Why Emily in Paris Clothes Still Make Everyone So Angry (and Where to Buy the Best Pieces)

Why Emily in Paris Clothes Still Make Everyone So Angry (and Where to Buy the Best Pieces)

Let’s be real. If you walked through the 5th Arrondissement wearing a lime-green checkered suit and a matching beret, a Parisian would probably scoff at you before you even had a chance to say bonjour. Yet, here we are, seasons deep into a global obsession with Emily in Paris clothes. It’s chaotic. It’s loud. It’s frequently "ringarde," as Pierre Cadault would say. But somehow, it works.

Marylin Fitoussi, the costume designer who took over the reigns from the legendary Patricia Field, doesn’t care about your rules. She doesn’t care about "quiet luxury" or the "clean girl" aesthetic that has dominated Instagram for the last three years. She wants maximalism. She wants a clash of patterns that makes your eyes twitch just a little bit.

The show isn't a documentary. It’s a fever dream of high fashion, and if you're trying to dress like Emily Cooper, you have to embrace the absurdity.

The Evolution of the Cooper Closet

In the beginning, Emily was just a girl from Chicago with too many charms on her bag. Remember that Eiffel Tower blouse? Yikes. It was literal. It was thirsty. But as the seasons progressed, the Emily in Paris clothes transformed from "tourist trying too hard" into a sophisticated—albeit still eccentric—homage to French couture.

By Season 4, we see a massive shift. There’s more structure. We’re seeing vintage pieces from the 1980s mixed with contemporary giants like Magda Butrym and Schiaparelli.

Actually, the Schiaparelli moments are where the show hits its peak. When Emily wears those giant gold buttons or surrealist accessories, she’s finally speaking the language of French fashion, even if she’s still shouting it. It's not just about the labels, though. It's about the silhouette. Fitoussi often mentions in interviews that she wants to push the boundaries of what "matching" even means.

If you think a floral skirt can’t go with a striped top and a neon yellow coat, Emily Cooper is here to prove you wrong. Or at least to prove that you can wear it if you have enough confidence to ignore the stares.

It’s Not Just Emily: Camille and Sylvie’s Masterclass

Honestly, some people only watch for Sylvie Grateau. I get it. While Emily is busy being a human kaleidoscope, Sylvie is teaching a masterclass in effortless Parisian chic.

📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana

Philippine Leroy-Beaulieu wears clothes like they’re a second skin, not a costume. Her wardrobe is the antithesis of Emily’s. It’s all about black, olive, navy, and deep plums. It’s Saint Laurent. It’s Alaïa. It’s the kind of clothing that says "I have a lover and a cigarette, and I don’t care about your marketing plan."

Then there’s Camille. Her style is the "cool girl" bridge. She wears oversized blazers with nothing underneath, leather berets that don't look kitschy, and boots that cost more than my rent. If you want to actually live in a city without being pointed at, Camille is your North Star.

Where the Clothes Actually Come From

People think everything on the show is custom or straight off the runway. It’s not. A huge chunk of Emily in Paris clothes comes from high-end resale sites like Vestiaire Collective.

Fitoussi is a vocal advocate for upcycling. She mixes a $5,000 Chanel jacket with a $50 thrifted vest. This is the secret to the show’s visual depth; it doesn’t look like a mannequin at a department store. It looks like a collection.

  • The Big Labels: Miu Miu, Balmain, Christian Louboutin (obviously), and Valentino.
  • The "Affordable" French Brands: Maje, Sandro, and Ba&sh. These are the mid-tier brands that real Parisians actually buy.
  • The Wildcards: Germanier (the king of sustainable sparkles) and Iris Apfel’s collaborations.

If you’re hunting for a specific look, you need to look at the accessories. The bags are almost always the focal point. Whether it’s a tiny Pierre Hardy bag that can’t fit a phone or a massive Longchamp tote, the bag is the period at the end of the sentence.

The "Costume" Controversy

Why does the fashion world hate these outfits so much?

Because they’re "wrong."

👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed

Fashion critics at Vogue and Harpers Bazaar have spent years dissecting why Emily’s outfits shouldn't work. The proportions are often off. The colors vibrate against each other. But that’s the point. The show is an escape. It’s a cartoon. Expecting Emily to wear a beige trench coat and a navy striped shirt is like expecting a superhero to fight crime in a tracksuit. Boring.

How to Wear Emily in Paris Clothes Without Looking Like a Tourist

You want the vibe but don't want the mockery? Easy. Pick one "crazy" piece and build the rest of the outfit around it.

If you have a bright, multi-colored coat (very Emily), wear it with plain straight-leg jeans and a white tee. You get the pop of color without the sensory overload.

Also, pay attention to the textures. One thing the show does exceptionally well is mixing fabrics. Leather with lace. Wool with sequins. It creates a tactile richness that looks great on camera and even better in person.

  1. Start with a statement blazer. It’s the easiest entry point.
  2. Invest in one pair of "architecture" shoes. Think weird heels or bold buckles.
  3. Actually wear a hat, but keep your hair messy. If the hat is perfect and the hair is perfect, you look like you’re in a play.

The Economics of the Emily Effect

When a brand gets featured on the show, the "Emily Effect" is real.

Lyst and Google Trends usually see a massive spike in searches for things like "green silk scarves" or "checkered buckets hats" within 24 hours of a season drop. For smaller designers like Polène (the bag brand that exploded after being on the show), it can change their entire business trajectory.

This isn't just about pretty dresses; it's a massive global marketing engine. Every time Emily walks into a scene, she’s essentially a walking billboard for both established luxury and emerging talent.

✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild

Actionable Steps for Your Wardrobe

Stop buying entire outfits from fast-fashion sites that claim to have "Emily's Look." They usually look cheap because they lack the structural tailoring that makes the show's outfits pop. Instead, do this:

First, go to a local vintage or consignment shop. Look for 80s power suits with oversized shoulders. That’s the "Emily" silhouette. Second, don't be afraid of the "wrong" color. If you're wearing pink, try adding an orange accessory. It’s a classic color-blocking move that the show uses constantly to create energy.

Finally, remember the "Rule of Three." An outfit needs three elements to feel "finished." A top and bottom is just clothes. A top, bottom, and a bold belt (or a scarf, or a statement hat) is an outfit.

The most important takeaway from Emily in Paris clothes isn't that you should wear a beret. It's that fashion should be fun. It’s okay to be a little much. It’s okay to take up space.

If you’re ready to overhaul your closet, start by looking at your most "boring" outfit and adding one piece that makes you feel slightly nervous to wear. That’s the Cooper way. Check out sites like The RealReal or Vestiaire to find the actual labels used on set for a fraction of the retail price. Look for brands like Essentiel Antwerp or Ganni for that same playful, high-energy aesthetic without the five-figure price tag of the show's custom couture.

The real "Parisian" secret isn't following the rules—it's having the confidence to pretend the rules don't exist in the first place.