You’ve seen them everywhere. They’re at weddings, hipster BBQ joints, and all over your Pinterest feed filled with layered salads or colorful cocktails. We're talking about canning jars with handles. They look rustic. They feel sturdy. They scream "farmhouse chic." But there is a massive, somewhat dangerous misunderstanding floating around the internet regarding what these things can actually do. If you try to use a glass mug with a handle to preserve your summer tomato harvest, you’re likely headed for a sticky, glass-shards-everywhere disaster in your kitchen.
It’s a naming problem. Marketing teams realized that "Mason jar" is a vibe people will pay for, so they slapped handles on glass jars and called them canning jars. They aren't. Not really.
The Structural Science of Why These Jars Break
Standard Mason jars, like those made by Ball or Kerr (now owned by Newell Brands), are engineered for high-heat stress. When you’re water-bath canning or pressure canning, the glass has to expand and contract evenly. Authentic canning jars are made of annealed glass, specifically designed to withstand the thermal shock of going from a warm counter into a boiling pot of water.
Jars with handles are a different beast entirely. The handle creates an uneven thickness in the glass. Think about it. Where the handle joins the body of the jar, the glass is significantly thicker than the surrounding walls. When you heat that jar up, the thin parts expand faster than the thick parts. This creates internal tension. Physics doesn't care about your aesthetic. That tension often leads to "thermal shock," where the jar simply snaps or explodes in the canner.
Honestly, I’ve seen people lose entire batches of expensive organic peaches because they thought a handle would make the jar easier to lift out of the pot. It’s a mess.
✨ Don't miss: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
Why the "Mason" Name is Misleading
You’ll often see "Mason" embossed on the side of these handled mugs. It's important to realize that "Mason" refers to the thread style—the screw-top design patented by John Landis Mason in 1858—not the quality of the glass or its suitability for heat processing. Most manufacturers of canning jars with handles explicitly state on the packaging "not for home canning" or "for cold beverages only."
Why do they do this? To protect themselves from lawsuits, sure. But also because the manufacturing process for "novelty" glass is cheaper. They aren't tempered the same way. The glass used in a handled mug is often soda-lime glass that hasn't been annealed for thermal endurance. It's meant for iced tea, not 240°F pressure canning.
Real-World Uses Where Handled Jars Actually Shine
Look, I’m not here to trash these jars completely. They are fantastic for what they are: durable, charming drinkware. If you’re hosting a backyard party, a handled jar is objectively better than a standard Mason jar.
- Better Grip. Condensation is the enemy of a firm hold. When you have a cold drink in a regular jar, the glass gets slippery. The handle solves this. It’s practical.
- Temperature Buffer. If you’re drinking something hot—like mulled cider—the handle keeps your hand away from the heat. This is the one time the handle helps with temperature, ironically.
- Portion Control. Most handled jars come in 16-ounce or 24-ounce sizes. They’re the perfect "pint" or "pint-and-a-half" vessels for smoothies or meal-prepped overnight oats.
I personally use them for sourdough starter. Since I'm not putting the starter through a heat-processing cycle, the handle makes it easy to pull the jar out of the back of the fridge. It's convenient. It’s basically a mug with a lid.
🔗 Read more: Bird Feeders on a Pole: What Most People Get Wrong About Backyard Setups
The Lidding Issue
Another thing people miss is the seal. A real canning jar has a very specific rim. It’s smooth, flat, and designed to interface perfectly with a plastisol-lined metal lid to create a vacuum seal. Many canning jars with handles have slight irregularities on the rim. They might look flat, but even a microscopic dip means your lid won't seal properly.
If you’re trying to ferment sauerkraut, you might think a handled jar is fine since there’s no heat involved. But if the lid doesn't seat perfectly, you're inviting mold and oxygen into your ferment. Stick to the classics for anything involving food safety.
Finding the Good Stuff: What to Look For
If you’re dead set on buying these, don't just grab the cheapest four-pack at a dollar store. Those are notorious for "lead leaching" or simply shattering if you drop an ice cube into them too hard.
Check the bottom of the jar. You want to see a reputable manufacturer's mark. Libbey makes some decent handled jars that are sturdy enough for commercial dishwasher use. Golden Harvest is another brand often found in big-box stores that produces handled jars; they are great for gifting dry cookie mixes or "soup in a jar" kits, but again, please don't boil them.
💡 You might also like: Barn Owl at Night: Why These Silent Hunters Are Creepier (and Cooler) Than You Think
A Quick Guide to Glass Safety
- Check for "Thermal Shock" ratings. If the box doesn't mention it, assume it can't handle heat.
- Inspect the handle seams. If you see air bubbles where the handle meets the jar, that’s a structural weak point.
- Weight test. Real canning-grade glass feels "dense." If the jar feels as light as a standard drinking glass, it's definitely not for preserving.
The Expert Consensus
The National Center for Home Food Preservation (NCHFP) is the gold standard for this stuff. Their stance is pretty clear: they don't recommend using "commercial" jars or novelty jars for home canning. This includes those cute handled ones. They specifically point out that the glass is thinner and the shapes are not conducive to proper heat distribution.
I’ve talked to veteran "canners"—people who have put up 500 jars a year since the 70s. They all have the same story. Someone gave them a handled jar, they tried to use it for jelly, and the bottom fell off in the water bath. It’s a rite of passage you should probably avoid.
Practical Next Steps for Your Kitchen
If you already own a set of canning jars with handles, keep them! They are wonderful for iced coffee, organizing pens on a desk, or holding tea lights for a wedding centerpiece. But if you are planning to preserve food this season, go out and buy a fresh flat of Ball or Kerr wide-mouth jars.
When you start your next project, do this:
- Dedicate handled jars to "Fresh Use." Label them or keep them in a separate cupboard so you don't accidentally mix them with your actual canning stock.
- Buy New Lids. Even if you're using handled jars for "refrigerator pickles" (which don't require boiling), always use new lids to ensure a tight fit.
- Test for Heat. Before putting a hot liquid in a handled jar, "temper" it by running it under warm tap water first. Never pour boiling liquid into a cold glass jar of any kind, handle or no handle.
Safety isn't about being paranoid; it's about knowing your tools. A handled jar is a mug. A Mason jar is a tool. Treat them accordingly and you’ll save yourself a lot of cleaning and a potential trip to the urgent care for glass cuts.
Stay safe and keep those handles for your margaritas.