Movies based on theme park rides are a weird gamble. You’ve got Pirates of the Caribbean, which basically printed money for a decade, and then you’ve got the others. Honestly, the Haunted Mansion movie is the one Disney keeps trying to "fix," yet it feels like they’re chasing a ghost they can’t quite catch. Whether we are talking about the 2003 Eddie Murphy version or the 2023 reboot directed by Justin Simien, there is this bizarre tension between being a family comedy and a genuine gothic horror.
It’s a tough tightrope.
The original 1969 attraction in Disneyland wasn't even sure what it wanted to be. Walt Disney himself saw various iterations—some scary, some whimsical—before it finally opened. That internal conflict is baked into the DNA of the ride, which explains why every Haunted Mansion movie feels a bit disjointed. Fans want the "Grim Grinning Ghosts" singing at a tea party, but they also want the genuine dread of the Stretching Room.
The 2003 Experiment: A Product of Its Time
Look back at 2003. Rob Minkoff, who directed The Lion King, was at the helm. This was the same year Pirates launched, so expectations were through the roof. But instead of a swashbuckling epic, we got a slapstick comedy centered on real estate. Eddie Murphy played Jim Evers, a workaholic dad. It’s a very "early 2000s" trope.
The production design was actually incredible. Rick Baker, a legend in makeup effects, handled the zombies in the mausoleum. If you watch it today, those practical effects still hold up better than half the CGI we see in modern blockbusters. Yet, the movie sits at a dismal 13% on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics hated the tone. It felt like a sitcom set in a graveyard. For many of us who grew up with it, there is a massive nostalgia factor, but objectively? It missed the mark on the ride's atmospheric creepiness.
✨ Don't miss: Danny Gokey Mary Did You Know: Why This Version Hits Differently
Why the 2023 Haunted Mansion Movie Changed the Game (Sorta)
Fast forward twenty years. Disney tries again. This time, they recruited Justin Simien, who actually worked at Disneyland once. You can tell he loves the source material. The 2023 Haunted Mansion movie is packed with "Easter eggs." We see the Hatbox Ghost (played by Jared Leto), the Bride (Constance Hatchaway), and even the specific wallpaper patterns from the hallway.
The plot shifted to something much deeper: grief. LaKeith Stanfield plays Ben, an astrophysicist who lost his wife and now leads "ghost tours" he doesn't believe in. It’s heavy.
One major issue was the release date. Disney put this movie out in July. Why? It’s a Halloween movie through and through. By the time October rolled around and people actually wanted to see spooky stuff, it was already leaving theaters or heading to Disney+. This scheduling choice is often cited by industry analysts as a primary reason the film struggled to find its footing at the box office despite a star-studded cast including Jamie Lee Curtis and Danny DeVito.
The Del Toro "What If" That Haunts Fans
We have to talk about Guillermo del Toro. Around 2010, the legendary director announced he was developing a Haunted Mansion movie. For horror nerds, this was the dream. Del Toro is the master of "beautiful monsters." He wanted it to be scary. He wanted the Hatbox Ghost to be a pivotal, terrifying figure.
Unfortunately, it languished in "development hell" for years. Disney reportedly felt his vision was too dark for a PG rating. They wanted a four-quadrant family film; he wanted a gothic nightmare. While elements of his influence supposedly lingered in later scripts, we will likely never see the true Del Toro version. This highlights the core problem: Disney is terrified of actually scaring children, but you can't have a truly great haunted house movie without some genuine stakes.
Breaking Down the Visuals and Practical Effects
The 2023 version used a mix of massive physical sets and "The Volume" (the LED screen technology used in The Mandalorian). The Gracey Manor was built to feel expansive yet claustrophobic.
- The Stretching Room: Recreated with a moving floor to mimic the ride experience.
- The Doom Buggy: Reimagined as a physical chair that Ben uses to navigate the spectral realm.
- Madame Leota: Jamie Lee Curtis performed inside a literal crystal ball rig to get the proportions right.
The 2003 film relied more on massive soundstages at Disney Studios. The "Great Hall" set was one of the largest ever built at the time. When you compare them, the 2003 version feels more like a stage play, while the 2023 version feels like a lived-in, decaying estate.
🔗 Read more: Why the Lyrics Where I Come From Montgomery Gentry Still Hit Home Twenty Years Later
What Most People Get Wrong About the Lore
People often think the Haunted Mansion movie has to follow a specific "story" from the ride. But the ride doesn't have a linear plot! It’s a series of vignettes. This gives writers too much freedom. Should it be about Master Gracey’s lost love? Or the murderous Bride in the attic?
In the 2023 film, they introduced the concept of "ghosts following you home." This is a direct nod to the "Hitchhiking Ghosts" at the end of the attraction. It’s a clever way to expand the stakes beyond the walls of the house. However, casual viewers who haven't been to the parks often find these references confusing or random. To a fan, a floating candelabra is iconic; to a general audience member, it’s just a floating light.
The Financial Reality
The 2023 film had a budget of roughly $150 million. It earned about $117 million worldwide. In Hollywood terms, that's a "flop." But looking at the streaming numbers, it found a massive second life. It turns out people love watching ghost movies in their living rooms during October.
This suggests that the Haunted Mansion movie isn't a bad property—it’s just a misunderstood one. It’s a seasonal "vibe" rather than a summer tentpole. Disney’s mistake wasn't the movie itself; it was the strategy behind it.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Night
If you are planning to dive into these films, here is how to actually enjoy them without getting bogged down in the "is it a flop?" discourse:
1. Watch them in the right order. Start with the 2003 version for a lighthearted, goofy evening. It’s great for younger kids who might find the newer one too intense. Then, move to the 2023 version for a more emotional, visually stunning experience.
🔗 Read more: Who is the Real Satan in Dear Santa? Explaining the Jack Black Twist
2. Look for the "Ghost Host." Neither movie features the iconic narrator in the way the ride does, but the 2023 film incorporates his lines into the dialogue. Listen closely to the character descriptions—they’re all pulled from the original Imagineering scripts.
3. Check out the "Behind the Attraction" series on Disney+. There is an entire episode dedicated to how the mansion was built. Watching this before the movies makes you appreciate the set design 100% more. You’ll notice things like the "bat" stanchions and the specific purple wallpaper that you’d otherwise miss.
4. Skip the 2021 Muppets version... unless you love puns. Muppets Haunted Mansion is actually surprisingly faithful to the ride's spirit, but it's a 50-minute special, not a feature film. It’s the "hidden gem" of the franchise if you want something short and funny.
The Haunted Mansion movie legacy is complicated. It's a mix of corporate branding, genuine fan love, and a struggle to define what "scary" means for a family audience. While we might not have the "perfect" version yet, the 2023 attempt got us closer than ever by finally acknowledging that a ghost story needs a little bit of heart—and a lot of grief—to feel real.