You’re standing over a whelping box, and there are six tiny, squirming golden retriever puppies. One of them is bolder than the rest. He’s the first to waddle over to your shoes. He’s biting your laces while the others are napping or sniffing a corner. The breeder looks at you and says, "That one right there? He’s the pick of the litter." You feel a surge of ego. You want the best. You want the leader. But honestly? That "leader" might be the worst possible dog for your actual life.
The term pick of the litter has become this weird status symbol in the dog world. Historically, it was the puppy the breeder kept for themselves to continue their bloodline. It was about structure, gait, and breed standards—the stuff that wins ribbons at Westminster. Somewhere along the way, regular families started using it to mean "the coolest puppy" or "the strongest one."
We’ve got this obsession with being #1. We want the smartest kid, the fastest car, and the pick of the litter. But a puppy isn't a trophy. It's a ten-to-fifteen-year commitment to a living, breathing personality that might not mesh with yours.
The Myth of the "Best" Puppy
There is no objective "best" in a group of siblings. Think about your own family. Is your oldest brother "better" than your youngest sister? Probably not, they’re just different. In a litter of dogs, one might have the best "stack" (how they stand for a judge), while another has the most stable temperament for a household with toddlers.
If you're looking for a couch potato to watch Netflix with, the traditional pick of the litter—the high-drive, high-energy spitfire—will make your life a living hell. They'll chew your baseboards. They'll bark at the mailman for three hours straight. They need a job. Most people don't have a job for a dog. They have a living room.
What Breeders Actually Mean
When a reputable breeder like those at the American Kennel Club (AKC) talk about the pick, they’re looking at specific traits.
- Topline: Is the back straight?
- Angulation: How do the joints sit?
- Temperament: Is the dog bold enough for the show ring?
If you aren't planning to spend your weekends in a suit running in circles at a dog show, these things don't matter to you. Not really. You need a dog that doesn't have separation anxiety and doesn't try to herd your neighbor's cat.
Temperament Testing vs. Gut Feeling
Most people pick a puppy because "he chose me." It’s a classic story. You walk in, one puppy runs up, and you’re convinced it’s destiny. In reality, that puppy might just be the one who happened to be awake at that exact second. Or maybe he’s the bully who pushes his siblings away from the food bowl.
Professional trainers often use the Volhard Puppy Aptitude Test. It’s a series of exercises done at seven weeks old to see how a dog reacts to pressure, noise, and new people.
- Social Attraction: Does the puppy come when called?
- Following: Does it follow a human?
- Restraint: How does it handle being held down?
- Elevation: How does it feel being off the ground?
A puppy that scores "1" across the board is a powerhouse. That’s your typical "pick." But that dog is also a handful. He’s likely to be dominant and aggressive if not handled by a pro. Most families actually want the "3" or "4" puppies. The middle-of-the-road guys. The ones who are social but not bossy.
The Hidden Cost of the Alpha
We love the word "Alpha." It sounds cool. But the pick of the litter often exhibits those alpha traits early on. They are the first to the teat. They grow the fastest. They explore the furthest.
In a working environment—think police dogs or search and rescue—you need that. You need a dog that won't quit. If you’re a hiker who spends six hours on the trail every Saturday, maybe you do want the pick. But if your idea of exercise is a brisk walk to the coffee shop, that high-drive dog is going to become destructive.
I’ve seen it a hundred times. A family buys the "star" of the litter, and six months later, the dog is in a shelter because he's "too much to handle." He wasn't a bad dog. He was just the wrong dog for that specific house.
The Science of Birth Order
Does birth order matter? Some people swear the firstborn is the strongest. Scientifically, it's a bit of a wash. Studies in canine neonatology suggest that while birth weight can vary, the "runt" often catches up within weeks. The pick of the litter isn't always the first one out of the birth canal. It’s the one that develops the best combination of physical traits and confidence during those first eight weeks of life.
Why the "Runt" is Sometimes the Real Winner
On the flip side, you have the runt. Everyone feels bad for the runt. People think they’re "saving" the small one. While the pick of the litter is the athlete, the runt is often the one who had to learn to be a bit more clever to get what they needed.
✨ Don't miss: Downtown Winter Park Historic District Photos: What Most People Get Wrong About Central Florida’s Soul
However, be careful. A "runt" can sometimes have underlying health issues, like a liver shunt or heart murmur. A true runt is just small. A "sickly" puppy is something else entirely. Always check the vet records. Don't let your heart make a decision that your bank account (and your tear ducts) will regret later.
How to Actually Choose Without Regret
You shouldn't be choosing the puppy anyway. The breeder should be choosing for you.
A good breeder spends 24 hours a day with these dogs. They know who is shy. They know who is a jerk. They know who loves to cuddle. When you tell a breeder, "I have three kids, a cat, and I work from home," they know exactly which puppy fits that vibe. If a breeder lets you just walk in and take the "pick" because you showed up first with cash, run away. That’s a puppy mill tactic.
Questions to Ask the Breeder
- "Which puppy is the most resilient when startled?"
- "Is there a puppy that settles down quickly after playtime?"
- "Which one is the most food-motivated?" (This makes training way easier).
- "Can I see the Volhard scores for the whole litter?"
Genetic Luck and the Environment
Even if you get the literal best dog in the world, the pick of the litter status only takes you so far. Nature vs. Nurture is a real thing. You can take a genetically perfect dog and ruin it with poor socialization.
The first 16 weeks of a dog's life are the "critical period." If you get the pick but leave him in a crate for ten hours a day, he’s going to have issues. If you get the "worst" puppy but spend every day training and socializing, you’ll end up with a better companion than the person who coasted on their dog's pedigree.
The Financial Side of the "Pick"
Sometimes breeders will charge more for the pick of the litter. Is it worth it?
Honestly, usually not for a pet owner. You're paying a premium for aesthetics. Unless you're going to breed the dog (which, please, leave that to the experts) or show the dog, those extra hundreds or thousands of dollars are just for bragging rights at the dog park.
And let's be real—nobody at the dog park cares about your dog's rear angulation. They care if your dog tries to steal their ball or hump their Labrador.
Real World Example: The Lab That Couldn't Quit
I knew a guy who insisted on the "pick" from a line of field-trial Labradors. This dog was a machine. He was beautiful, muscular, and had eyes like a hawk. But the owner lived in a suburban condo.
That dog ended up eating a hole through a drywall. Why? Because he was meant to be retrieving ducks in freezing water for eight hours a day, not sitting on a rug waiting for his owner to finish a Zoom call. The "pick" was too much dog. Meanwhile, his brother—the one who was a bit slower and a bit more "lazy"—was living his best life with a family down the street, sleeping on their kid's bed.
Who actually got the better dog?
Insights for Your Search
Stop looking for the "best" puppy in the litter. It's a trap. Start looking for the puppy that matches your energy level on your worst day, not your best day. If you’re tired after work, you need a dog that’s okay with being tired too.
Don't be afraid of the middle of the pack. The middle is where the balance is. The middle is where you find the dogs that are smart enough to learn but chill enough to hang out.
🔗 Read more: Colores modernos para casas interiores: Por qué el gris ya no es la respuesta
Actionable Next Steps
- Define your "Dog Persona": Write down what a Tuesday looks like for you. Not a Saturday. A Tuesday. Do you have 20 minutes for a walk or two hours?
- Interview Breeders, Not Puppies: Ask about temperament first. If they only talk about "champion bloodlines," they aren't listening to your needs.
- Request a Video: Ask for a video of the puppies playing together. Watch for the one that isn't bullying but also isn't cowering. That’s your sweet spot.
- Check the Health Guarantee: Regardless of where they rank in the litter, every puppy should have a health guarantee against genetic defects.
- Ignore the "Pick" Label: When you visit, ignore what the breeder calls the "pick." Sit on the floor and see which one interacts with you without being over-the-top frantic.
The reality is that the pick of the litter is a subjective title. For a hunter, it’s the one with the nose. For a show person, it’s the one with the strut. For you? It’s the one that’s going to be your best friend without driving you crazy. Choose the dog, not the title.