When Mel Brooks decided to skewer the legend of the Prince of Thieves in 1993, he didn't just need a guy who could handle a sword. He needed a guy who could mock the very idea of handling a sword while looking incredibly good doing it. Enter the Cary Elwes Robin Hood era. It was a weird time for movies. Kevin Costner had just dominated the box office with a gritty, Mullet-heavy version of the folk hero, and the world was ripe for a takedown.
Elwes was fresh off The Princess Bride. He already had that swashbuckling DNA. But what he brought to Robin Hood: Men in Tights wasn't just a repeat of Westley. It was something sharper.
The "Patriot" vs. The Parody
Most people forget how much of a direct middle finger this movie was to the 1991 blockbuster Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. You remember the one. It had the Bryan Adams power ballad and Alan Rickman chewing the scenery like a starving man at a buffet. But Costner’s refusal to even attempt an English accent became a Hollywood punchline.
Cary Elwes knew exactly what he was doing.
In the opening minutes of Men in Tights, Elwes looks directly at the camera and delivers the line that defined his take: "Because, unlike some other Robin Hoods, I can speak with an English accent." It was a surgical strike. It signaled to the audience that this wasn't just a Mel Brooks movie; it was a Cary Elwes showcase of comedic timing. He wasn't playing Robin Hood; he was playing a guy playing the most arrogant, charming, and self-aware version of Robin Hood ever conceived.
Why the Cary Elwes Robin Hood works when others failed
Parody is a dangerous game. If you go too broad, it’s just a series of fart jokes—though, let’s be honest, Brooks still put those in. But for a parody to actually stick the landing, the lead actor has to play it straight enough that the world feels real. Elwes has this specific brand of "sincere absurdity."
Think about the archery tournament.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
He’s wearing green spandex. He’s surrounded by idiots. Yet, Elwes handles the bow with the grace of a trained athlete. He brings a physical competence to the role that makes the jokes land harder. If he were clumsy, the humor would be physical slapstick. Because he’s actually cool, the humor comes from the subversion of that coolness.
Honestly, the chemistry between Elwes and the rest of the cast is what keeps the movie on the rails. You’ve got Dave Chappelle in his first film role as Ahchoo, Richard Lewis as a neurotic Prince John, and Amy Yasbeck as Maid Marian. Elwes acts as the "straight man" who is simultaneously the most ridiculous person in the room. It’s a tightrope walk. Most actors would fall off.
The Princess Bride Connection
It’s impossible to talk about this performance without acknowledging The Princess Bride. In a way, Westley was the dress rehearsal for Robin. Both characters are masters of the blade. Both are motivated by a singular, slightly goofy love. But where Westley is romantic and mysterious, the Cary Elwes Robin Hood is a ham. He’s the guy who knows he’s the hero of the story and wants to make sure the lighting is hitting his jawline just right.
Brooks reportedly sought out Elwes specifically because of that "Errol Flynn" quality. Flynn was the gold standard for Robin Hood in 1938. He had that twinkle in his eye. Elwes took that twinkle and turned it into a high-powered searchlight.
A Production of Chaotic Genius
The stories from the set of Men in Tights are almost as funny as the movie itself. Mel Brooks is a legendary taskmaster of comedy. He demands precision. Elwes has spoken in various interviews about the technical difficulty of the "Blinkin" scenes. Working with Mark Blankfield, who played the blind servant, required choreographed chaos.
They weren't just riffing.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The sword fights were legit. Elwes insisted on doing as much as he could, bringing a level of athleticism that most 90s comedies lacked. This is the "secret sauce" of the film. You can enjoy it as a kid because the action looks real, but you love it as an adult because the dialogue is biting.
There's a scene where Robin gets into a fight with Little John (played by the massive Eric Allan Kramer) on a tiny bridge over a stream that is literally two inches deep. The commitment Elwes shows to "drowning" in a puddle is a masterclass in physical comedy. He isn't afraid to look stupid. That’s the hallmark of a great comedic lead.
The Cultural Longevity of Men in Tights
Why do we still talk about this movie in 2026? Why does it show up in memes every time a new "serious" Robin Hood movie (like the 2010 Russell Crowe version or the 2018 Taron Egerton one) fails to find an audience?
It's because the Cary Elwes Robin Hood is the definitive "final word" on the character.
Once you’ve seen a hero break into a choreographed dance number while singing about being "manly men" in tights, it’s very hard to take a gritty reboot seriously. Brooks and Elwes effectively "deconstructed" the myth before deconstruction was a buzzword. They exposed the tropes:
- The magical accuracy of the arrows.
- The absurdity of the secret passages.
- The bizarre "saving the girl" dynamics.
The movie basically told the industry, "We’ve seen this story a thousand times, so let’s stop pretending it’s not a bit ridiculous."
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The Technical Brilliance Behind the Scenes
We should talk about the "look" of Elwes in this role. The costume design by Dodie Shepard was a brilliant satire of 1950s Technicolor films. The greens are too green. The feathers in the hat are too long.
And then there’s the hair.
Elwes’ hair in this movie deserves its own IMDB page. It is perfectly coiffed, never moving out of place even during a duel to the death. It adds to that layer of artifice. He looks like a toy. He looks like a character on a cereal box. This visual language tells the viewer exactly how to feel: don't take this seriously, but do pay attention.
A Legacy of Laughter
If you look at the career of Cary Elwes, he’s one of those rare actors who can pivot from horror (Saw) to drama (Glory) to high-concept comedy. But Robin remains his most "re-watchable" role for a reason. There is a joy in his performance. You can tell he’s having the time of his life.
Compare this to the 2018 Robin Hood where everyone looked miserable and the sets were covered in grey soot. The audience doesn't want soot. They want a guy who can split an arrow with another arrow and then look at the camera with a "can you believe I just did that?" expression.
What We Can Learn from Elwes’ Performance
Basically, Elwes taught us that charm is a weapon. In the film, his Robin Hood isn't just winning because he’s a better fighter; he’s winning because he’s more likable than the villains. He’s the person you want to hang out with in the woods.
How to Revisit the Legend
If you're planning a rewatch, don't just look for the big jokes. Watch Elwes in the background of scenes. Look at his reactions to the absurdity around him.
- Focus on the physical comedy: Notice how he uses his cape. It’s practically a character itself.
- Listen for the rhythm: Brooks writes comedy like music. Elwes hits every beat perfectly, especially in the rapid-fire exchanges with Roger Rees (the Sheriff of Rottingham).
- Compare it to the source: If you really want to appreciate the genius, watch ten minutes of the Costner version first. The satire becomes ten times sharper.
The Cary Elwes Robin Hood isn't just a role; it's a mood. It represents a time when movies were allowed to be purely fun without needing to set up a cinematic universe or a dark back-story. It’s a man, his tights, and a bow, making us laugh for three decades.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Next Movie Night
- Watch the "Special Features": If you can find the behind-the-scenes footage or the commentary by Mel Brooks, grab it. Hearing Elwes talk about the "English accent" joke reveals how much thought went into even the smallest jabs.
- Track the Evolution: Watch The Princess Bride followed by Men in Tights. You can see Elwes evolving his "hero" persona into a "satire of a hero" persona. It’s a brilliant acting arc.
- Check Out Elwes' Memoir: He wrote a book called As You Wish. While it focuses on The Princess Bride, it gives deep insight into his approach to physical roles and his collaboration with legendary directors, which clearly carried over to his time in Sherwood Forest.