Low budget. High concept. No script.
That sounds like a recipe for a total disaster, doesn't it? Honestly, most of the time, it is. But back in 2013, a guy named James Ward Byrkit decided to invite eight friends over to his house, throw some cameras at them, and see if they could survive a dinner party while the fabric of reality basically disintegrated. The result was Coherence, a movie that practically nobody saw in theaters but has since become the ultimate "you have to watch this" recommendation for people who actually like their science fiction to make them feel a little bit insane.
It’s weird. It’s claustrophobic. It’s brilliant.
Most people think great scifi needs a $200 million budget and a bunch of blue-screen explosions. Coherence proves that all you really need is a glow stick, a box of random household items, and the terrifying realization that you might not be the only "you" in the room.
What Actually Happens During the Comet Miller Event?
The setup is deceptively simple. A group of friends gathers for a dinner party on the night a comet is passing overhead. We’ve seen this trope a million times. Someone mentions a historical precedent—Comet Miller in 1923—where people in a Finnish town got confused and didn't recognize their own families. You think you know where this is going. You think it's an alien invasion or a slasher flick.
It isn't.
When the power goes out, the group notices one house down the street still has lights on. Two of them decide to walk over to ask to use a phone. When they come back, things are... off. They have a box. Inside that box is a paddle with a number on it and photos of everyone at the party. The photos were taken tonight.
This is where Coherence stops being a drama and starts being a masterclass in quantum decoherence. According to the Everett many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, every possible outcome of a quantum event exists in its own separate branch of reality. Usually, these branches don't touch. But the comet? The comet acts as a bridge.
Suddenly, the "dark space" outside the house isn't just a dark street. It's a localized Schrodinger’s cat scenario. Every time someone leaves the house and passes through that darkness, they aren't necessarily returning to the same house they left. They might be walking into a version of the party where someone made a slightly different choice ten minutes ago.
💡 You might also like: Brother May I Have Some Oats Script: Why This Bizarre Pig Meme Refuses to Die
The Absolute Chaos of the Production
You have to understand how this movie was made to appreciate why it feels so real. Byrkit didn't give the actors a script. He gave them "notes" or "bullet points" for their characters each day.
Nicholas Brendon (the guy from Buffy) might get a note saying, "You’re an alcoholic and you’re starting to get defensive." Emily Foxler (the lead) might get a note saying, "You’re the only one who notices the subtle changes in the room." The actors didn't know what the other actors were told.
So, when a character reacts with genuine confusion or anger, that’s not just acting. It’s a real human being trying to figure out why their friend is suddenly acting like a jerk. This improvisational approach gives the film a jittery, documentary-like energy. The camera is handheld, the lighting is practical, and the dialogue is messy. People talk over each other. They panic. They make stupid decisions because they’re scared.
It’s the opposite of a polished Hollywood production, and that’s exactly why it works.
Why Fans Keep Obsessing Over the "Red Glow Stick" Theory
If you watch this movie once, you'll be confused. If you watch it twice, you'll start taking notes.
The fans who love Coherence are the same ones who spent years dissecting Primer or Inception. Because the movie involves multiple versions of the same eight people crossing paths, you need a way to track which "version" we’re following. The movie gives you breadcrumbs.
- The color of the glow sticks (Blue vs. Red).
- The number written on the ping-pong paddle.
- The specific object placed in the box (a stapler, a napkin, a coaster).
- The way a character’s phone screen is cracked.
There is a point in the middle of the film where the characters realize they are "The Blue House." They have blue glow sticks. But they soon realize that the people who just knocked on their door are from a house with red glow sticks.
Wait.
📖 Related: Brokeback Mountain Gay Scene: What Most People Get Wrong
If they are the blue house, and there’s a red house, how many other houses are there? The math gets terrifying. It’s not just two. It’s infinite. Every time a group goes out into the dark, they are potentially shuffling themselves into a new reality. By the third act, you realize that the people sitting around the table might not even be from the same original reality as each other.
Emily, our protagonist, is the only one who truly grasps the horror of this. She realizes that her "original" life was kind of a mess anyway, so she starts looking for a "better" version of the party to slip into. This shifts the movie from a scifi mystery into a psychological thriller about identity and the predatory nature of regret.
Dealing With the "Plot Hole" Accusations
People often complain that the characters act "irrationally." Why do they keep leaving the house? Why don't they just stay put and wait for the sun to come up?
Honestly, have you met people?
Put eight stressed-out adults in a room with limited information, no cell service, and a looming sense of existential dread, and they will fall apart. The movie isn't about the physics of the comet; it's about the fragility of the social contract. The moment they realize there are "other" versions of themselves, they stop trusting the people in the room.
If you knew there was another version of you out there who might be "winning" at life, would you try to replace them? That’s the dark heart of Coherence. It’s not a plot hole that they leave the house; it’s a character flaw. They are driven by curiosity and, eventually, by a desperate need to find a reality where they aren't the losers.
Where to Find the Best Details You Missed
Look at the background. Seriously.
In the first ten minutes, before the power even goes out, look at the way the characters interact. There are hints about affairs, failed careers, and old resentments. These aren't just filler dialogue. They are the variables that change in the different realities.
👉 See also: British TV Show in Department Store: What Most People Get Wrong
In one reality, Kevin is a supportive boyfriend. In another, he’s distant. In one, Amir is a tag-along; in another, he’s the one holding the secrets.
There’s a specific scene involving a "book" on quantum physics written by one of the characters' brothers. This book serves as the "rules" of the movie, but even the book is unreliable because the version of the book they find might not be the version written in their world. It’s layers upon layers of uncertainty.
Practical Steps for Your First (or Fifth) Viewing
If you're going to dive into this movie, don't just put it on in the background while you fold laundry. You will be lost in five minutes.
- Watch it in the dark. The film’s atmosphere relies heavily on the contrast between the cozy dining room and the pitch-black exterior.
- Track the "Totems." Pay attention to the box they create. That box is the only way to verify which reality you are in. If the items in the box don't match the items they wrote down earlier, you're in a different timeline.
- Listen to the phone call. Early in the film, Emily is on the phone and it cuts out. Pay attention to what she was saying and who she was talking to. It matters more than you think.
- Observe the "Kitchen Scene." There is a moment where a character goes into the kitchen and comes back out. Watch their body language. They might not be the same person who went in.
- Stop trying to find the "Correct" ending. The movie doesn't have a happy resolution where everyone goes back to their original homes. That’s impossible. The "coherence" has been broken. The ending is about survival, not restoration.
Why Coherence Matters in 2026
We live in an era of multiverse fatigue. Marvel has turned the concept of parallel realities into a giant CGI spectacle where anything can happen and nothing has consequences. Coherence is the antidote to that. It shows that the multiverse isn't cool or fun—it’s a nightmare. It’s the loss of the self.
It reminds us that the most terrifying thing isn't a monster under the bed; it's the person looking back at us in the mirror who made one better choice than we did.
If you haven't seen it, find a copy. It’s often streaming on platforms like Prime Video or Shudder, or you can find it on Kanopy if you have a library card. Just make sure you know which house you're coming back to when the movie is over.
Once you finish the film, the next logical step is to look up the "Coherence Timeline Map" online. There are several fan-made charts that track every single character jump through the darkness. Studying these maps is the only way to truly see the clockwork precision of Byrkit’s "unscripted" experiment. It’ll make you want to watch the whole thing again immediately just to spot the moment the "Blue Emily" becomes the "Red Emily."
Stay inside. Keep your glow sticks handy. Don't open the door for anyone—even yourself.