It is loud. That is the first thing you notice when you stand on the corner of Selby and Western in the middle of a Friday afternoon. It’s not the sound of sirens or industrial grinding, though. It’s the sound of history rubbing up against a very expensive, very hungry modern reality. You have the squeal of the 21 bus, the clinking of silverware from the patio at W.A. Frost, and the distant, heavy chime of the Cathedral of Saint Paul itself.
Cathedral Hill St Paul isn't a museum, even if the architecture tries to convince you otherwise.
Most people come here for the "Great Gatsby" vibes. They want to see the sandstone, the massive Victorian turrets, and the place where F. Scott Fitzgerald tried to find a sense of belonging. But if you actually live here, or spend enough time wandering the side streets like Laurel or Holly, you realize the neighborhood is basically a giant, beautiful contradiction. It is incredibly wealthy in spots, yet it feels strangely approachable. It’s a place where you can buy a $2 million mansion or a $12 sandwich, and both feel like the "correct" Cathedral Hill experience.
The Gilded Age Ghost That Never Left
To understand why this hill matters, you have to look at the ground. Literally. The neighborhood sits on a massive bluff overlooking the Mississippi River and downtown St. Paul. In the late 1800s, this was the ultimate flex for the railroad barons and lumber kings. If you were anybody in Minnesota, you built on the hill.
James J. Hill, the "Empire Builder," basically set the tone. His house on Summit Avenue is a 36,000-square-foot monster of red sandstone. Honestly, it’s a bit much. It has 22 fireplaces. Who needs 22 fireplaces? But that’s the point. The neighborhood was designed to show off.
Fitzgerald’s Complicated Relationship with the Hill
F. Scott Fitzgerald is the neighborhood’s unofficial mascot, but the reality is more nuanced. He was born here, lived in various row houses, and famously finished This Side of Paradise at 599 Summit Avenue. However, Fitzgerald always felt like an outsider looking in. He wasn't one of the ultra-wealthy kids; he was the talented kid living on the edge of their world.
When you walk past the Commodore Hotel, you aren't just looking at a building. You’re looking at the site of legendary 1920s parties. The Art Deco bar inside is original. If you sit there with a gin rickey, it doesn't take much imagination to see the ghosts of flappers. It’s one of the few places in the Twin Cities where the "Roaring Twenties" isn't a theme—it's just the wallpaper.
✨ Don't miss: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
The Architecture is More Than Just Pretty Houses
If you think all old houses look the same, Cathedral Hill St Paul will prove you wrong. It’s a chaotic mix. You have Richardsonian Romanesque (think heavy, dark stone and arches), Queen Anne (the colorful ones with the "gingerbread" trim), and Italianate styles.
Most of these homes were actually divided into apartments during the Great Depression and World War II. For a long time, the hill was kind of gritty. It wasn't the polished destination it is today. The "urban renewal" of the 1970s and 80s is what saved these structures, but it also started the gentrification process that defines the area now.
Check out the "Seven Sisters" on Summit. These are a row of nearly identical houses. They were built for the daughters of a wealthy businessman—or so the legend goes. The reality is usually more about real estate speculation, but the story sticks because it fits the vibe of the neighborhood.
Where the Locals Actually Eat and Hang Out
Forget the tourist traps. If you want the real soul of Cathedral Hill, you go to Moscow on the Hill. Get the vodka flight. It’s cold, it’s sharp, and it feels right when the Minnesota wind is whipping up the bluff.
Then there’s Nina’s Coffee Cafe. It’s located in the old Blair Arcade building. The floors creak. The ceilings are high. It’s the kind of place where people actually write novels, not just browse TikTok. It’s named after Nina Clifford, who ran the most famous brothel in St. Paul just down the hill. The city has a history of being a bit... colorful, and the neighborhood leans into that.
- The Food Scene: It’s dense. Within three blocks, you have Thai, Russian, French-inspired bistro fare, and classic American pub food.
- The Shopping: It’s mostly independent. You won't find a Gap here. You’ll find bookstores and antique shops that smell like old paper and beeswax.
- The Walkability: It is arguably the most walkable square mile in the entire state of Minnesota.
The Cathedral Itself: A Massive Granite Anchor
We have to talk about the Cathedral of Saint Paul. It’s the fourth-largest church in the United States. Whether you’re religious or not, the scale of it is intimidating.
🔗 Read more: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
The architect, Emmanuel Masqueray, was obsessed with light. When you go inside, the dome is massive. It’s inspired by St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome, but it has this distinctively Midwestern toughness to it. It’s built from St. Cloud granite. It’s meant to last forever.
The funny thing is, the Cathedral almost didn't happen on this spot. Archbishop John Ireland had to fight to get this land. Now, it serves as the literal and metaphorical North Star for the neighborhood. You can see that green copper dome from miles away. It’s how you know you’re almost home.
The "Secret" Spots You’ll Probably Miss
Most people stick to Selby and Summit. That’s a mistake.
Go to Maiden Lane. It’s a tiny, narrow street that feels like it belongs in London or Boston. It’s quiet. The houses are smaller, more intimate. It’s a reminder that Cathedral Hill wasn't just for the 1%. It was for the people who worked for them, too.
Then there’s the Overlook Park. It’s just a small patch of grass at the end of the hill, but the view of the downtown skyline at night is arguably the best in the city. It’s where people go to propose, to break up, or to just sit and realize how small they are compared to the river valley below.
Why Does This Neighborhood Still Matter?
In a world of "luxury" condos that all look like gray boxes, Cathedral Hill St Paul offers something authentic. It has "texture." You can feel the weight of the decisions made 150 years ago.
💡 You might also like: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
Is it perfect? No. It’s expensive. Parking is a nightmare—honestly, don't even try to find a spot on Selby during dinner rush. And the tension between preserving history and allowing new growth is always there. Some people hate the new apartment buildings going up; others say they bring the life the neighborhood needs to survive.
But that tension is what keeps it from becoming a theme park. It’s a living, breathing place. It’s where the past isn't just remembered; it’s lived in.
Practical Ways to Experience Cathedral Hill
If you're planning a visit or thinking about moving here, don't just do the "standard" tour. Here is how to actually see the place:
- Walk, don't drive. Park your car six blocks away in the residential zone and just wander. Look at the rooflines. Look at the iron fences.
- Visit the James J. Hill House. Yes, it’s a tourist thing, but the basement tour shows you the tech that was cutting-edge in 1891. It’s fascinating.
- Go to the University Club. Even if you aren't a member, the building is a masterpiece of Tudor style.
- Check out the "Fitzgerald Shortcut." Walk from his birthplace on Laurel to his favorite haunts on Selby. It's a short walk that covers his entire childhood.
- Eat at The Revival. It’s some of the best fried chicken in the North, and it’s housed in a building that feels like a cozy neighborhood secret.
The neighborhood isn't going anywhere. It’s survived economic crashes, the arrival of the interstate (which cut a huge scar through the city), and the changing tastes of the wealthy. It remains the heart of St. Paul because it refuses to be boring.
Actionable Insights for Your Visit
- Timing is everything: Visit on a Tuesday or Wednesday afternoon if you want to experience the quiet, "Old World" atmosphere without the weekend crowds.
- The "Summit Stroll": If you walk the length of Summit Avenue from the Cathedral to the river, you are walking one of the longest stretches of Victorian homes in the country. It's about 4.5 miles. Wear good shoes.
- Local Secret: The basement of the Blair Arcade has some of the coolest small businesses and a weirdly peaceful vibe that feels miles away from the street noise.
- Winter Warning: The hill is steep. If there’s a blizzard, stay off the side streets unless you have all-wheel drive and a lot of confidence.
Cathedral Hill is the rare place that actually lives up to its own hype. It’s beautiful, it’s complicated, and it’s undeniably St. Paul.