It was June 25, 2013. If you were a fan of YouTube’s burgeoning Let’s Play scene back then, you remember exactly where you were when the "Ode to Jon" video dropped. It was short. It was weird. It felt like a breakup text from a guy you’d been dating for a year. Suddenly, the chaotic, high-energy duo of Arin Hanson and Jon Jafari was over. Just like that. No warning, no long goodbye tour. One day they’re playing Sonic '06 and screaming about Garshtosteles, and the next, Dan Avidan is sitting on the couch.
Naturally, the internet did what it does best: it spiraled.
The question of why did JonTron leave Game Grumps became the "Who Shot J.R.?" of the gaming world. For years, the silence from both camps was deafening. You’d watch new episodes, and it was like Jon never existed. His name was scrubbed. The "Not-So-Grump" head in the intro changed. It felt clinical. It felt corporate. And because there was a vacuum of information, fans filled it with some of the wildest conspiracies you’ve ever heard.
The Official Story vs. The Reality
The "official" reason given at the time was simple: Jon wanted to focus on his own show, JonTron.
If you look at the timeline, it sort of makes sense. During his year on Game Grumps, the JonTron channel had slowed down to a crawl. Producing a high-quality, scripted review show while recording daily unscripted gaming sessions is a massive workload. Jon has stated in various livestreams and interviews—most notably a SleepyCast episode years later—that the show started to feel like a "job." He missed the creative control of his solo work. He wanted to move to New York to be with his girlfriend and start a new chapter.
But fans didn't buy that it was only that. Why? Because of how abruptly it happened.
You don't just walk away from a massive, revenue-generating brand mid-series unless there's some friction. Usually, there’s a transition period. A hand-off. Instead, we got a "he’s gone, here’s Dan, also check out our new show Steam Train" all in the same breath. It felt like a corporate pivot, not a friendly parting of ways.
The "Fartners" and the Business of Grumps
One thing people often overlook is that Game Grumps wasn't just two dudes on a couch; it was becoming a business. Arin Hanson, or Egoraptor, has always had a more "professional" mindset when it comes to brand building. He wanted to expand. He wanted editors, offices, and merchandise.
Jon? Jon was a wild card.
There have been long-standing rumors, fueled by bits and pieces of info from people like the "Continue?" crew and various Reddit sleuths, that a "management" conflict was the real breaking point. The story goes that Arin was making the big business decisions—the "fartner" at the bank, as they once joked—and Jon felt like he was losing his voice in his own creation.
Basically, it’s the classic "art vs. commerce" struggle. Arin wanted to build an empire; Jon just wanted to make funny videos and keep his autonomy. When you’ve got two stubborn, creative personalities in a room for 12 hours a week, someone is going to snap.
👉 See also: Terminal Call of Duty Map: Why We Can't Stop Playing It After 15 Years
The Conspiracies: From Slaps to NDAs
For a long time, the "Subreddit That Must Not Be Named" (r/ConspiracyGrumps) was the hub for every crackpot theory under the sun. Did Jon slap Suzy (Arin's wife)? That was a big one. It was entirely baseless, yet it persisted for years because neither side would address it.
The most likely reality is far less dramatic but much more legally complicated.
It’s widely believed that Jon and Arin signed a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) during the split. This would explain why Arin refused to mention Jon’s name for years. It wasn't necessarily because they hated each other—though things were definitely rocky—but because they had to legally disentangle their business interests.
Think about it. If you’re Arin, you’ve just lost your co-founder. You need the brand to survive. If you keep talking about the "old guy," you’re making it harder for the "new guy" (Dan) to be accepted. You have to kill the past to save the future. It’s cold, sure. But from a business perspective, it worked.
Evidence of a Falling Out
While they eventually made up (we’ll get to that), there’s no denying they weren't on speaking terms for a while.
- The Scrubbing: Old videos weren't deleted, but the "Jon era" was never referenced.
- The "Dishonesty" Comments: In some early post-Grumps livestreams, Jon alluded to "dishonesty" and things not being as they seemed.
- The 2015 Reunion: The first real proof they were okay was a photo of them together at MagFest in 2015.
That photo was like a weight lifting off the community’s chest. They weren't best friends anymore, but they weren't enemies. Arin even eventually appeared in the finale of Jon’s StarCade series as Darth Vader. It was a brief, wordless cameo, but it meant everything to fans who had been mourning the friendship.
Why the Controversy Matters
You might wonder why we’re still talking about something that happened over a decade ago. It matters because it changed the trajectory of YouTube. Game Grumps under Jon was experimental, edgy, and totally unscripted. It felt like "lightning in a bottle."
When Dan Avidan joined, the show became something else. It became "comfort food." It became more consistent, more professional, and honestly, more successful. But that transition left a scar on the fanbase. It was the first time "YouTube Parasocial Relationships" really collided with "Business Reality." We felt like we were part of their friend group, so when one friend "left" without a good explanation, it felt like a betrayal.
Honestly, if Jon had stayed, Game Grumps probably wouldn't be around today. His style was too volatile for the modern, advertiser-friendly YouTube landscape. Arin’s vision for a stable, long-term brand is what kept the lights on.
The Aftermath and Modern Context
Since leaving, Jon's career has been... complicated. He moved into high-production comedy, which is what he always wanted. However, he also became a lightning rod for controversy due to his political comments in a 2017 debate with streamer Destiny.
Interestingly, these controversies actually made the "Game Grumps Split" look different in hindsight. Some fans started to argue that Arin "saw the writing on the wall" and distanced the brand from Jon before things got messy. There’s no evidence for that—the timeline doesn't really fit—but it’s a narrative that has taken root in the fandom.
What Can We Learn From the Split?
Looking back at why JonTron left Game Grumps, the lesson isn't about secret fights or dramatic betrayals. It's about growth and the reality of creative partnerships.
- Creative Alignment is Key: You can be best friends with someone, but that doesn't mean you can run a business together.
- Communication Prevents Conspiracies: The "silent treatment" approach might have been legally necessary, but it fueled years of toxicity in the community.
- Transitions Are Hard: Dan Avidan had the hardest job on the internet in 2013, and the fact that he won over the "Lovelies" is a testament to his personality.
If you’re looking for a smoking gun, you’re probably not going to find one. The "real" reason is a messy mixture of creative burnout, a desire for a different lifestyle, and the growing pains of a small channel turning into a multi-million dollar company.
To get the most out of this history, you should check out the "Ode to Jon" video again, but this time, look at it through the lens of a business announcement rather than a personal one. You can also watch Jon’s StarCade finale to see the moment the "cold war" officially ended. It’s a fascinating look at how digital celebrities navigate the bridge between being "friends" and being "colleagues."
The best way to respect the legacy of that era is to appreciate the content they made together—like the Kirby Super Star series or the legendary Sonic '06 run—without needing them to be the same people they were in 2012. People grow, they move to New York, and sometimes, they just want to stop being "Grump."