Why Emily in Paris Netflix Fans Are Divided Over the Move to Rome

Why Emily in Paris Netflix Fans Are Divided Over the Move to Rome

Everything changed when she hopped on that Vespa. Honestly, nobody expected the most polarizing show on television to actually pack its bags and leave the city that defines its very title. But here we are. After four seasons of berets, questionable marketing campaigns, and a love triangle that has aged about as well as an open bottle of Bordeaux, Emily in Paris Netflix finally shifted its gears toward Italy. It was a bold move. Some might even say it was desperate.

If you’ve been following Emily Cooper’s chaotic trajectory since 2020, you know the drill. She arrives. She offends a local. She accidentally revolutionizes a luxury brand with a basic selfie. She wears something that costs more than a Parisian apartment’s monthly rent. It’s a formula that works, regardless of how much critics claim to hate it.

The Rome Pivot: Refresh or Identity Crisis?

Season 4, Part 2 took us to the Eternal City. Darren Star, the mastermind behind the series (and the man who gave us Sex and the City), decided that the Parisian drama had hit a ceiling. Gabriel was moping. Camille was... well, Camille. We needed fresh blood. Enter Marcello.

Marcello Muratori isn't just another handsome face in the crowd. He represents a fundamental shift in the show's DNA. While the show is still technically called Emily in Paris Netflix, the move to Rome feels like a soft reboot. For once, Emily isn't just trying to conquer a market; she's actually trying to live. Or at least, that’s what the writers want us to believe. The contrast between the hustle of Agence Grateau and the "slow life" of the Italian countryside provides a much-needed friction that the show had lost somewhere around Season 3.

It’s about the vibe. The lighting changed. The color palette shifted from the cool blues and greys of the Seine to the warm, terracotta hues of the Roman sunset.

Fact-Checking the "Marketing Genius"

Let’s be real for a second. As an expert looking at the "marketing" Emily actually does, most of it is nonsense. In the real world of 2026, a luxury brand like Savoir wouldn't let an American associate with 20k followers run a global campaign based on a pun.

However, the show does get one thing right: the power of "le buzz."

💡 You might also like: Dark Reign Fantastic Four: Why This Weirdly Political Comic Still Holds Up

In the latest episodes, we see the tension between traditional luxury—represented by Marcello’s family cashmere business—and the aggressive digitalization Emily brings. This is a real struggle in the fashion industry today. Brands are terrified of losing their soul while trying to stay relevant on TikTok. When Emily suggests "democratizing" a heritage brand, the pushback she receives from the Italians is actually the most grounded the show has ever been. It’s a rare moment of intellectual honesty in a show usually made of candy floss.

The Gabriel vs. Marcello Debate

You're either Team Gabriel or you're wrong. Or maybe you're Team Alfie. Or, if you’ve actually watched Season 4, you’re probably Team "Emily Needs a Break."

  1. Gabriel: The chef. The neighbor. The guy who can't seem to communicate a single thought without looking like he's about to cry into a Hollandaise sauce. His arc has become a bit of a circle. He wants a Michelin star. He gets it. He wants Emily. He gets her. He loses her. It’s exhausting.
  2. Marcello: The Italian heir. He's direct. He doesn't have a pregnant ex-girlfriend living downstairs (as far as we know). He offers Emily a version of herself that isn't tied to a spreadsheet or a ring light.

The fan reaction to Marcello has been overwhelmingly positive, mostly because viewers are tired of the back-and-forth in Paris. By moving the setting, the showrunners effectively bypassed the stagnant love triangle and gave Emily a reason to evolve. Even if that evolution still involves wearing 6-inch heels on cobblestone streets.

Cultural Friction: Paris vs. Rome

Paris didn't take the move lying down. Even the French President’s wife, Brigitte Macron, made a cameo this season. That’s not a fever dream; it actually happened. It’s a testament to the cultural weight Emily in Paris Netflix carries. Whether you think it’s a "cliché-fest" or "pure escapism," the French government clearly sees the value in the "Emily Effect" on tourism.

The Romans, however, are portrayed differently. In Paris, Emily is an intruder. In Rome, she’s a guest. There’s a warmth in the Italian episodes that feels like a direct response to the "cold" reception Emily traditionally gets at the office from Sylvie. Speaking of Sylvie—Philippine Leroy-Beaulieu continues to be the best thing on screen. She is the anchor. Without her cynical, cigarette-fueled glare, the show would float away into total absurdity.

Why We Can’t Stop Watching

It’s hate-watching. It’s love-watching. It’s "I need to turn my brain off after a 10-hour workday" watching.

📖 Related: Cuatro estaciones en la Habana: Why this Noir Masterpiece is Still the Best Way to See Cuba

Psychologically, the show functions as a travelogue for the weary. In an era where travel is expensive and complicated, seeing Emily navigate a pristine, curated version of Europe is a hit of dopamine. We know it’s not real. We know people in Paris don’t burst into song in the middle of a park (usually). But the production value is so high that we don't care.

The costumes, designed by Marylin Fitoussi, have become characters themselves. In Season 4, we saw a slight move away from the "costume-y" look of earlier years toward something a bit more sophisticated—think structured coats and monochromatic sets—though she still managed to sneak in a few outfits that looked like they were made of recycled gift wrap.

The Real-World Impact of the Show

The "Emily Effect" is a documented phenomenon. Travel searches for the locations featured in the show spike by over 200% following a season premiere.

  • Place de l'Estrapade: This quiet square in the 5th Arrondissement is now a permanent tourist trap.
  • La Boulangerie Moderne: They sell more "Pain au Chocolat" than they ever dreamed of before 2020.
  • Rome: Expect the Trevi Fountain to be even more crowded this summer.

This isn't just entertainment; it's a massive engine for the European tourism industry. When Netflix drops a new season, travel agencies literally rewrite their brochures.

What Happens in Season 5?

Netflix has officially greenlit Season 5. The big question: is she staying in Rome?

The cliffhanger left Emily with an apartment in Italy and a new office. But the show is called Emily in Paris. Does she become Emily in Europe? Or does she pull a classic Emily and try to commute between two countries while maintaining a flawless blowout?

👉 See also: Cry Havoc: Why Jack Carr Just Changed the Reece-verse Forever

Most industry insiders expect a split-narrative approach. We’ll likely follow Sylvie and the team in Paris while Emily tries to establish the Roman branch of Agence Grateau. This allows the show to keep its French roots while milking the Italian "La Dolce Vita" aesthetic for all it's worth. It’s a smart business move. It keeps the scenery fresh and the stakes high.

Actionable Insights for Fans and Travelers

If you're planning to live out your own Emily Cooper fantasy, there are a few things you should actually know before you book that flight.

First off, Paris is a working city. If you show up at a marketing firm and try to give them advice on their social media without being asked, you won't get a promotion; you'll get a lecture in French that you won't understand.

Secondly, the "Emily in Paris" tour is a real thing, but it's often better to do it yourself. Start at the Pantheon, walk down to her apartment, and then grab a coffee at Café de Flore. Just don't expect the waiters to be as patient as they are on TV.

If you're heading to Rome, remember that the "slow life" depicted in the show is a luxury. Rome is loud, chaotic, and the public transport is... let's just say, "unreliable." If you try to ride a Vespa through the city center like Marcello, please wear a helmet. The show skips that part for the sake of hair, but the Roman police won't be as forgiving.

To truly capture the show's spirit, focus on the "joy of discovery" rather than the "perfect photo." Emily’s best moments are when she actually stops trying to brand everything and just eats the pizza. Or the crepe. Or the pasta.

  • Download a language app: Even Emily is finally trying to learn the language (sorta). Don't be the American who expects everyone to speak English.
  • Invest in "statement" basics: You don't need a Dior wardrobe. A well-tailored blazer and a pair of comfortable but stylish boots will get you further in Europe than a beret ever will.
  • Be okay with being a tourist: The locals know. It’s fine. Embrace the awkwardness of not knowing how to order water. It’s part of the experience.

The legacy of the show isn't about the plot—which is often thin—but about the feeling of being somewhere new. Whether she's in Paris or Rome, Emily represents the messy, optimistic, and often cringe-inducing process of reinventing yourself in a foreign land. And that is why we’ll all be clicking "Play" the second Season 5 drops.