February 11, 2013, was supposed to be a boring Monday at the Vatican. A few cardinals were gathered for a routine meeting about some new saints. Then, Pope Benedict XVI started speaking in Latin. Most people in the room weren't really leaning in until he hit the words ingravescente aetate—basically, "advanced age."
He was quitting.
The room went silent. A journalist for the Italian agency ANSA, Giovanna Chirri, was the only one who realized what was happening immediately because she actually understood the Latin. She rushed to file the story, and the world broke. We hadn't seen a pope walk away in nearly 600 years. It just didn't happen.
Naturally, the vacuum of information was filled with every conspiracy theory you can imagine. People talked about the Vatileaks scandal, the "Gay Lobby" inside the Curia, and even blackmail. But now that we’re over a decade out from that moment, and since Benedict’s passing in late 2022, the real picture has finally come into focus. It wasn't one big, dramatic secret. It was a slow, exhausting burn.
The "Central Motive" We Didn't Know About
For years, people rolled their eyes at the "health reasons" excuse. He looked frail, sure, but he didn't look dying. After all, he lived for another ten years as Pope Emeritus.
👉 See also: The Station Nightclub Fire and Great White: Why It’s Still the Hardest Lesson in Rock History
But in 2023, his biographer Peter Seewald went public with a letter Benedict had sent him shortly before his death. In it, Benedict admitted the "central motive" was something much more mundane but devastating: insomnia.
It sounds like a minor thing until you’re 85 and running a global institution with a billion followers. Benedict had been on "strong remedies"—sleeping pills—since World Youth Day in Cologne back in 2005. By 2012, those pills had "reached their limits." He was basically a walking ghost, unable to get the rest his brain needed to process the massive complexities of the Church.
The Mexico Incident
There was a specific turning point. In March 2012, during a trip to Mexico and Cuba, Benedict woke up to find his handkerchief "blood-soaked." He’d fallen in the bathroom during the night and hit his head, and he didn't even remember doing it.
His doctor gave him an ultimatum: no more transatlantic flights.
✨ Don't miss: The Night the Mountain Fell: What Really Happened During the Big Thompson Flood 1976
This was a massive problem. World Youth Day 2013 was scheduled for Rio de Janeiro. Benedict knew he couldn't go, and he didn't believe the Church should be led by a "virtual" pope on a TV screen. He felt he was holding the seat for someone who actually had the "vigor of body and mind" to be there in person.
It Wasn’t Just the Body
Honestly, Benedict was never a "politician" pope. He was a bookworm. A brilliant, shy academic who spent his life in libraries and lecture halls. When he was elected at 78, he actually hoped for a short reign. He wanted to go back to his books.
Instead, he inherited a mess.
- Vatileaks: His own butler, Paolo Gabriele, was stealing private documents from the Pope’s desk and leaking them to the press. It revealed a Vatican bureaucracy that was, frankly, a viper’s nest of infighting and power struggles.
- The Abuse Scandals: While Benedict had actually done more than his predecessors to defrock abusive priests, the sheer weight of the ongoing revelations was crushing.
- The "Rottweiler" Reputation: The media often painted him as this harsh, rigid enforcer (the "Panzerkardinal"), which was the opposite of his actual personality. That disconnect takes a psychological toll.
His personal secretary, Archbishop Georg Gänswein, later said that Benedict didn't resign because of these scandals. He resigned because he felt he didn't have the strength to fix them. He didn't want to be a passive observer while the "Barque of Peter" took on water.
🔗 Read more: The Natascha Kampusch Case: What Really Happened in the Girl in the Cellar True Story
The Shadow of John Paul II
You have to remember who Benedict followed. Pope John Paul II’s decline was public and agonizing. He stayed in the Chair of Peter until his very last breath, unable to speak or walk.
Benedict saw that up close. He was JPII's right-hand man. And he reached a different theological conclusion. He didn't think the papacy should be a slow-motion martyrdom if you could no longer "adequately fulfill the ministry." He chose a modern, practical path over the traditional "suffer until the end" model.
It was a "revolutionary act," as Gänswein called it. It turned the papacy from a life sentence into a job—a holy one, but still a job that requires a certain level of performance.
What This Means for You Today
The reason why did pope benedict xvi resign still matters is because it changed the rules for everyone who comes next. Pope Francis has already signed a resignation letter "just in case" his health fails. The taboo is gone.
Key Takeaways:
- Physical limits are real: Even for a Pope. Chronic exhaustion and insomnia were the primary drivers.
- Leadership is about fitness: Benedict believed the Church deserved someone who could keep up with the 21st century's "rapid changes."
- The office is bigger than the man: By stepping down, he proved that the papacy isn't a personality cult.
If you’re interested in the deep history of how the Vatican operates under pressure, you might want to look into the official Declaratio Benedict read that morning. It’s a masterclass in concise, humble communication. You can also track the changes Pope Francis has made to the "Pope Emeritus" rules to see how the Church is still trying to figure out how to handle having two men in white living in the same garden.