Honestly, most movies about "tough topics" feel like they're pulling punches. They give you a sad soundtrack, some soft lighting, and a resolution that makes you feel okay about the world by the time the credits roll. Del Otro Lado del Jardín isn't interested in making you feel okay. This Colombian production, which hit Max (formerly HBO Max) with a quiet intensity, tackles the ethics of assisted dying and the right to a "dignified death" without the usual Hollywood gloss.
It’s heavy.
Based on the semi-autographical novel by Carlos Framb, the story follows a man who finds himself at the center of a legal and moral firestorm after helping his elderly, ailing mother end her life. This isn't just a "courtroom drama." It's a claustrophobic, deeply personal look at what we owe the people we love when their lives become a cycle of unmanageable pain.
The Reality Behind the Fiction
The film is rooted in a real-life case that shook Colombia. Carlos Framb, a poet and intellectual, was arrested in 2007 after his mother, Luz Mila Rivas, died in their home in Medellín.
They had a pact.
It’s the kind of thing families whisper about but rarely act on. Luz Mila was 82, nearly blind, suffering from debilitating arthritis, and terrified of the further decay that aging promised. Framb didn't just "help" her; he attempted to go with her, taking a massive dose of medication himself. He survived. She didn't. The state called it murder. He called it an act of supreme mercy.
The movie captures this tension perfectly. Julian Román, who plays the lead, delivers a performance that feels less like acting and more like a slow-motion breakdown. You see the exhaustion in his eyes. There’s no mustache-twirling villain here—just a man caught between his conscience and a legal system that, at the time, hadn't caught up to the nuances of bioethics.
Why Del Otro Lado del Jardín Hits Different
Most people expect a movie about euthanasia to be a political manifesto. This isn't that. It’s a movie about a house. Specifically, a house filled with books, memories, and the smell of impending loss.
📖 Related: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
Director Daniel Posada makes some gutsy choices here. The pacing is slow, almost agonizingly so in the first act. We see the mundane rituals of caregiving: the lifting, the feeding, the cleaning. It’s repetitive. It’s exhausting. By the time the central act of the film happens, you aren't just watching a crime—you’re feeling the weight of the years that led up to it.
- The cinematography uses tight frames to make the house feel like a sanctuary and a prison simultaneously.
- The dialogue is sparse. It relies on the silence between a mother and son who have already said everything there is to say.
- It challenges the viewer: If you loved someone this much, could you do the unthinkable?
Colombia actually has a very complex relationship with euthanasia. It was one of the first countries in the world to decriminalize it under certain conditions, yet the social stigma remains massive, largely due to deep-seated religious traditions. Del Otro Lado del Jardín leans into this friction. It shows the neighbors whispering. It shows the cold, clinical nature of the police investigation.
A Deep Dive Into the Legal Grey Zone
In the film, the legal battle serves as the framework, but the emotional battle is the soul. We see how the prosecution tries to paint the protagonist as a "depressed poet" who forced a decision on a vulnerable woman. On the flip side, the defense argues for the autonomy of the individual.
It’s messy.
There’s a specific scene where the protagonist explains that he didn't kill his mother; he helped her "cross over" because he couldn't bear to see her spirit crushed by her body. It’s a hard argument to win in a court of law, but it’s an easy one to understand if you’ve ever sat by a hospital bed for weeks on end.
The film doesn't shy away from the "how" either. It’s graphic in its emotionality, if not its physical violence. The preparation of the "cocktail," the final meal, the way they say goodbye—it’s handled with a terrifying level of intimacy. You feel like an intruder.
The Controversy You Might Not Know About
When the book first came out, it sparked a national debate in Colombia about "Matricidio" (matricide). People were divided. Some saw Framb as a saint, a man who sacrificed his own freedom to grant his mother's final wish. Others saw it as a dangerous precedent.
👉 See also: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
The film manages to capture this polarization without being preachy. It presents the mother as a woman with total agency. She isn't a victim of her son; she's a victim of a body that failed her. This is a crucial distinction that many "right to die" films miss. Usually, the sick person is portrayed as a passive observer of their own fate. Here, she is the architect.
A Masterclass in Acting
Julian Román is a household name in Latin American television, often known for his more "operatic" roles. Here, he’s stripped back. He’s raw. Opposite him, Virginia Innocenti (playing the mother figure) is haunting. Her performance is mostly in her voice and her expressions, given the physical limitations of the character.
The chemistry isn't "mother-son" in the Hallmark sense. It’s two people who have become a single unit against the world. When that unit is broken, the devastation is total.
What This Movie Says About Modern Colombia
Beyond the personal story, Del Otro Lado del Jardín acts as a mirror to a country in transition. Colombia is often portrayed in media through the lens of narco-trafficking or civil war. This movie ignores all of that. It focuses on the intellectual, urban, and deeply Catholic middle class.
It shows a Medellín that is beautiful, rainy, and somber. It’s a reminder that the most significant battles aren't always fought in the streets with guns; sometimes, they're fought in a bedroom with a glass of water and a handful of pills.
Understanding the Philosophical Core
The title itself—Del Otro Lado del Jardín (From the Other Side of the Garden)—is a poetic reference to the boundary between life and whatever comes next. It suggests that death isn't a wall, but a fence you can look through.
The protagonist views himself as a gardener of sorts, tending to the end of a life as carefully as one would tend to a dying plant. It’s a provocative metaphor. It’s also one that the film’s critics found distasteful, arguing that human life shouldn't be "pruned."
✨ Don't miss: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Practical Insights for the Viewer
If you’re planning to watch this on Max, go in prepared. This isn't background noise. You need to pay attention to the subtext.
Watch for the symbolism: The recurring motifs of light and shadow aren't just for show. They represent the protagonist's fading hope and his mother's desire for the "darkness" of sleep.
Research the context: Understanding that Colombia's Constitutional Court has been a pioneer in euthanasia rights (see Sentence C-233 of 2021) adds a layer of irony to the protagonist’s legal struggles. He was a man ahead of the law, and he paid the price for it.
Expect to be uncomfortable: The film doesn't give you an easy out. It forces you to sit with the morality of the act. You might finish the movie and still not know if he did the "right" thing. That’s the point.
Moving Forward After the Credits
Watching Del Otro Lado del Jardín usually leaves people with a lot of questions about their own families and their own views on end-of-life care.
- Talk to your family. It sounds morbid, but movies like this highlight the importance of having "The Conversation" before it’s too late. Advance directives are a real thing, and they save families from the kind of agony shown in this film.
- Explore the literature. If the movie moved you, read Carlos Framb’s original memoir. It’s even more lyrical and provides a deeper look into the philosophical justifications he used to cope with his actions.
- Check out the director's other work. Daniel Posada has a knack for finding the human element in "gritty" stories. His transition from high-stakes thrillers to this intimate drama shows a massive range.
This film is a landmark for Colombian cinema. It moves away from the "porno-misery" tropes of the past and moves into the realm of high-stakes philosophical inquiry. It’s a tough watch, sure. But it’s an essential one for anyone interested in the limits of love and the definition of mercy.
Instead of looking for a happy ending, look for the truth in the performances. The truth is that there are no easy answers when it comes to the "other side of the garden." There is only the burden of choice and the memories we leave behind.
To get the most out of your viewing experience, watch it in the original Spanish with subtitles rather than a dub. The cadence of the language and the specific regional accents of Medellín provide an authenticity that is lost in translation. This is a story about a specific place and a specific time, but the themes of grief and devotion are as universal as it gets.