Honestly, if you ask a hardcore fan when the BAU really started to feel like a family—the kind that survives anything—they’re probably going to point you toward Criminal Minds Season 9. It’s a weird, dark, and surprisingly emotional stretch of television. By the time this season premiered in 2013, the show was already a veteran. Most procedurals start to rot by year nine. They get lazy. They repeat tropes. But for the Behavioral Analysis Unit, this was the year things got personal in a way that actually mattered for the characters' long-term DNA.
It wasn't just about the "unsubs" anymore.
The season kicks off with "The Inspiration" and "The Inspired," a two-part premiere that basically sets the tone: we’re going into the deep end of psychological deviance. But the real heartbeat of the season is the 200th episode. That’s the milestone everyone remembers. It brought back Prentiss. it gave us the backstory on JJ’s "missing year" at the State Department. It proved that even when the show felt like a "case of the week" machine, there was a massive, interconnected web of trauma holding these people together.
The JJ Backstory We Actually Needed
For years, fans wondered what Jennifer Jareau was really doing while she was away from the team. We knew it involved the Middle East. We knew it was "classified." But Criminal Minds Season 9 finally stopped dancing around it. In the episode titled "200," directed by Larry Teng, we find out about Task Force 122. This wasn't just some administrative desk job. JJ was in the trenches, dealing with high-stakes interrogation and a double agent named Askari, played with a terrifying chill by Faran Tahir.
This revelation changed JJ. She wasn't just the "Liaison" or the "Team Mom" anymore. She became a hardened profiler with a darker edge. Some fans felt the shift was too sudden, but looking back, it gave A.J. Cook so much more to chew on. The trauma of her miscarriage in the field and the torture she endured at the hands of Askari and Hastings added a layer of grit that the show leaned on for the rest of its run. It’s gritty. It’s hard to watch. It’s exactly what the show needed to stay relevant.
Those Unsubs That Still Give You Chills
We can't talk about this season without mentioning the "The Itch." You know the one. The guy who thinks he has bugs under his skin? It’s arguably one of the most viscerally uncomfortable episodes in the entire series. It taps into a very real psychological condition called Morgellons disease, or delusional parasitosis. Watching it makes your skin crawl. Literally.
📖 Related: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
Then there’s "Blood Relations."
Directed by Matthew Gray Gubler.
Of course it was weird.
It’s set in the backwoods of West Virginia and feels more like a southern gothic horror movie than a standard FBI procedural. You’ve got feuding families, a mysterious creature in the woods, and an ending that doesn't wrap things up in a neat little bow. It’s classic Gubler—strange, atmospheric, and deeply unsettling. This season really leaned into the "Director's Vision" for certain episodes, allowing the cast to put their own thumbprints on the nightmare fuel.
The Section Chief Shuffle
Remember Mateo Cruz? Esai Morales joined the cast this season as the new Section Chief. Usually, the "boss" character in these shows is either a bureaucratic nightmare or a boring suit. Cruz was different because he had a shared history with JJ. That secret they kept for the first half of the season—the "What are they hiding?" vibe—fueled a lot of the tension.
It wasn't a romantic secret, which was a relief. It was a professional, life-and-death secret. Having a Section Chief who actually knew how to work a case and had "dirt" under his fingernails changed the power dynamic at the BAU. He wasn't just Strauss 2.0. He was an ally who understood the cost of the job.
The Blake Departure: A Quiet Exit
Jeanne Tripplehorn’s Alex Blake was always an interesting fit. She was an academic. A linguist. She didn't hunt with her gut; she hunted with her brain. In Criminal Minds Season 9, her relationship with Reid really blossomed. They were like two nerds in a pod, bonding over crossword puzzles and complex sentence structures.
👉 See also: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
But the finale, "Angels" and "Demons," was a brutal exit for her. When Reid gets shot in the neck—a moment that sent the fandom into a literal tailspin—Blake is the one who holds it together. But the trauma of seeing a young genius in peril, which mirrored the loss of her own son, Ethan, was too much. Her exit wasn't a big explosion or a dramatic firing. She just left her badge in Reid's bag and walked away.
It was sad.
It was quiet.
It felt real.
People in high-stress jobs don't always leave with a party. Sometimes they just realize they've reached their limit.
Key Episodes You Have to Rewatch
If you’re planning a binge-watch of Criminal Minds Season 9, you can’t just skip around. You need the full context. However, if you're short on time, these are the pillars:
- The Inspiration / The Inspired (Episodes 1 & 2): A masterclass in "creepy twin" tropes done right.
- 6 to Guanajuato (Episode 7): A great look at how the BAU handles international jurisdictions and the complexities of "vigilante" justice.
- The Black Queen (Episode 12): This is the Garcia origin story we deserved. We get to see her hacker roots and her past with the "Star Chamber." Plus, seeing her in her old "Goth" gear is a total treat.
- 200 (Episode 14): The big one. High stakes, returning characters, and massive lore drops.
- Rabid (Episode 18): Reid and Garcia training for a fitness test is the lighthearted B-plot we needed to survive the terrifying A-plot involving, well, rabies.
- Angels / Demons (Episodes 23 & 24): The two-part finale in Texas. It’s a conspiracy thriller masked as a procedural. Corruption, shootouts, and heavy emotional stakes.
Why Season 9 Matters for the Long Game
Looking back from the perspective of the later seasons (and even the Evolution revival), Season 9 was a pivot point. It proved the show could survive major cast changes and still tell deeply personal stories. It bridged the gap between the "classic" era of the show and the later, more serialized years.
✨ Don't miss: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
The writing team, led by Erica Messer, started taking bigger swings here. They weren't afraid to let the characters fail or suffer long-term consequences. When Reid gets shot, he doesn't just "get better" by the next episode. The psychological scars of that event, and Blake’s subsequent departure, ripple through Season 10 and beyond.
The "Golden Age" of the show is often debated, but Season 9 makes a very strong case for being the peak of the ensemble's chemistry. Rossi, Hotch, Morgan, Reid, JJ, Garcia, and Blake—this specific lineup had a balance of intellect and muscle that felt grounded.
Actionable Steps for the Ultimate Fan Experience
If you want to dive back into Criminal Minds Season 9, don't just watch it passively. There’s a lot under the hood.
- Watch "The Black Queen" and "200" back-to-back. These two episodes do more for the backstories of Garcia and JJ than the previous three seasons combined. It helps you see them as soldiers, not just support staff.
- Pay attention to the background details in Reid's apartment. Season 9 gives us a few more glimpses into his private life and his recovery process. The set designers were notorious for hiding "Easter eggs" about his reading list.
- Check out the director credits. This was a big year for the cast behind the camera. Joe Mantegna directed "The Road Home," and Thomas Gibson took the helm for "Gabby." Seeing how the actors direct their peers often reveals who they think the "star" of a particular scene should be.
- Listen to the score. The music in the two-part finale "Angels/Demons" is particularly haunting. It moves away from the standard "tension" strings and into something much more cinematic.
The beauty of this show is that it’s always there. Whether it’s on a streaming loop or a late-night cable marathon, Criminal Minds Season 9 stands as a testament to why we keep coming back to the basement of the FBI. It’s dark, it’s messy, and it’s surprisingly full of heart. Just maybe don't watch "The Itch" while you're eating. Trust me on that one.