Choosing your first partner is a core memory. For some, it was a pixelated Charmander in 1998; for others, it was a high-definition Sprigatito. That choice defines your entire playthrough. It’s not just about stats. It's about that weird, emotional bond we form with a digital animal that follows us from the first patch of grass to the Hall of Fame. Honestly, looking back at every generation starter pokemon, you start to see a fascinating evolution in how Game Freak designs these creatures. They aren't just monsters anymore. They're characters with specific jobs, cultural inspirations, and occasionally, designs that make the internet absolutely lose its mind.
The meta has changed. Back in the Red and Blue days, your choice was essentially a difficulty setting. Picking Bulbasaur was "Easy Mode" because he rolled over the first two gyms. Charmander? That was "Hard Mode." Try taking a lizard to a rock fight against Brock and see how that goes. But today, the starter trio—Grass, Fire, and Water—serves as an introduction to complex mechanics like Hidden Abilities, signature moves, and competitive viability.
The Kanto Classics and the Blueprint of Perfection
We have to start at the beginning. Venusaur, Charizard, and Blastoise are the gold standard. Why? Because they represent a clear, natural progression. You see a turtle, it grows ears and a tail, then it gets cannons. Simple. Elegant.
Charizard is the outlier here. Despite not being a Dragon-type until Mega Evolution was introduced in Gen 6, it remains the poster child for the franchise. It’s the "cool" pick. But if we’re talking raw utility in the original games, Blastoise was the tank that got you through the Elite Four with Surf and Ice Beam. Venusaur, often sidelined by ten-year-olds who thought flowers were "lame," eventually became a powerhouse in the competitive scene thanks to Chlorophyll and Sleep Powder.
Johto took a different path. Meganium, Typhlosion, and Feraligatr felt like a direct sequel to Kanto’s design philosophy. Typhlosion is literally the "Vulcano Pokemon," and its base stats are identical to Charizard’s. That’s a fun piece of trivia most people miss—Game Freak basically copy-pasted the stats because the Fire-type formula worked so well. Feraligatr, however, suffered for years because the "Physical/Special Split" hadn't happened yet. It was a physical attacker forced to use special Water moves. It was a rough time to be a big blue crocodile.
When Every Generation Starter Pokemon Got "Jobs"
Somewhere around Generation 4 or 5, the design philosophy shifted. The starters stopped being just animals and started having "professions" or archetypes.
Look at the Sinnoh trio. Infernape is a Sun Wukong-inspired warrior. Torterra is a literal continent. Empoleon is a Napoleonic emperor. This was the era where the secondary typing became crucial. The "Steel" sub-type on Empoleon changed the game, giving it a massive list of resistances that made it a nightmare to take down.
👉 See also: Getting Through the Ruined Forge of Starfall Past Without Losing Your Mind
The Unova Controversy
Gen 5 gave us Snivy, Tepig, and Oshawott. People hated Emboar. They really did. It was the third Fire/Fighting starter in a row after Blaziken and Infernape. Fans were exhausted. "Another one?" was the collective groan across the internet. But Oshawott’s evolution into Samurott showed a weird jump—from a bipedal otter to a quadrupedal sea lion samurai. It felt disjointed to some, but it paved the way for the high-concept designs we see now.
The Kalos Breakthrough
Then came Greninja. If you look at the popularity polls, Greninja often sits at the very top, even eclipsing Pikachu in some years. It’s a ninja. Its tongue is a scarf. It’s objectively cool. But more importantly, its Protean ability changed how we think about typing. It allowed Greninja to change its type to match whatever move it was using. This was a massive shift in the power dynamic of every generation starter pokemon. Suddenly, your starter wasn't just a story-mode companion; it was a top-tier threat in the Master Ball tier of online play.
The Modern Era: Themes, Cultures, and Furry Controversies
Recently, Game Freak has leaned hard into regional themes. The Alola starters (Gen 7) were based on an archer (Decidueye), a pro wrestler (Incineroar), and an opera singer (Primarina). This is where the designs started becoming very "humanoid."
- Incineroar: It’s a "Heel" wrestler. It’s supposed to be arrogant and flashy. While it’s a polarizing design, it is arguably the most successful competitive Pokemon ever. In the VGC (Video Game Championships), Incineroar has been a dominant force for years because of its Fake Out and Intimidate combo.
- Rillaboom: The Gen 8 Grass starter is a drummer. It’s loud, it’s bulky, and with Grassy Surge, it shaped the entire Sword and Shield meta.
- Meowscarada: The magician cat from Gen 9. It’s fast, it hits hard with Flower Trick (which never misses and always crits), and it follows the trend of starters becoming "characters" rather than wild beasts.
There is a segment of the fanbase that misses the "monstrous" look. They want creatures like Feraligatr or Swampert. The shift toward bipedal, human-like starters has been a point of contention for a decade. But from a branding perspective, it makes sense. These Pokemon have more personality for the anime and merchandise. You can't really have a tea party with a feral swamp monster, but you can imagine a story with a spy lizard like Inteleon.
💡 You might also like: Winning the Uma Musume Negishi Stakes: Why This Dirt Sprint Changes Everything
Breaking Down the "Best" Choices
If you're jumping into a game today, how do you actually choose? It’s not just about which one looks the cutest in the first five minutes. You have to look at the "hidden" value.
In the Hoenn games (Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald), Mudkip is statistically the best choice. Swampert only has one weakness: Grass. Since Grass-type trainers are rare in Hoenn, Swampert basically allows you to steamroll the entire region. It’s the king of efficiency.
In the newer games, like Scarlet and Violet, Fuecoco is the darling of casual players. Its final form, Skeledirge, is a Fire/Ghost type with a signature move called Torch Song. Every time it uses it, its Special Attack goes up. It’s a self-buffing tank. It makes the difficult late-game battles significantly easier.
Why the Grass/Fire/Water Triangle Persists
People often ask why we don't have Dark/Psychic/Fighting or some other trio. The reason is simple: The Grass/Fire/Water triangle is the most intuitive teaching tool in gaming history.
Fire burns grass. Water puts out fire. Grass drinks water.
Even a five-year-old understands that. It’s the perfect "Rock-Paper-Scissors" introduction to the concept of Type Advantages. It teaches the player that no matter how strong your favorite is, there is always a counter. It humbles the player. It forces you to catch more Pokemon and build a team. That is the soul of the game.
Actionable Strategy for Your Next Playthrough
When you're staring at those three Poke Balls on the Professor's table, don't just click your favorite color. Think about the long game.
- Check the Gym Leaders: In many games, the first two gyms are heavily biased against one specific type. Doing a quick search for the region's gym lineup can save you hours of grinding.
- Look at the Secondary Typing: A pure Fire type is fine, but a Fire/Ghost or Fire/Fighting type offers much better coverage. You want a starter that can hit at least two or three different types for "Super Effective" damage.
- Speed vs. Bulk: Do you want to go first and one-shot enemies (like Meowscarada or Greninja), or do you want to survive a hit and counter-attack (like Torterra or Skeledirge)? Speed is generally better for the main story, while Bulk is often better for difficult boss fights.
- Hidden Abilities Matter: If you’re planning on playing online, the standard ability (like Overgrow or Blaze) is usually mediocre. You’ll want to look into how to get the Hidden Ability version later in the game through Ability Patches or Raids.
The history of every generation starter pokemon is a history of the franchise itself. From the simple sprites of the Game Boy to the complex, culturally-coded creatures of the Switch, these three choices remain the most important decision you'll make in any Pokemon journey. Whether you're Team Sprigatito or Team Bulbasaur, the bond remains the same. Pick the one you like, but keep an eye on those base stats—because at the end of the day, your rival is waiting, and they definitely picked the one that's super effective against you.
📖 Related: Not Of This World MTG: Why This Weird Eldrazi Spell Is Suddenly Relevant Again
Get your team ready. The next generation is always just around the corner, and the debate will start all over again.