If you’ve ever felt like the world was trying to force you into a category you didn’t quite fit, you’ve basically lived the life of Countee Cullen. He was the "golden boy" of the Harlem Renaissance. Everyone loved him, until they didn't.
He was brilliant. A prodigy. By the time he was 22, he had already published his first collection, Color, to insane critical acclaim. People were calling him the next Keats. But there was a catch. Cullen didn't want to be a "Black poet." He wanted to be a poet.
That distinction sounds small, but in the 1920s, it was a freaking earthquake.
The Mystery of the Man
Honestly, we don't even know for sure where he was born. Some records say Louisville, Kentucky; others say Baltimore. He was born Countee LeRoy Porter in 1903, but after his grandmother died when he was fifteen, he was unofficially adopted by Reverend Frederick A. Cullen.
The Reverend wasn't just some guy. He was the pastor of Salem Methodist Episcopal Church, one of Harlem’s most powerful congregations.
Imagine growing up in that house. It was conservative. It was strictly Christian. It was also at the dead center of Black intellectual life. This duality—the stiff collar of the church versus the wild, creative energy of 1920s Harlem—basically defined everything he ever wrote.
He was an academic beast. He crushed it at New York University, then went to Harvard for his Master’s. He wasn't just good; he was "Phi Beta Kappa" good. But while his peers like Langston Hughes were experimenting with jazz rhythms and the "low-down" blues of the streets, Cullen was obsessed with the classics.
He loved the sonnet. He loved the rhyming couplet. He worshipped at the altar of John Keats and Percy Bysshe Shelley.
The Controversy: Why "Countee Cullen for a poet" matters
A lot of people today get confused about why his peers started to turn on him. It’s because Cullen made a choice. He famously said, “If I am going to be a poet at all, I am going to be POET and not NEGRO POET.”
You've gotta understand the weight of that.
🔗 Read more: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
To some, like W.E.B. Du Bois, Cullen was the ultimate example of the "Talented Tenth." He showed the white world that a Black man could master their "high art" forms better than they could. He was the proof that race didn't limit intellect.
But younger writers? They weren't so sure.
Langston Hughes basically called him out (without naming him) in his famous essay The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain. Hughes argued that any Black artist who tries to be "just a poet" is actually saying they want to be white.
It was a brutal critique.
Cullen wasn't trying to hide his race, though. If you actually read his work, it's obsessed with race. His most famous poem, "Yet Do I Marvel," ends with these haunting lines:
"Yet do I marvel at this curious thing: / To make a poet black, and bid him sing!"
He wasn't ignoring the struggle. He was just arguing that his tools shouldn't have to be "Black tools." He wanted the whole toolbox.
The Wedding of the Century (and the Disaster After)
If you think celebrity weddings are a modern thing, you haven't read about Cullen and Yolande Du Bois.
In 1928, Countee married Yolande, the daughter of W.E.B. Du Bois. It was the event of the decade. 1,200 invited guests. 3,000 more people standing in the streets just to get a glimpse. Langston Hughes was even an usher!
💡 You might also like: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
It was a literal merger of Harlem royalty.
It lasted two months.
Basically, it was a mess. They went to France on a Guggenheim Fellowship, and things fell apart fast. There’s a lot of evidence—and most historians like Henry Louis Gates Jr. agree—that Cullen was gay. He lived in a time where he couldn't be open about that, especially as the son of a high-profile minister and the son-in-law of Du Bois.
The divorce was a huge scandal. It hurt his reputation. Some say he never really recovered that "golden boy" glow afterward.
The Pivot to the Classroom
By the 1930s, the Harlem Renaissance was cooling off. The Great Depression hit, and the white patrons who were funding the arts disappeared.
Cullen’s later poetry collections, like The Black Christ (1929), didn't get the same love as his early stuff. People thought he was getting too "old-fashioned." While everyone else was moving toward modernism and grit, Cullen stayed with his formal verses.
So, he did something unexpected. He became a teacher.
From 1934 until his death in 1946, he taught French and English at Frederick Douglass Junior High in New York. One of his students? A kid named James Baldwin.
Yeah, that James Baldwin.
📖 Related: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Baldwin later credited Cullen with being a massive influence. Even when Cullen wasn't the "it" poet anymore, he was still shaping the next generation of American literature. He spent his final years writing children's books (like The Lost Zoo) and working on a musical called St. Louis Woman.
He died young—only 43. High blood pressure and kidney issues took him out in 1946.
Why You Should Care Today
We spend a lot of time arguing about "authenticity." We ask if someone is "Black enough" or "real enough."
Cullen was fighting that battle a hundred years ago.
He didn't want to be a mascot. He didn't want his art to be a political pamphlet. He just wanted the poem to be good. His legacy is a reminder that being "universal" doesn't mean you're betraying your roots. It just means you refuse to let anyone else define the boundaries of your world.
How to actually read Countee Cullen
If you want to understand the man, don't just read a biography. Read the work.
- Start with "Incident." It’s short, simple, and will absolutely wreck you. It’s about an eight-year-old boy in Baltimore who has his whole day ruined by a single racial slur. It shows that Cullen didn't "ignore" race—he felt it deeply.
- Check out "Heritage." This is his long-form masterpiece. It asks the question, "What is Africa to me?" It’s a beautiful, conflicting, and kinda messy exploration of identity.
- Read "Yet Do I Marvel." It’s a perfect sonnet. It’s technically flawless, which makes the pain of the message even sharper.
Countee Cullen wasn't a "traitor" or a "sell-out." He was a man caught between two worlds—the classical past he loved and the racial reality he couldn't escape. He chose to stand in the middle.
And honestly? That’s probably the bravest place a poet can be.
Next Steps for Your Research:
If you're studying Cullen for a project or just for fun, your best move is to compare his style directly with Langston Hughes. Look at Cullen's "From the Dark Tower" alongside Hughes's "The Negro Speaks of Rivers." You'll see two geniuses looking at the same world through completely different lenses. One uses the structure of the past to demand a future; the other builds a new language entirely. Understanding that tension is the key to understanding the Harlem Renaissance.