New York City’s dining scene is basically a revolving door of concepts that try way too hard to be "global" or "fusion" or whatever the buzzword of the week happens to be. But every once in a while, a place comes along that does something so specific, so localized, and so stubbornly authentic that it changes the way people think about American food. Delaware and Hudson NYC was exactly that kind of place.
If you weren't hanging out in Williamsburg during its peak run, you might have missed it. That’s a shame. It wasn't just another Brooklyn bistro. It was a love letter to the Mid-Atlantic, a region that gets overshadowed by the flashy seafood of New England or the heavy-hitting soul food of the South.
Chef Patti Jackson didn’t just cook; she curated a menu that felt like a history lesson you actually wanted to attend.
What Made Delaware and Hudson NYC Different
Most people think of "regional American" and their minds go straight to BBQ or clam chowder. Jackson looked at the map between the Delaware River and the Hudson Valley and saw something else. She saw the influence of Pennsylvania Dutch heritage, the Baltimore waterfront, and the fertile farms of New York.
It was a Michelin-starred spot that didn't feel like a Michelin-starred spot.
Walking in felt like stepping into a cozy tavern. It was small. Dimly lit. The wood was dark, and the atmosphere was thick with the smell of roasting meats and seasonal vegetables. You didn't find foams or gels here. Instead, you found pretzel rolls served with beer cheese and snapper soup that would make a Philadelphian cry.
The Pennsylvania Dutch Connection
Jackson grew up in Northeastern Pennsylvania. That's the secret sauce. You can’t fake that kind of culinary DNA.
💡 You might also like: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
The menu was a rotation of things like "Schenckels" (basically fried dough) and incredible sausages. She brought a level of refinement to "peasant food" that New York hadn't really seen before. It wasn't about elevating the food—which is a condescending term chefs love to use—it was about honoring it.
- The Cider-Glazed Pork Belly was a staple.
- The Funnel Cakes weren't the greasy carnival versions; they were light, airy, and topped with seasonal fruit preserves.
- Lady Baltimore Cake made a rare appearance on the dessert menu, proving that forgotten American classics still have a place on modern plates.
Honestly, the way she handled starches was a masterclass. Potato filling—a traditional dish from her home region—became a revelation for diners who thought they knew everything there was to know about spuds.
Why the Michelin Star Mattered
In 2015, Delaware and Hudson NYC earned its first Michelin star. This was a huge deal for a few reasons. First, the price point was actually accessible. You could do a four-course tasting menu for around $50 back then. In NYC, that’s practically a rounding error at some of the midtown power spots.
Second, it validated the idea that regional American "comfort food" was technically complex. Getting a Michelin inspector to care about scrapple is a feat of strength.
The restaurant proved that you didn't need white tablecloths or a French-trained brigade to be world-class. You just needed a clear point of view and a relentless commitment to sourcing. Jackson worked with farmers who were actually growing the heritage crops of the Mid-Atlantic. This wasn't "farm-to-table" as a marketing slogan. It was farm-to-table as a necessity.
The Layout and the Vibe
The space was divided into two distinct parts: the tavern and the dining room.
📖 Related: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
The tavern was for the casuals. You’d grab a craft beer—usually something from a local brewery like Ommegang or Victory—and eat some snacks. The dining room was where the fixed-price magic happened. It was an intimate setup. Maybe 30 seats total? It created this sense of being part of a private club, but without the snootiness.
One thing that always stood out was the lack of ego.
You’d often see Jackson in the kitchen, actually cooking. In an era of "celebrity chefs" who are rarely behind the line, that meant something. The consistency was terrifyingly good. You knew that if you ordered the fried chicken, it was going to be exactly the same level of crunchy-salty-juicy as it was six months ago.
The Legacy of the Mid-Atlantic Menu
When we talk about Delaware and Hudson NYC today, we’re talking about a lost art.
The restaurant eventually closed its doors in 2018. It was a gut punch to the neighborhood. But its influence is everywhere now. You see "Mid-Atlantic" popping up on menus across the country. Chefs are finally realizing that the corridor between DC and Albany is a goldmine of flavor.
- Heritage Grains: Jackson was using local flours before it was cool.
- Preservation: The pickling and fermenting done in that kitchen drew directly from Pennsylvania Dutch traditions (think "seven sweets and seven sours").
- Small-Batch Spirits: The bar program focused heavily on regional rye whiskeys, honoring the history of the Whiskey Rebellion.
It’s easy to get cynical about the Brooklyn dining scene. It's trendy. It's expensive. It's often more about the "vibe" than the food. But Delaware and Hudson was the real deal. It was a place that forced you to slow down and actually taste the history of the land you were standing on.
👉 See also: Curtain Bangs on Fine Hair: Why Yours Probably Look Flat and How to Fix It
The Realistic Future of This Cooking Style
While the physical location on Grand Street is gone, the philosophy lives on.
We’re seeing a resurgence of "Hyper-Regionalism." It’s no longer enough to be "American." You have to be "Lowcountry" or "Appalachian" or "Pacific Northwest." Jackson was a pioneer in that movement. She showed that the Mid-Atlantic has a culinary identity that is just as strong as the South or the West Coast.
If you're looking for that same energy today, you have to hunt for it. Look for chefs who aren't afraid of "ugly" food. Look for the places serving suet puddings, root vegetables that haven't been turned into a foam, and meats that have been cured in-house for months.
Actionable Steps for the Modern Diner
If you miss Delaware and Hudson NYC, or if you're just now realizing you missed out on something special, here is how you can still engage with that culinary spirit:
- Track Chef Patti Jackson: She didn't disappear. Keep an eye on her latest projects and pop-ups. Her expertise in regional baking and savory pies is still some of the best in the industry.
- Visit the Source: Take a weekend trip to the Lehigh Valley or the Hudson Valley. Eat at the roadside stands and the old-school diners that inspired the menu. Look for "Lebanon Bologna" and real pot pie (the kind with noodles, not a crust).
- Cook the Classics: Buy a Pennsylvania Dutch cookbook. Learn how to make a real shoofly pie or a batch of chow-chow. The ingredients are humble, but the technique is where the flavor lives.
- Support the Locals: Seek out NYC restaurants that prioritize regionality over trends. Places like Hearth in the East Village or The Dutch in Soho carry a similar torch for high-quality, localized ingredients.
Delaware and Hudson NYC was a moment in time. It was a reminder that the best food doesn't always come from far away. Sometimes, it's right in our own backyard, waiting for someone with enough skill and heart to bring it to the table.