You know that feeling when you're scrolling through Netflix or Prime Video in December, past the big-budget blockbusters and the Hallmark cookie-cutter films, and you stumble upon something that actually feels... real? That’s basically the vibe of Christmas in the Heartland. It’s a movie that, on paper, sounds like a dozen other holiday swap stories. But honestly? It’s got this weird, gritty, soulful charm that keeps people coming back to it years after its 2017 release.
It's about two teenage girls, Kara and Jessie. They meet on a plane. They’re both heading to meet grandparents they’ve never met in a small town in Oklahoma. One is from a wealthy background; the other is a country girl. They swap places. Standard trope, right? Except the movie isn't just about the swap. It’s about the specific, dusty, warm, and sometimes messy reality of middle America.
The "Parent Trap" Formula with an Oklahoma Twist
Most people compare this to The Parent Trap, which is fair. But there’s a difference here. In most holiday movies, the "country" setting is a sanitized version of Vermont with perfect snow and $40 jars of maple syrup. Christmas in the Heartland gives us something different. It gives us the "Heartland" pageant. It gives us families that aren't just "quirky" but feel like people you actually know if you’ve ever spent time in the Midwest or the South.
Kara Gentry and Jessie Wilkins—played by Sierra McCormick and Brighton Sharbino—actually have decent chemistry. It’s not just about the clothes they change into. It’s about the fact that both of them are looking for a sense of belonging that their "real" lives haven't provided. You’ve got Bo Derek and Shelley Long playing the grandmothers. Think about that for a second. Bo Derek and Shelley Long. It’s a wild casting choice that somehow works because they lean into the absurdity of the rivalry between the two families.
The movie was originally titled The Christmas Trap. It’s a bit on the nose. Changing it to Christmas in the Heartland was probably a smart move for SEO and branding, but the "trap" element is what drives the plot. It’s the engine. But the heart? That’s the Oklahoma landscape and the genuine desire for family connection.
Why This Movie Hits Differently Than Hallmark
Hallmark movies are great. They’re like warm blankets. But they are predictable. You know the lead will end up with the guy who owns the Christmas tree farm. In Christmas in the Heartland, the stakes feel slightly more grounded in identity. It’s about girls who are struggling with their parents' legacies.
One thing most people get wrong about this film is assuming it’s just for kids. It’s really not. There’s a level of sarcasm and wit in the dialogue—especially from Shelley Long’s character, Judy—that appeals to adults who have survived their own family holiday gatherings. It deals with the friction of class, the assumptions we make about people based on where they live, and the idea that "home" is a fluid concept.
The production didn't have a massive budget. You can tell. Some of the lighting is a bit flat, and the pacing in the middle drags a little. But who cares? It feels authentic. It was filmed on location in places like Guthrie and Edmond, Oklahoma. Using real locations instead of a soundstage in Vancouver gives it a texture you can’t fake. The dust is real. The sunlight is real.
The Casting Jackpot: Bo Derek and Shelley Long
Let’s talk about the grandmothers. This is where the movie earns its keep. Bo Derek (of 10 fame) and Shelley Long (Cheers) are icons. Seeing them share the screen in a family holiday movie is sort of like seeing two different eras of Hollywood collide.
- Shelley Long as Judy: She’s doing a version of the high-strung, slightly overbearing but well-meaning matriarch. It’s a role she can do in her sleep, but she brings a warmth to it that prevents the character from becoming a caricature.
- Bo Derek as Elsa: She’s the more "refined" grandmother, representing the Gentry family wealth. The tension between her and Judy is where the movie finds its comedic footing.
It’s not just about the girls. It’s about these two women realizing they have more in common than they thought. It’s a sub-plot that carries a lot of the emotional weight. Honestly, without them, the movie might have faded into the background of the thousands of other holiday titles. They give it gravity.
💡 You might also like: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Breaking Down the Plot Without the Fluff
The setup is quick. Kara is flying to Oklahoma because her dad is busy. Jessie is flying there because her mom is in jail. That’s a heavy detail for a "light" holiday movie, right? Jessie’s mom being incarcerated adds a layer of real-world struggle that you rarely see in the genre.
They swap. Kara goes to the humble Wilkins household. Jessie goes to the Gentry estate.
What follows is a series of "fish out of water" moments. Kara has to learn how to live without a silver spoon. Jessie has to navigate the high expectations of a wealthy social circle. They both enter a local beauty pageant—because of course they do. It’s the Heartland. Pageants are a staple of the culture.
The movie manages to avoid being mean-spirited. It would have been easy to make fun of the "poor" family or mock the "rich" family’s snobbery. Instead, it finds the humanity in both. It suggests that whether you’re eating a five-course meal or a casserole, the loneliness of not knowing your roots is the same.
The Impact of the Oklahoma Film Scene
Christmas in the Heartland is actually a great example of the growing film industry in Oklahoma. For years, the state has been pushing tax incentives to bring productions there. This movie is a product of that push.
Director Harvey Lowry has a background in special effects and makeup—working on huge films like The Curious Case of Benjamin Button—but here he focuses on character. It’s a pivot. He uses the Oklahoma scenery to create a sense of place that is central to the narrative. The town of Guthrie, with its Victorian architecture, is practically a character itself.
If you’re a film nerd, you might notice the cinematography captures that specific golden-hour light you only get in the plains. It’s beautiful in a way that feels unpolished.
Why the Movie Found a Second Life on Streaming
When the film first came out, it didn't set the world on fire. It was a modest release. But then came the streaming boom. Netflix, Amazon, and various "free with ads" services like Tubi or Pluto TV started picking up holiday content to fill their libraries.
Suddenly, Christmas in the Heartland was everywhere.
📖 Related: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
It became a "discovery" title. People would put it on for their kids and end up watching the whole thing themselves. It’s got a high re-watch value because it’s comfortable. It doesn't demand too much of you, but it doesn't insult your intelligence either. The music, featuring country tracks that actually fit the vibe, helps a lot too.
Common Misconceptions About the Film
I’ve seen a lot of reviews that get certain things wrong.
First, people think it’s a musical. It’s not. There is singing, particularly because of the pageant plotline, but it’s not a "characters burst into song to express their feelings" kind of movie. The music is diegetic—it’s happening within the world of the story.
Second, some viewers expect a romance-heavy plot. While there are some teenage crushes and some adult sparks, that’s not the focus. The core of Christmas in the Heartland is family. It’s about grandmothers and granddaughters. It’s about fathers and daughters. If you’re looking for a heavy "meet-cute" romance, this might not be your first choice, but the familial bonds are much more rewarding.
Critical Reception vs. Audience Love
Critics were mixed. They often are with these types of movies. They pointed to the predictable plot and the occasionally cheesy dialogue. And yeah, it’s a holiday movie. Cheese is part of the recipe.
But audiences? They loved it. On Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb, the audience scores generally outshine the critic scores. That’s because the movie delivers exactly what it promises: a feel-good story with a bit of grit and a lot of heart. It’s "comfort food" cinema.
The film also avoids the trap of being "too" religious. While it’s set during Christmas in a part of the country where church is central to life, it focuses more on the universal themes of kindness, honesty, and forgiveness. It’s accessible to everyone, regardless of their background.
What You Should Take Away From the Movie
If you haven't seen it yet, or if you're planning a re-watch this year, pay attention to the smaller moments. Look at the way the girls' friendship develops. It’s not just a plot device; it’s a genuine connection between two people who feel like outsiders.
There’s a lesson there about stepping into someone else’s shoes—literally—to understand their perspective. In a world that feels increasingly polarized, that’s a pretty solid message for a "simple" holiday movie to carry.
👉 See also: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
Christmas in the Heartland isn't trying to win an Oscar. It’s trying to make you feel something. It’s trying to remind you that family is complicated, messy, and ultimately, the thing that grounds us.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Holiday Movie Marathon
If you're planning to dive into the world of heartland holiday films, here's how to make the most of it.
Watch for the local flavor. If you're from Oklahoma or the Midwest, look for the landmarks. It adds a layer of fun to the viewing experience to see real-world spots like the Guthrie post office or local diners.
Double-feature it. Pair this with another Oklahoma-set film or a classic swap movie like the 1998 Parent Trap. It’s interesting to see how different directors handle the "identity swap" trope.
Check the soundtrack. The movie features some genuine country talent. If you like the music in the film, it’s worth looking up the artists—many of them are local to the region where the movie was filmed.
Focus on the themes of honesty. One of the best ways to talk about this movie with kids is to ask about the consequences of the girls' lie. Even though it's a comedy, the movie doesn't completely let them off the hook for the deception, which is a great talking point.
The film is currently available on multiple streaming platforms, often changing depending on the season. It’s a staple of the "Holiday" category on Amazon Prime and can frequently be found on Peacock or Tubi.
Go into it with an open mind. Don't expect a $200 million epic. Expect a story about two girls, two grandmothers, and a whole lot of Oklahoma heart. It’s the kind of movie that reminds us why we watch holiday films in the first place—not for the spectacle, but for the feeling of coming home, even if home is somewhere you've never been before.
Next Steps for the Holiday Season
To get the full "Heartland" experience, you can actually visit some of the filming locations. Guthrie, Oklahoma, goes all out for Christmas with its "Territorial Christmas" celebration. It features lighted parades, caroling, and home tours that make you feel like you’ve stepped right onto the movie set. If you can’t make the trip, hosting a "Heartland" themed watch party with some classic Midwest comfort food—think chicken fried steak or a solid potluck casserole—is the next best thing.
Keep an eye on the streaming schedules starting in late October. Most platforms begin rotating their holiday libraries then, and Christmas in the Heartland is almost always in the mix. Whether you're a fan of Shelley Long's comedic timing or you just want a break from the usual holiday glitz, this movie remains a reliable, heartwarming pick for any December night.