If you grew up in the eighties or nineties, you didn't just read The Baby-Sitters Club. You inhaled it. And let's be honest: while Kristy was busy being a boss and Mary Anne was crying over a lost kitten, we were all actually there for one thing. We were there for the side-ponytails, the high-top sneakers painted with acrylics, and the oversized button-downs that looked like they belonged in a SoHo gallery. I’m talking about the vice president of the club, the undisputed queen of junk food and secret stashes, Claudia Kishi.
The Claudia Kishi Baby-Sitters Club outfits weren't just clothes. They were a manifesto. Ann M. Martin, along with the ghostwriters who populated Stoneybrook, used Claudia’s wardrobe to signal a specific kind of creative rebellion. She was the "cool one" not because she tried hard, but because she fundamentally understood that a pair of stirrup leggings could be high art if you paired them with the right earrings. Huge, dangly earrings. Usually shaped like food or abstract geometric shapes.
The Anatomy of a Kishi Classic
People often try to pigeonhole Claudia’s style as "maximalist." That’s a bit of a lazy take. Honestly, her look was more about the juxtaposition of high and low, or rather, the "intentional" and the "accidental." In the books, her outfits are described with a level of granular detail that borders on the obsessive. You’ve probably read about the time she wore a baggy black jumpsuit with a wide white belt and a fedora. Or the iconic oversized men's shirt cinched with a sash.
It wasn't just about the fabric. It was the DIY ethos.
Claudia was a maker. Before Etsy existed, she was living the life. She’d take a perfectly good pair of jeans and rip them, or she’d sew lace onto a denim jacket. This is why her style resonates so deeply with Gen Z today. It’s the original thrifting energy. If you look at the 2020 Netflix adaptation, costume designer Cynthia Ann Summers didn't just copy the book covers. She translated that 1980s vibe into a modern context. She kept the spirit—the "clashing but it works" energy—and made it feel like something you’d actually see on a TikTok trendsetter.
Why the Book Covers Lied to Us (Sort Of)
If you look at the original covers illustrated by Hodges Soileau, Claudia often looks... well, a bit more subdued than the text suggests. The text might say she’s wearing "electric blue leggings and a sweater with a giant paint palette on it," but the cover might show her in a fairly standard pink turtleneck. This created a weird duality for readers. We had the "Canon Claudia" of the prose and the "Visual Claudia" of the art.
The real magic happened in our imaginations.
We had to fill in the gaps. We had to imagine what "boots with faux-fur trim and a matching headband" actually looked like on a middle-schooler in Connecticut. Most of us realized that if we tried to wear that to our own schools, we’d be sent to the principal's office or, worse, ignored. Claudia had the confidence of someone who didn't care about the Stoneybrook social hierarchy, even though she was technically part of the popular crowd.
The Color Palette of Rebellion
Claudia’s wardrobe was a riot of primary colors. We’re talking:
👉 See also: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
- Fuchsia
- Teal
- Mustard Yellow
- Red (always a bold, classic red)
She rarely did "boring." If she wore black, it was because she was in a "sophisticated artist" phase, likely paired with a beret and a charcoal pencil tucked behind her ear. Her outfits were a shield. They protected her from the pressure of being the "perfect student" that her sister, Janine, so effortlessly embodied. When you’re failing math, you might as well look like a masterpiece while doing it.
The Netflix Effect: Updating a Legend
When Netflix revived the series, the pressure to get the Claudia Kishi Baby-Sitters Club outfits right was immense. Momona Tamada, who played Claudia, became an overnight style icon for a new generation. The showrunners understood that in 2020 (and into 2026's nostalgic cycle), "cool" looks different than it did in 1986.
They leaned into the "Art Kid" aesthetic.
They used brands like Anthropologie and Zara, but mixed them with vintage pieces that felt authentic. There was a specific yellow suit in the first season that basically broke the internet. It was bold. It was structured. It was something a thirteen-year-old shouldn't be able to pull off, yet she did. That’s the core of Claudia: she wears the clothes; the clothes never wear her.
One thing the show did exceptionally well was acknowledging Claudia’s heritage through her clothes. While the books touched on her Japanese-American identity, the show’s wardrobe sometimes incorporated subtle nods to Asian streetwear trends, blending Harajuku vibes with New England prep. It was a layer of depth that the original books sometimes skimmed over.
The Secret Language of Accessories
You cannot talk about Claudia without talking about the earrings. My god, the earrings.
In the BSC universe, Claudia’s earrings were legendary. She had earrings shaped like:
- Telephone receivers
- Tropical fruit
- Miniature paint sets
- Geometric shapes that looked like a Memphis Design fever dream
These weren't just jewelry. They were conversation starters. They were a way for her to signal her mood without saying a word. If she was wearing the big, bright, plastic hoops, she was having a good day. If she was wearing something smaller and more intricate, she was probably deep into a charcoal sketch or hiding a bag of Peanut M&Ms in a hollowed-out book.
✨ Don't miss: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
She also pioneered the "multi-layer" look. Scarves over necklaces over collars. It was chaotic. It was messy. It was exactly what every repressed suburban kid wanted to look like.
Beyond the Fabric: The Emotional Weight of Fashion
Why are we still obsessed with these outfits decades later? It’s not just nostalgia. It’s because Claudia used fashion as a form of agency. In a world where she felt "less than" because of her grades, her clothes were the one area where she was the smartest person in the room.
She was a visual learner. She saw the world in shapes and textures.
When she put on a pair of high-top sneakers with mismatched laces, she was asserting her identity in a town that valued conformity. Stoneybrook is a place of white picket fences and "sensible" sweaters. Claudia was the glitch in the matrix. She was the reminder that you can be a good friend, a great babysitter, and a responsible person while still looking like you just fell through a rack at a vintage store in the Village.
Misconceptions About Claudia's Wardrobe
A lot of people think Claudia just grabbed random things and threw them on. That’s a total myth. If you read the books closely, you see she’s incredibly deliberate. She spends time thinking about her outfits. She plans them. It’s her version of studying. She might not understand the quadratic formula, but she understands the color wheel.
Another misconception is that her style was expensive. Sure, she had some nice things, but most of her "iconic" looks were DIY. She was a fan of the "remix." Taking something old and making it new. This is a crucial distinction. Claudia wasn't a "fashion victim" chasing trends; she was a "fashion creator" setting them.
How to Channel Your Inner Claudia Kishi Today
If you want to bring some of that Claudia Kishi Baby-Sitters Club outfits energy into your current rotation, you don't need to dress like it's a costume party. It's about the philosophy, not just the pieces.
Start with a base of something simple—maybe a pair of wide-leg trousers or a simple jumpsuit. Then, ruin it. Not literally, but add something that "doesn't belong." A pair of bright orange socks. A massive, chunky necklace that looks like it weighs five pounds. The goal is to create a point of tension in the outfit.
🔗 Read more: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Look for items that have a "hand-done" feel. Embroidery, patches, or visible mending. Claudia would have loved the modern "slow fashion" movement. She would have been the first person to teach a workshop on how to upcycle a thrifted blazer using nothing but fabric markers and sheer willpower.
The Lasting Legacy of Stoneybrook's Resident Artist
At the end of the day, Claudia Kishi taught a generation of girls that it was okay to be different. She taught us that "smart" comes in many forms. Sometimes, smart looks like a girl who can't pass a spelling test but can compose a perfectly balanced outfit using only primary colors and a dream.
Her outfits were her voice.
Even now, when we see a girl on the subway with neon hair and a vintage coat covered in pins, we think of Claudia. She gave us permission to be loud. She gave us permission to be colorful. And most importantly, she gave us permission to hide snacks in our boots, though I personally wouldn't recommend that if you're wearing suede.
To truly embrace the Kishi aesthetic, you have to stop asking "does this match?" and start asking "does this feel like me?" If the answer is yes, then you’ve nailed it. Go find some hollowed-out books, buy some oversized sweaters, and never, ever apologize for wearing earrings shaped like pieces of pizza.
Next Steps for the Aspiring Kishi:
- Audit your closet for items you haven't worn in a year and brainstorm one way to "Claudia-fy" them—think fabric paint, new buttons, or even just cutting the sleeves off.
- Support local artists when buying accessories. Skip the mass-produced stuff and find a creator who makes weird, wonderful earrings that tell a story.
- Document your "risk" outfits. Take a photo when you wear something that makes you feel a bit nervous. Claudia’s confidence came from practice; start practicing your own visual language today.
---