Honestly, the year 2000 was a weird time for Disney fans. It was the peak of the "Cheapquel" era, that specific window where Disney’s home video department was churning out direct-to-video sequels faster than we could keep up with them. Disney The Little Mermaid 2: Return to the Sea was one of the big ones. It wasn’t just a random sequel; it was the follow-up to the movie that literally saved Disney animation in 1989. People had expectations. High ones.
Most people remember it as the "reverse" of the first movie. Instead of a mermaid wanting to be human, we got Melody, Ariel’s daughter, who is a human desperately wishing she was a mermaid. It’s ironic. Kinda poetic, if you think about it. But for a lot of critics and hardcore fans of the original Ron Clements and John Musker masterpiece, the sequel felt like a massive step down in terms of animation quality and narrative weight.
Yet, here we are decades later, and Melody has a massive cult following. Why? Because the movie tapped into something very real about parental anxiety and the cycle of family secrets.
The Polarizing Legacy of Disney The Little Mermaid 2
When you look at the technical side of things, the difference is jarring. The 1989 original had that lush, hand-painted feel with incredible effects animation for the water. Return to the Sea was produced primarily by Disney Television Animation and Disney Animation Canada. You can see the difference in the line work. It’s thinner. The colors are flatter.
But if you ask a kid who grew up in the early 2000s, they don't care about the frame rate or the ink-and-paint process. They care about Melody.
Melody is probably the most relatable "Disney Princess" offspring because she’s a total social outcast. She talks to a crab. She's awkward. She doesn't fit in at the palace. It’s a very different vibe from Ariel’s rebellious but confident nature. Ariel wanted to explore a world she wasn't part of; Melody wants to belong to a world she was born from but kept away from by her own mother.
There is a deep irony in Ariel becoming the "King Triton" of this movie. She becomes the overprotective parent who builds a wall—literally—to keep her child away from the sea. She does it out of love and fear of Morgana, Ursula’s sister, but it’s the exact same mistake her father made. It’s a cycle of trauma. That’s actually a pretty heavy theme for a movie that features a comedic duo consisting of a penguin and a walrus.
The Villain Problem: Morgana vs. Ursula
We have to talk about Morgana. Voiced by the legendary Pat Carroll, who also voiced Ursula, Morgana is a fascinating mess. She’s written with this massive inferiority complex. She’s not just trying to take over the ocean; she’s trying to live up to the shadow of her "much more talented" sister.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
"My sister was the one they loved! I was the one they ignored!"
That’s basically her entire motivation. It makes her less threatening than Ursula but way more neurotic. Some fans find her annoying, while others appreciate the "second-child syndrome" energy she brings to the table. She’s thinner, frailer, and lacks that grand, theatrical confidence Ursula had. She’s a different kind of scary—the kind that comes from desperation.
Why the Music Actually Hits Harder Than You Remember
You probably can't hum the entire soundtrack, but "For a Moment" is a legitimate banger. It’s a duet between Ariel and Melody, though they aren't singing to each other in the same space. Ariel is singing about her regret and her fear of the ocean, while Melody is finally experiencing the joy of being a mermaid for the first time.
The songwriting team, including Michael and Patty Silversher, had a nearly impossible task. How do you follow Alan Menken and Howard Ashman? You don't. You just try to stay in the same lane.
The song "Down to the Sea" is a massive opening number that tries to capture the Broadway scale of the first film. It’s grand. It’s sweeping. It introduces the conflict immediately. Does it have the lyrical genius of "Part of Your World"? No. But it works for what it is.
The real heart of the film is the voice acting. Jodi Benson returned as Ariel, and she brings a maternal warmth that feels like a natural evolution of the character. Tara Strong, the voice of Melody, is a legend in the industry (you know her as Bubbles from Powerpuff Girls or Raven from Teen Titans). She perfectly captures that crackly, teenage uncertainty. Their chemistry makes the movie watchable even when the plot feels a bit like a re-tread.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Plot
A common criticism of Disney The Little Mermaid 2 is that it makes Ariel look like a hypocrite. People say, "How could she forget how much she hated being kept from the surface?"
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
But that’s actually the most realistic part of the movie.
Parents often overcorrect. Ariel didn't keep Melody from the sea because she thought the sea was "bad." She did it because a literal sea witch threatened to kidnap her baby. That’s a very different context than Triton’s general prejudice against humans. Ariel’s motivation is pure survival instinct, which makes her eventual realization and apology to Melody at the end of the film actually quite moving.
The movie also gives us a look at Eric as a dad. In the first movie, Eric was... well, he was a handsome guy with a dog. In the sequel, he’s a supportive partner. He trusts Ariel’s judgment but also gently pushes her to tell Melody the truth. He’s one of the few Disney princes who actually gets to do some "parenting" on screen.
The Direct-to-Video Technical Constraints
To understand why the movie looks the way it does, you have to look at the business model of Disney in the late 90s and early 2000s. These movies weren't meant for theaters. They were meant to sell VHS tapes and DVDs to parents at Blockbuster.
- Budget: These sequels usually had a fraction of the budget of the theatrical releases.
- Timeline: They were produced on much shorter schedules, often by international satellite studios.
- Frame Rate: You'll notice the movement is less fluid. There are fewer "drawings per second" compared to the 1989 film.
Despite these constraints, the team at Disney Animation Canada did some impressive work with the character designs. Melody feels like a perfect 50/50 split between Ariel and Eric. She has Eric’s hair color and eyebrows but Ariel’s eyes and spirit.
Is It Canon?
This is the big question for Disney theorists. With the 2023 live-action remake of The Little Mermaid starring Halle Bailey, the "canon" has shifted. The live-action film is its own universe. Return to the Sea belongs strictly to the 1989 animated timeline.
In the 1989 timeline, the order is:
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
- The Little Mermaid: Ariel’s Beginning (The prequel)
- The Little Mermaid (The TV series)
- The Little Mermaid (The original movie)
- The Little Mermaid 2: Return to the Sea
If you try to fit them all together, there are some continuity errors—mostly regarding how many sisters Ariel has and their names—but for the most part, the sequel acts as the definitive ending for Ariel's story. It completes her journey from a girl who wanted to leave her world to a queen who successfully united two worlds.
Critical Reception and Modern Re-evaluation
When it dropped on September 19, 2000, critics were pretty harsh. They called it a "watered-down" version of the original. Rotten Tomatoes still has it sitting at a pretty low score.
But look at TikTok or Instagram today. You'll find thousands of "Melody core" aesthetic videos. There’s a whole generation of women who saw Melody as their first representation of a "clumsy, tomboyish" girl who didn't fit the traditional princess mold. She wore a baggy t-shirt over her swimsuit. she was messy. She was real.
The "Tip and Dash" duo (the penguin and the walrus) are often cited as the weakest part of the movie. They are clearly trying to fill the shoes of Timon and Pumbaa, but the humor is a bit more "Saturday morning cartoon" than "Disney classic." Even so, their song about being "Tip and Dash" is catchy enough to get stuck in your head for days.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you're looking to revisit this movie or introduce it to a new generation, here are a few things to keep in mind to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch for the Voice Continuity: Pay close attention to Jodi Benson’s performance. She recorded her lines for this around the same time she was doing other Ariel projects, and her consistency is what anchors the film to the original.
- Check the Aspect Ratio: If you’re watching on Disney+, the movie is presented in high definition, which actually makes some of the animation flaws more apparent than they were on an old tube TV. It’s a fascinating look at the "digital ink and paint" transition era.
- Skip the "Ariel's Beginning" Prequel First: If you're doing a marathon, watch the movies in release order, not chronological order. The jump in animation quality from the 2008 prequel back to the 2000 sequel can be very jarring.
- Focus on the Mother-Daughter Arc: Instead of comparing it to the epic romance of the first film, watch it as a story about communication. It makes the ending where the wall is torn down much more symbolic of breaking down emotional barriers.
- Look for the Easter Eggs: There are small nods to the first movie’s animation sequences, especially during the "For a Moment" sequence, that pay homage to Ariel's original "Part of Your World" movements.
Disney The Little Mermaid 2 might not be a "perfect" movie, but it’s a fascinating piece of Disney history. It represents a specific era of the company’s growth and a unique take on what happens after the "Happily Ever After." Whether you love it for the nostalgia or pick it apart for the animation, there’s no denying that Melody has earned her place in the Disney pantheon.
The movie serves as a reminder that even when we try to protect the people we love by hiding the truth, the truth has a way of coming to the surface—literally. It’s a story about embracing your heritage, even the parts that are messy, scaly, or dangerous. In the end, Melody didn't have to choose between the land and the sea; she just had to find a way to be herself in both.