You’re sitting at a diner on a random Friday in March, and the "Fish Fry" special is everywhere. Maybe you grew up with it. Maybe you just noticed that your Catholic friends suddenly become very interested in Filet-O-Fish sandwiches once a year. If you’ve ever wondered why don't Catholics eat meat on Fridays, the answer isn't just a quirky dietary habit or a secret deal with the fishing industry. It’s actually a mix of ancient theology, a specific way of honoring a death, and a long-standing tradition of "penance" that has shifted quite a bit over the centuries.
Honestly, it’s about Friday. Specifically, Good Friday.
In the Christian tradition, Friday is the day Jesus was crucified. For the early Church, it didn't feel right to feast on the day their savior died. So, they fasted. But "fasting" back then wasn't just skipping a snack; it was a hardcore communal grieving process. Eventually, that evolved into a specific ban on the flesh of warm-blooded animals.
The Flesh vs. The Fish: What’s the Logic?
Why meat? Why not chocolate or wine?
The distinction comes from a few places. First, there’s the symbolic link. Meat—specifically "carne" or the flesh of mammals and birds—is associated with festivals and celebrations. You kill the fatted calf when the prodigal son returns; you don't do it when you're in mourning. By giving up meat, Catholics were essentially putting themselves in a state of "mini-mourning" every single week.
There is also a deeper, more biological reasoning that the medieval Church leaned on. They viewed the meat of land animals as "hot" or "libidinous." Essentially, people believed eating beef or chicken increased your lust. Since Friday was a day for spiritual discipline, eating something "cool" like fish was thought to keep the soul a bit more level-headed. St. Thomas Aquinas actually touches on this in his Summa Theologica, noting that meat provides more nourishment to the body and therefore more "incentive to lust" than fish does.
Interestingly, the definition of "meat" got pretty weird.
In some parts of the world, if it lived in the water, it was fair game. This led to some hilarious loopholes. For instance, in 17th-century Quebec, the Bishop actually asked if beaver could be considered a fish because it was a great swimmer. The Church said yes. In Venezuela, capybaras—the world’s largest rodents—are often eaten on Fridays during Lent for the same reason. They spend time in the water, so, in the eyes of a hungry 18th-century monk, they were basically weird-looking fish.
✨ Don't miss: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
The Shift in the 1960s
Most people think the "no meat" rule only applies during Lent, the 40 days before Easter. That’s a common mistake.
Actually, for centuries, it was every Friday. Every single one. If you were a Catholic in 1950, you weren't touching a burger on a Friday in July, let alone during Lent. But things changed with Pope Paul VI and the Second Vatican Council.
In 1966, the document Paenitemini was released. The Church realized that in a modern, globalized world, a blanket ban on meat might not be the most meaningful way for everyone to practice self-denial. In many places, fish had become a luxury item, more expensive than a cheap chicken wing. If you’re "sacrificing" by eating a $40 lobster tail instead of a $5 hamburger, you’ve kinda missed the point of penance.
So, the rules loosened. In many countries, including the United States, the USCCB (United States Conference of Catholic Bishops) decided that outside of Lent, Catholics could choose their own form of penance. You could skip meat, sure. But you could also give up soda, or spend an hour volunteering, or pray a Rosary. The obligation to do something remained, but the meat part became optional for the majority of the year.
However, during Lent? The meat ban is still a hard rule.
Why don't Catholics eat meat on Fridays during Lent specifically?
Lent is the "major leagues" of the Catholic liturgical year. It’s a season of intense preparation. Because of this, the Church keeps the universal law of abstinence (no meat) on all Fridays of Lent for everyone over the age of 14.
It’s a communal act. There’s something powerful about millions of people across the globe all deciding to skip the pepperoni on their pizza at the same time. It creates a sense of identity. It’s also a physical reminder. Every time your stomach rumbles for a chicken nugget on a Friday in March, you’re supposed to be reminded of why you’re doing it—to focus on spiritual hunger rather than physical satisfaction.
🔗 Read more: Bird Feeders on a Pole: What Most People Get Wrong About Backyard Setups
The "Fish Fry" culture that emerged from this is massive, especially in the American Midwest. Cities like Milwaukee, Pittsburgh, and St. Louis turn into fish-frying hubs. It’s a social event. You go to the parish hall, sit at a folding table, and eat fried cod with a bunch of strangers. It’s one of the few times ancient religious law creates a massive boom for local economies and social cohesion.
Common Misconceptions and the "Fish Industry" Myth
You might have heard the conspiracy theory that a Pope once had a secret deal with the fishing industry to boost sales.
It’s a fun story. It's also completely false.
While the fishing industry certainly benefited from the "Meatless Friday" rule, there is zero historical evidence of a "Big Fish" lobby influencing Vatican policy in the Middle Ages. The practice predates any kind of organized international fish trade. It grew out of the Jewish tradition of fasting and the early Christian desire to mark the day of the Passion.
Another misconception: "I can't eat anything all day."
Actually, that’s fasting, not abstinence.
- Abstinence: Not eating meat. This applies to all Fridays in Lent.
- Fasting: Eating only one full meal and two smaller snacks. This only applies to Ash Wednesday and Good Friday.
So, on a regular Lenten Friday, you can eat three full meals of cheese pizza or shrimp scampi. You just can't have the steak.
Expert Nuance: Is it even a sacrifice anymore?
This is where contemporary theologians get into heated debates.
💡 You might also like: Barn Owl at Night: Why These Silent Hunters Are Creepier (and Cooler) Than You Think
If you love sushi, is "abstaining from meat" by eating a $60 yellowtail platter really a penance? Probably not. The spirit of the law is meant to be ascetical—it’s supposed to cost you something. If you aren't a meat-eater to begin with, the Church actually suggests you find something else to give up that actually feels like a sacrifice.
The goal isn't just to follow a checklist. It's to cultivate a "poverty of spirit."
Actionable Takeaways for Observance
If you are looking to follow this tradition or just want to understand the practice better, here is how it actually works in a modern context:
1. Know the age limits. The law of abstinence from meat applies to Catholics who are 14 years of age and older. There is no upper age limit. If you're 90, you're still skipping the bacon.
2. Check the calendar. In the U.S., you are required to abstain from meat on Ash Wednesday and every Friday of Lent. For the rest of the year, you are encouraged to abstain, but you can technically substitute it with another form of penance.
3. Define "Meat." Meat is considered the flesh and organs of mammals and fowl. This includes beef, pork, chicken, turkey, and lamb. It also includes salt pork or suet used in cooking.
What's allowed?
- Fish and shellfish (shrimp, crab, lobster).
- Amphibians (frogs).
- Reptiles (alligator, though this is mostly a Louisiana thing).
- Eggs and dairy products (butter, cheese, milk).
4. The "Solemnity" Exception. Here is a pro-tip: if a major Church feast (called a Solemnity) falls on a Friday, the requirement to abstain from meat is actually canceled. For example, if St. Joseph’s Day (March 19) or the Annunciation (March 25) lands on a Friday, you can legally fire up the grill. The Church views these feast days as so important that they override the penitential nature of the Friday.
5. Focus on the "Why." If you find yourself getting legalistic about whether or not chicken broth counts (it generally does, as it's not "flesh"), you might be missing the forest for the trees. The point is a simple, humble gesture of self-denial.
The next time Friday rolls around and you see the local church basement filling up with people smelling like tartar sauce, you'll know exactly what's going on. It’s not just about the food. It’s a 2,000-year-old "thank you" expressed through a menu.