Hindsight is a funny thing in the NFL. If you go back and look at any mock draft 2018 nfl experts were churning out in April of that year, it feels like looking at a dispatch from an alternate dimension. It was the year of the quarterback. Everyone knew it. Five went in the first round, but the order? Man, the order was a mess.
The 2018 class was supposed to be headlined by "safe" prospects. Sam Darnold was the golden boy. Josh Rosen was the "most pro-ready." Then you had the outliers—the guys with the "scary" traits that made scouts lose sleep. Josh Allen was a human highlight reel who couldn't hit the broad side of a barn in Wyoming. Lamar Jackson was a Heisman winner that some "experts," including Bill Polian, famously suggested should move to wide receiver.
Looking back, the 2018 draft didn't just change five franchises; it broke the way we evaluate the quarterback position entirely.
The Baker Mayfield Shocker and the Predictability of Chaos
Remember the morning of the draft? Honestly, the Cleveland Browns kept a tighter lid on the number one pick than most government agencies keep on classified intel. For months, the mock draft 2018 nfl consensus pointed toward Sam Darnold. He had the USC pedigree. He had the frame. He had that weirdly slow delivery that people just decided to ignore because he "looked the part."
Then, about 24 hours before the commissioner took the stage, the whispers started. Baker Mayfield.
It felt like a prank. Mayfield was a walk-on. He was short. He was fiery—maybe too fiery for a Browns team that had just gone 0-16 and needed a "leader," not a lightning rod. But John Dorsey didn't care. When Cleveland took Baker at number one, it sent a shockwave through every war room. It meant the Giants were on the clock with a generational running back sitting right there.
Dave Gettleman took Saquon Barkley at number two. People still argue about this. You don't take a RB at two, right? That’s what the analytics crowd says. But Saquon was a freak of nature. The Giants thought they could give Eli Manning one last ride. They were wrong, obviously, but in the context of 2018, that pick was the second domino that pushed the quarterbacks down the board.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
The Josh Allen "Accuracy" Problem That Wasn't
If you want to see a fan base melt down, go find the Twitter archives of Buffalo Bills fans the night they traded up to number seven. They didn't just trade up; they traded up for the guy with the 56% completion percentage.
Every mock draft 2018 nfl cycle featured a heated debate about Josh Allen. The stats were ugly. He was playing against Mountain West defenses and struggling to find his targets. The "Draft Twitter" community hated the pick. They called him a "tools-only" prospect who would inevitably bust because "you can't teach accuracy."
Well, it turns out you can teach accuracy if you have a work ethic like Allen’s and a coaching staff like Sean McDermott’s.
Allen is the ultimate outlier. He’s the reason why, every year since, we see teams reach for guys like Anthony Richardson or Will Levis. Teams are now obsessed with finding the next "unprocessed" superstar. They saw what the Bills did. They saw a guy go from a developmental project to an MVP candidate who can hurdle linebackers and throw 70 yards off his back foot. Buffalo didn't just draft a QB; they drafted a new philosophy.
The Disrespect of Lamar Jackson
It is still baffling that 31 teams passed on Lamar Jackson. Some passed twice.
The Baltimore Ravens eventually traded back into the first round at pick 32 to get him, but the journey there was insulting. Imagine being a Heisman Trophy winner and having teams ask you to run routes at the Combine. Lamar refused. He knew he was a quarterback.
✨ Don't miss: Men's Sophie Cunningham Jersey: Why This Specific Kit is Selling Out Everywhere
Most mock draft 2018 nfl pundits had Lamar sliding, but nobody expected him to be the last pick of the first round. The league was terrified of his style of play. They thought he was too thin. They thought his game wouldn't translate to the "complex" NFL defenses.
What actually happened? He became the second-ever unanimous MVP. He redefined what a dual-threat quarterback looks like in the modern era. The Ravens built an entire ecosystem around his specific talents, proving that the "pro-style" requirement was a relic of the past. If you look at the 2018 draft today, Lamar going 32nd is arguably the biggest heist in the history of the sport.
The "Safe" Picks That Failed
While Allen and Jackson were ascending, the guys who were supposed to be "safe" were crumbling.
- Sam Darnold (Pick 3): The Jets thought they found their savior. Instead, they found a guy who was "seeing ghosts" against the Patriots. Darnold had the talent, but the Jets' infrastructure was a disaster. It’s a classic tale: a good prospect ruined by a bad situation.
- Josh Rosen (Pick 10): Rosen famously said there were "nine mistakes" made ahead of him. As it turns out, the Cardinals decided he was a mistake too, dumping him after just one season to draft Kyler Murray. Rosen’s career became a cautionary tale about arrogance and the importance of processing speed over "pure" mechanics.
Josh Rosen was the darling of the mock draft 2018 nfl world for those who valued traditional pocket passing. He was "cerebral." He was "polished." He was also immobile in an era where the pocket was disappearing. He never found his footing, becoming a journeyman before most people even realized he was gone.
Why 2018 Still Dictates How Teams Draft Today
We are still living in the shadow of the 2018 draft.
When you see the Chicago Bears or the Washington Commanders debating between a "high-floor" guy and a "high-ceiling" guy, they are looking at the 2018 tape. They are looking at the delta between Josh Rosen and Josh Allen.
🔗 Read more: Why Netball Girls Sri Lanka Are Quietly Dominating Asian Sports
The 2018 class taught us that traits matter more than college production. It taught us that "pro-ready" is a myth because the NFL is constantly changing. A guy who is "pro-ready" for the 2005 NFL is a statue in the 2026 NFL.
We also learned about the "Year 3 Leap." Josh Allen didn't become JOSH ALLEN until his third season when the Bills brought in Stefon Diggs. It reminded GMs that you can't just draft a savior; you have to build a shrine for him to play in.
What You Can Take Away From This
If you’re looking back at 2018 to understand future drafts, keep these things in mind:
- Ignore the "Completion Percentage" Trap: If a guy has the arm talent and the rushing floor, NFL coaching can often fix the footwork issues that lead to poor accuracy.
- Context is King: Sam Darnold might have succeeded in Buffalo. Josh Allen might have failed with the Jets. The team matters as much as the player.
- The "Dual-Threat" Tax is Real: Teams are still scared of injuries with running QBs, but the reward (Lamar Jackson) is worth the risk of a late first-round pick every single time.
- Don't Fall for the "Polish": Pure pocket passers with no mobility are becoming extinct. If a scout calls a guy "pro-ready" but mentions he has "average athleticism," run the other way.
The 2018 NFL Draft was a pivot point. It was the moment the old guard of scouting died and the new, traits-based era began. Every time a mock draft comes out now, it’s trying to find the next Josh Allen—and usually failing, because players like that only come around once a decade.
If you're analyzing current prospects, start by looking at their "uncapped" potential rather than their current floor. Study the offensive coordinator's history with mobile quarterbacks. Look at the offensive line's pass-blocking win rate from the previous season. These are the factors that actually determined who survived the 2018 massacre and who didn't.
Next Steps for Draft Fans:
Go back and watch the 2018 Week 17 highlights of the Bills and Ravens. Pay attention to how different their offenses looked compared to the rest of the league. Then, compare that to the college tape of the current top-ranked QB prospects. You’ll see the DNA of 2018 in almost every high-end starter in the league today. For a deeper dive into modern scouting, check out the latest "Success Rate" metrics on Pro Football Focus (PFF) to see which traits are actually translating to wins in the current season.