Why Dr. Mary Walker’s Medal of Honor Was Actually Revoked (and Why She Kept Wearing It Anyway)

Why Dr. Mary Walker’s Medal of Honor Was Actually Revoked (and Why She Kept Wearing It Anyway)

Dr. Mary Edwards Walker didn't care about your rules. She wore trousers when women were expected to suffocate in corsets, she practiced medicine when men thought "female doctor" was a joke, and she crossed enemy lines during the Civil War to treat dying soldiers because she believed human life mattered more than military rank.

But most people know her for one specific thing: she is still the only woman to ever receive the Medal of Honor.

What gets lost in the history books is the sheer messiness of it all. This wasn't a clean, heroic story where everyone clapped and she lived happily ever after. It was a bureaucratic nightmare. Fifty-two years after she was awarded the nation’s highest military honor, the government actually tried to take it back. They literally scrubbed her name from the rolls.

They told her she wasn't a "real" soldier. They told her the medal was for combat, not for being a brave surgeon.

Mary’s response? She basically told them to come and get it. She wore that medal on her lapel every single day until she died in 1919. She knew she earned it, and she didn't need a committee of men in 1917 to validate what she did in the bloody mud of 1864.

The Surgeon Who Refused to Sit Still

Mary Walker was born in Oswego, New York, in 1832. Her parents were—honestly, for the time—total radicals. They didn't believe in "gendered" work and encouraged Mary to be educated and independent. When she graduated from Syracuse Medical College in 1855, she was one of the few women in the entire country with a medical degree.

Then the Civil War broke out.

Most people think she just showed up and got a job. Nope. She went to Washington D.C. and tried to join the Union Army as a medical officer. They laughed at her. They told her she could be a nurse, but Mary knew she was overqualified for that. She didn't want to fluff pillows; she wanted to perform surgeries. So, she volunteered. For months, she worked for free at the Patent Office Hospital in D.C., proving she could handle the gore and the chaos.

📖 Related: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop

Eventually, the Army gave in. Sort of. They hired her as a civilian "Contract Assistant Surgeon." It was a workaround. She wasn't an officer, but she was doing the work of one. By the time the Battle of Chickamauga rolled around, she was in the thick of it.

Behind Enemy Lines and the 1864 Capture

This is where the story gets intense. Dr. Walker wasn't just staying in the safe zones. She was known for crossing lines to help civilians and wounded soldiers regardless of which color coat they were wearing.

In April 1864, she bumped into a group of Confederate sentries.

She was captured as a spy. For four months, she was held in Castle Thunder, a notorious Confederate prison in Richmond, Virginia. Think about that for a second. A woman, a doctor, and a staunch abolitionist held in a prison known for its brutal conditions. Most accounts from the time suggest she was a nightmare for her captors. She complained about the food, the hygiene, and the lack of respect. She wouldn't play the "damsel in distress" part.

She was finally traded in a prisoner exchange for a Confederate major. She was literally traded for a man of significant rank. That should tell you everything you need to know about her value.

The Real Reason Behind the Dr. Mary Walker Medal of Honor

After the war, Mary wanted a commission. She wanted the rank she had earned through blood and capture. But the military was still the military. President Andrew Johnson, likely feeling the pressure of her persistence and her undeniable service record, decided to give her a medal instead of a pension or a rank.

On November 11, 1865, he signed the warrant for the Dr. Mary Walker Medal of Honor.

👉 See also: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters

The citation was specific. It didn't mention her killing enemies or charging a hill. It cited her "distinguished service" and her "devotion" during the war. It was a recognition of her being a pioneer. For Mary, it was a badge of legitimacy. For the government, it was a way to make a very loud woman go away.

It didn't work. She became even louder.

The 1917 Purge: Why They Revoked It

By 1917, the rules for the Medal of Honor were changing. The U.S. was entering World War I, and the military wanted to "standardize" the award. They created a Board of Medal of Honor Awards to review every single medal handed out since the Civil War.

They were looking for "actual combat" with an enemy.

Because Mary Walker was a civilian contractor and a woman, they decided she didn't meet the criteria. They revoked her medal, along with 910 others (mostly members of the 27th Maine who had received it for staying past their enlistment).

Imagine being 84 years old, a war veteran, a former prisoner of war, and a lifelong activist, only to have the government tell you that your service was a clerical error.

Mary didn't care. She kept wearing it. She told anyone who would listen that the medal was hers and no one was taking it. She died two years later, a "disgraced" recipient in the eyes of the law, but a hero to everyone who actually knew what she did.

✨ Don't miss: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think

Restoration: The 1977 Correction

It took nearly 60 years and a massive push from her descendants and feminist historians to fix this. In 1977, President Jimmy Carter officially restored the Dr. Mary Walker Medal of Honor.

The Army Board for Correction of Military Records finally admitted that her "acts of distinguished gallantry, self-sacrifice, and intrepidity" were exactly what the medal was meant for. It wasn't about being a "soldier" in the literal sense of carrying a rifle; it was about the bravery she displayed under fire.

Why People Get This Story Wrong

A lot of modern articles paint Mary as a "peaceful healer." That’s only half the truth. Mary was complicated. She was a suffragist who often fought with other suffragists because she thought they were too soft. She insisted on wearing men’s clothing—frock coats and top hats—long before it was acceptable.

People also assume she was awarded the medal just because she was a woman. That’s an insult to the work she did. She was awarded the medal because she did a job no one else wanted to do, in conditions most people couldn't survive, while being treated as a second-class citizen the entire time.


Understanding the Legacy: Takeaways

If you're looking for lessons from Mary Walker’s life, forget the standard "follow your dreams" clichés. Her life was about grit and refusal to comply.

  • Recognition isn't always fair. Mary waited decades for the "official" word to catch up to the reality of her life. If you know you've done the work, don't wait for a committee to tell you it counts.
  • The rules change, but the facts don't. The government changed the criteria for the medal in 1917 to exclude civilians, but that didn't change the fact that Mary treated soldiers under fire in 1863.
  • Stand your ground. When they asked for the medal back, she said no. There is a specific kind of power in refusing to return something that belongs to you.

To truly honor her legacy, don't just read about her. Look into the Mary Walker Clinic or the various veterans' organizations that now carry her name. Her story is a reminder that being the "only" one of something is rarely a comfortable position, but it is often the most necessary one.

Next Steps for History Buffs:
If you want to dive deeper, visit the Oswego County Historical Society website or the National Museum of Civil War Medicine. They house the actual documents regarding her contract and the legal battles over her status. You can also find her personal writings in the Library of Congress, which reveal a woman far more radical and interesting than any short biography can capture.

Stop thinking of her as a footnote. She was the whole book.