To Remember version. It is arguably the most famous Since You’ve Been Gone cover in existence. They didn't just play the song; they took the bubblegum structure and injected it with pop-punk energy and a heavy breakdown that shouldn't have worked, but absolutely did.
The music video was a parody of the original, which helped it go viral in the early days of YouTube. While Kelly’s version is about empowerment, ADTR’s version feels like a chaotic release of pent-up suburban frustration. They kept the melody intact—which is the most important part of any cover—but added those double-bass drums that make you want to punch a hole in a drywall. Honestly, it’s one of the few times a male vocal worked for this track. Most guys try to sing it in the original key and end up sounding like they’re stepping on a LEGO. ADTR leaned into the scream-singing, and it saved them.
Why Rock Bands Love This Song So Much
There is a specific DNA in this track that appeals to guitarists. Despite being a "pop" song, the riff is pure rock and roll. It’s crunchy. It’s loud.
Take the Butch Walker version. Butch is a power-pop legend who actually worked closely with many of these artists. His take is more stripped back, emphasizing the songwriting craftsmanship over the vocal gymnastics. It reminds you that underneath the glossy 2000s production, the bones of the song are indestructible.
Then you have the indie-folk attempts. These are hit or miss. Some artists try to make it "sad" by slowing it down and playing it on an acoustic guitar. It’s a bold choice. Sometimes it feels soulful, but often it just loses the "f-you" energy that makes the song great in the first place. You can’t really be polite when singing "Since You’ve Been Gone." It requires a bit of spit and vinegar.
The Vocal Trap: Why Most Covers Fail
Let's get technical for a second. The chorus of this song hits a high B-flat 4. For a female belt, that is a "money note." It’s right in that sweet spot where you have to be loud, but also clear.
- The Breath Control Issue. Most singers run out of air by the second "Since you've been gone" because they push too hard too early.
- The Enunciation. Kelly bites her words. A lot of covers get too "flowery" with the vowels, and the attitude disappears.
- The "Yeah, Yeah" Bridge. This is where the amateur covers fall apart. If you don't have the stamina to hit those repetitive high notes at the end, the whole song loses its climax.
Realistically, if you’re doing a Since You’ve Been Gone cover, you’re competing with a performance that redefined pop music in the 2000s. Pitchfork once called it one of the best tracks of the decade. That’s a lot of pressure.
💡 You might also like: Mistborn: The Bands of Mourning Is Actually a Western Noir Masterpiece
The Surprising Range of Interpretations
You’d be surprised who has tried this. Weird Al Yankovic did a polka medley version. Florence + The Machine have tackled it live, bringing a certain ethereal weight to it. Even Tokyo Police Club did a version that sounds like a basement garage band jam.
The diversity of these covers proves one thing: Max Martin is a genius. The song is "trans-genre." It doesn't matter if you play it on a synthesizer, a banjo, or a distorted Gibson Les Paul; the hook is going to get stuck in your head.
I think the best covers are the ones that don't try to out-sing Kelly Clarkson. You aren't going to beat her at her own game. She has one of the most powerful voices in history. The successful covers are the ones that change the mood. ADTR changed it to "angry/mosh-pit." Butch Walker changed it to "singer-songwriter/earnest." If you just try to do a karaoke version of the original, everyone is just going to wish they were listening to the Breakaway album instead.
What to Look for in a Great Cover
If you are hunting for a new version to add to your playlist, look for these three things:
Authentic Emotion
Does the singer actually sound like they’re glad someone is gone? Or do they sound like they’re reading a grocery list? The "Since you've been gone / I can breathe for the first time" line needs to feel like a sigh of relief.
Creative Re-arrangement
If the backing track sounds exactly like the 2004 radio version, it’s a waste of time. I want to hear different drum patterns. I want to hear a synth where there used to be a guitar, or vice versa.
Vocal Risk-Taking
I love it when a singer changes the melody slightly in the second verse. It shows they aren't just mimicking a record; they’re living in the song.
🔗 Read more: Disney+ and Hulu Bundle Basic: What Most People Get Wrong About the Price
Putting Together Your Own Version
If you're a musician thinking about recording a Since You’ve Been Gone cover, don't be afraid to transpose it. Drop the key. Make it fit your voice rather than straining for notes that aren't there. The song's power comes from the lyrics and the rhythm, not just the high notes.
Also, focus on the "shut" in "thanks to you, now I get what I want / since you've been gone." That percussive "T" at the end of the words is what gives the song its drive. Keep it sharp.
Final Take on the Legacy
It has been over two decades since this song dropped, and we are still talking about it. That is insane for a pop song. It survived the ringtone era, the iTunes era, and now the streaming era.
Every time a new contestant on a singing show tries to tackle a Since You’ve Been Gone cover, they are participating in a rite of passage. It is the ultimate "prove it" song. Whether it's the pop-punk snarl of the mid-2000s or a modern bedroom-pop reimagining, the song remains a titan.
To find the version that resonates with you, start by comparing the A Day To Remember version with Kelly’s original. Notice the difference in the "drop." Once you hear how the song can be bent without breaking, you’ll start to appreciate just how well-written it actually is. Check out the Butch Walker live versions on YouTube for a masterclass in how to command a crowd with just three chords and a lot of heart.