Walk into any supermarket in America and you’ll see towers of chicken eggs. Maybe some fancy duck eggs if you're at a high-end co-op. You might even spot tiny, speckled quail eggs sitting near the specialty cheeses. But you will almost never find a carton of turkey eggs. It’s weird, right? Turkeys are everywhere. We eat millions of them every November. They are a staple of the American diet, yet their eggs are practically ghosts in the culinary world.
So, why don't people eat turkey eggs on a regular basis?
It isn't because they taste bad. Honestly, if I served you a turkey egg omelet without telling you, you’d probably just think I used a really high-quality chicken egg. They are creamy. The yolks are huge. They’re actually kind of delicious. The real reason your fridge is empty of them has nothing to do with flavor and everything to do with the cold, hard math of agricultural economics.
The Economics of a Bird That Doesn't Want to Cooperate
Chickens are basically egg-laying machines. A modern Leghorn chicken can crank out 300 eggs a year, sometimes more. They start laying when they are just five months old. It's efficient. It's fast. It's cheap.
Turkeys are a whole different story.
A turkey doesn’t even start laying eggs until it’s about seven or eight months old. Think about the overhead there. You’re feeding a massive bird—and turkeys eat a lot more than chickens—for nearly three-quarters of a year before you get a single return on your investment. Once they do start laying, they aren't exactly prolific. A turkey might give you two eggs a week. Maybe. On a good year, a single turkey produces only about 100 to 120 eggs.
When you do the math, the price per egg becomes astronomical. While a dozen chicken eggs might cost you a few dollars, a single turkey egg often retails for $2 to $3 if you can find them at a local farm. If you wanted a full carton, you’re looking at $25 to $30. Most people just aren't going to pay thirty bucks for breakfast when a three-dollar alternative is sitting right next to it.
📖 Related: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
Space and Temperament Issues
Turkeys are big. They need more room to roam, more robust nesting boxes, and more maintenance than your average backyard hen. Commercial poultry farms are designed for the footprint of a chicken. To produce turkey eggs at scale, you’d need significantly more land and massive infrastructure upgrades.
Then there’s the attitude. Anyone who has spent time around a Heritage breed turkey knows they can be... intense. They have strong maternal instincts. While we’ve bred chickens to basically forget about their eggs once they lay them, turkeys get "broody." They want to sit on those eggs. They want to hatch them. Trying to collect eggs from a protective mother turkey is a lot more taxing than reaching under a docile chicken.
The Industry Priority: Meat Over Breakfast
The turkey industry in the United States is laser-focused on one thing: meat. Because turkeys take so long to mature and lay so few eggs, every egg a turkey does lay is incredibly valuable to a farmer. But not as food.
Every egg represents a potential 20-pound bird.
If a farmer sells a turkey egg to you for $2, they lose the opportunity to raise that turkey and sell it for $50 or $60 during the holiday season. It just doesn't make sense for a commercial hatchery to divert their "stock" to the breakfast table. This is why the entire supply chain for turkeys is built around reproduction for meat production, not for shell egg consumption.
A Taste Comparison: Is There a Difference?
Let’s talk about the actual eating experience. Because if they tasted like liquid gold, maybe we’d pay the $30.
👉 See also: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
A turkey egg is about 50% larger than a large chicken egg. The shell is remarkably tough—you really have to whack it against the counter to get it to crack. Inside, the yolk-to-white ratio is much higher than what you're used to.
- The Yolk: It’s rich. Very rich. Because of the fat content, it has a "velvety" mouthfeel.
- The White: Some people find the whites a bit tougher or "rubbery" if overcooked, but in baking, they are incredible.
- The Flavor: It’s "eggier." If you like the taste of a farm-fresh chicken egg with a deep orange yolk, you’ll love a turkey egg. It’s just... more.
Because of that high fat content in the yolk, turkey eggs are a secret weapon for pastry chefs. They make cakes rise beautifully and give custards a density that chicken eggs struggle to match. But again, for the average person making a quick scramble before work, the difference isn't life-changing enough to justify the hunt or the cost.
Historic Consumption and Cultural Shifts
It wasn't always this way. If you look back at 19th-century cookbooks or agricultural records, you'll see mentions of turkey eggs being eaten more frequently. In rural communities where people kept "barnyard mixes" of poultry, you ate whatever was laid.
But as the 20th century brought the industrialization of food, we chose winners and losers based on efficiency. The chicken won. The turkey was relegated to the "meat bird" category, and the duck became a "niche" bird. Our palates followed the supply chain. We became accustomed to the specific flavor profile and size of chicken eggs, and everything else started to seem "exotic" or "weird."
Why You Won't Find Them in the "Health Food" Aisle
You might think that because turkey eggs are "natural" or "heritage," they’d be marketed as a superfood. Nutritionally, they are quite dense. They have more B12, more Vitamin A, and significantly more iron than chicken eggs.
However, they also have much higher cholesterol. One turkey egg can contain about 700mg of cholesterol, which is more than double the old daily recommended limit. While our understanding of dietary cholesterol has evolved (it’s not the villain it was in the 90s), it still makes it a hard sell for health-conscious marketing.
✨ Don't miss: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think
Where Can You Actually Get Them?
If you’re dying to try one after reading this, don’t go to Whole Foods. You’ll just get a confused look from the stocker.
Your best bet is a local farmers' market or a site like Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace. Small-scale hobby farmers who keep turkeys often have a few extra eggs in the spring. Turkeys are seasonal layers—they mostly lay in the spring and early summer—so don't bother looking in November.
I’ve found that many small farmers are happy to sell them because they don't have the incubator space to hatch every single egg. Just be prepared to pay a premium.
The Future of the Turkey Egg
Is this ever going to change? Probably not.
The biological constraints of the turkey are pretty much set. Unless we genetically engineer a turkey to lay 300 eggs a year (which sounds like a nightmare for the bird), the economics will never balance out for the average consumer. We are stuck in a cycle: no one buys them because they are expensive, and they are expensive because no one buys them at scale.
Actionable Steps for the Curious Foodie
If you really want to experience what a turkey egg brings to the table, here is how you should actually handle it:
- Source Locally in April or May: This is peak laying season. Check local farm groups.
- Check for Freshness: Use the float test just like a chicken egg. If it sinks, it's good.
- The "Single-Egg" Meal: Because they are so big, one turkey egg is often enough for a full serving of fried eggs.
- Bake with Them: If you manage to get three or four, use them in a sponge cake or a rich brioche. The extra lecithin in the large yolks creates a texture you simply cannot get with standard store-bought eggs.
- Don't Overcook: Because the whites are denser, they can get rubbery fast. Cook them low and slow, or poach them to keep that yolk liquid and luxurious.
Basically, turkey eggs aren't missing from our diets because they’re gross. They’re missing because they are a logistical headache for a food system that prizes speed and low costs above all else. They remain a rare, seasonal luxury for those willing to track down a local farmer and pay the "slow food" tax.