He actually did it. On January 9, 2026, the unthinkable happened in Berlin: Cody Rhodes lost the Undisputed WWE Championship. After a marathon reign that felt like it would last forever, a Three Stages of Hell match against Drew McIntyre finally saw the "American Nightmare" fall. Honestly, watching Jacob Fatu return and cost him the gold was one of those "drop your phone" moments.
But losing a belt doesn't make Cody Rhodes the wrestler any less of a phenomenon. If anything, it makes him more interesting.
For the last few years, Cody hasn't just been a performer; he's been the literal gravity of the industry. You've seen the suits, the bus, the blonde hair, and that neck tattoo that everyone hated at first but now symbolizes a revolution. He is a second-generation star who refused to be just "Dusty's son." He became the guy who built a rival company, left it, and then came back to conquer the biggest one of them all.
The Berlin Shock: What Really Happened to Cody Rhodes
Most people thought Cody was bulletproof. Heading into 2026, he was the face of the Netflix era. But the match in Berlin changed everything. Drew McIntyre, after years of being the bridesmaid, finally snatched the title. It wasn't a clean win, though.
Jacob Fatu—the "Samoan Werewolf"—erupted back onto the scene. He didn't just attack McIntyre; he went after Cody too. In the chaos of that steel cage, Drew escaped. Just like that, the Rhodes era hit a brick wall.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Best Texas Longhorns iPhone Wallpaper Without the Low-Res Junk
Is he done? Not a chance.
Rumors are already swirling that this loss is the catalyst for a massive character shift. Some insiders, like Ibou from Self-Made, suggest we might be seeing a "heel" version of Cody soon. Imagine the guy who hand-delivers weight belts to kids suddenly becoming the most hated man in the room. It’s a risky play, but Cody thrives on risk.
Why Cody Rhodes the Wrestler is Different From Everyone Else
You have to understand where he came from to get why he matters now. He wasn't always the main event. In 2016, he was Stardust. He was a guy painted like a cosmic freak, begging for a chance to be taken seriously.
He asked for his release. He bet on himself.
🔗 Read more: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
He went to the indies, New Japan, and Ring of Honor. He carried a literal list of people he wanted to fight. That wasn't just a gimmick; it was a manifesto. When he co-founded AEW (All Elite Wrestling), he proved that he didn't need the WWE machine to be a global star.
The Metrics of a Megastar
- The Merch Power: He consistently tops the charts. Even after losing the title, "American Nightmare" hoodies are basically the uniform of wrestling fans.
- The Match Quality: Whether it was the bloody Hell in a Cell match against Seth Rollins with a torn pec or the 2025 King of the Ring finals, he delivers.
- The "Story": No one has ever used the phrase "Finish the Story" more effectively. It became a cultural movement that culminated at WrestleMania 40.
The Rumors of the Final Contract
There's a bit of a somber cloud hanging over the Rhodes camp lately. Cody recently hinted that his current WWE contract might be his last. He’s 40 now. He’s got a daughter, Liberty, and a wife, Brandi, who he clearly wants to spend more time with.
If this is the "beginning of the end," it explains why he’s working at such a breakneck pace. He wants to leave a legacy that isn't just about titles, but about the health of the business. He’s basically the "Corporate Cody" now—a bridge between the locker room and the front office.
What Most Fans Get Wrong About His "Hometown"
People always talk about Cody being from Georgia. He was a two-time state wrestling champion at Lassiter High School. But he was actually born in Charlotte, North Carolina. It’s a small detail, but for a guy so obsessed with wrestling history, those roots in the Mid-Atlantic territory matter. He’s a student of the game who knows exactly when to use a Figure-Four or a Bionic Elbow to make the crowd explode.
💡 You might also like: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
What’s Next for the American Nightmare?
Right now, the path leads to Royal Rumble 2026 and eventually WrestleMania 42 at Allegiant Stadium.
With Drew McIntyre holding the gold and Roman Reigns still lurking in the shadows, the "Triple Threat" of the century feels inevitable. But Cody’s next move isn't just about winning back a belt. It’s about navigating a locker room that is younger, faster, and hungrier. Guys like Bron Breakker and Jacob Fatu aren't just challengers; they are the future he helped build by raising the bar.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
- Watch the Promos: Pay attention to the subtle shifts in Cody’s tone on SmackDown. If he stops mentioning the "fans" as much, the heel turn is definitely coming.
- Follow the Fatu Feud: This isn't just a random attack. The mystery of who attacked Jacob back in October 2025 is the key to Cody's next six months.
- Check the Schedule: Cody is a workhorse. If he starts scaling back his house show appearances, those retirement rumors might have more weight than we think.
The story of Cody Rhodes the wrestler isn't over just because he lost a match in Berlin. It’s just entering a much darker, much more unpredictable chapter. Honestly, that’s exactly what he needs to stay relevant in a post-WrestleMania 40 world.
Keep an eye on the January 31st Royal Rumble. If Cody enters at number one, he’s looking to pull a hat trick. If he doesn't enter at all? Then we know something big is brewing behind the scenes with Nick Aldis and the WWE management.