Rockstar Games has never been shy about making people uncomfortable. It’s kinda their thing. But even for a series that lets you solicit sex workers and run over pedestrians, the mission By the Book GTA V hit a different nerve back in 2013. It wasn't just the violence. It was the lack of choice. Usually, Grand Theft Auto gives you an out—a way to play the "good" bad guy. Not here.
You’re forced into a basement. You’re forced to pick up tools. You’re forced to hurt a man who is clearly innocent of the crimes the FIB (Rockstar’s parody of the FBI) thinks he committed.
Honestly, it’s one of the few moments in the game where the satire feels like a punch to the gut rather than a wink to the camera. Most players remember it as the "torture mission." If you played it when it launched, or even now in the 4K remasters, the visceral nature of Trevor Philips pulling teeth or using a car battery stays with you. It’s brutal.
The Narrative Trap of By the Book
The mission kicks off with Michael De Santa and Dave Norton heading to a high-stakes meeting, but the real "action" happens with Trevor and Mr. K (Ferdinand Kerimov). The FIB wants information about an Azerbaijani figure named Tahir Javan. They’re convinced Mr. K knows something. He doesn't. Or at least, he doesn't know enough to satisfy the bloodthirsty agents in charge.
What makes By the Book GTA V so effective—and so hated—is the switching mechanic. You jump back and forth. One minute, you're Michael, looking through a sniper scope at a party, trying to identify a target based on vague descriptions. The next, you're Trevor, "extracting" those descriptions from a man who is screaming for mercy.
It creates this nauseating feedback loop.
You need the info to progress as Michael, but the only way to get it is to commit atrocities as Trevor. Rockstar intentionally designed this to be clunky. The controls for the torture segments are intimate. You aren't just pressing a button to "interrogate." You’re rotating the analog stick to pull a tooth. You’re tapping to swing a wrench. It’s meant to make you feel complicit.
💡 You might also like: Finding 5 Letter Words Starting with AI Is Harder Than You Think
The Political Point Rockstar Was Trying to Make
Some critics at the time, including writers at The Guardian and IGN, argued the mission was gratuitous. They weren't necessarily wrong about the gore. However, Dan Houser and the writing team at Rockstar North weren't just trying to be edgy for the sake of sales.
They were mocking the post-9/11 "enhanced interrogation" culture.
During the mission’s finale, after Trevor finally lets Mr. K go instead of killing him, he gives a monologue that basically spells out the game’s thesis. He tells Ferdinand that torture is useless for getting information. It’s only useful for the person doing the torturing—a way to exert power or "pay the bills" for the agency involved.
"Torture's for the torturer," Trevor says. It’s a rare moment of lucidity from a character who is usually a total psychopath. He knows the FIB is full of it. He knows the information could have been gathered through a simple conversation. But the bureaucracy demanded a show.
Why It Almost Got Banned
In certain territories, By the Book GTA V faced massive pushback. In Japan, for instance, the mission had to be edited for the CERO Z rating. You couldn't actually see the torture taking place in the same way Western audiences did. In the UK, politicians like Keith Vaz spoke out against the game, though that was par for the course for GTA releases.
The controversy didn't just come from outside the industry. Even fans were split.
Some players felt it crossed a line because, unlike the rest of the game, there was no "Gold Medal" path that allowed you to skip the violence. To finish the game, you had to do it. You couldn't be a pacifist. You couldn't find a secret back door. You had to pick up the pliers.
This forced participation is what separates GTA V from something like Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 and its infamous "No Russian" mission. In No Russian, you could choose not to shoot the civilians. In By the Book, Trevor doesn't give you that option.
Technical Details and Mission Design
If we look at the mechanics, the mission is actually quite complex for an early 2010s title. It uses:
✨ Don't miss: How To Make Money Grand Theft Auto 5: Stop Wasting Time On Low-Payout Grinds
- Real-time character switching that updates the world state instantly.
- Dynamic objective markers that change based on the "accuracy" of the information Trevor extracts.
- Heart rate monitors for the victim that you have to manage—if Mr. K’s heart stops, you have to use an adrenaline shot to revive him so you can keep going.
That last part is particularly dark. It’s a gamified version of a nightmare.
From a speedrunning perspective, the mission is a notorious "time loss" section. There is no way to skip the dialogue or the animations. You are locked into the pacing of the FIB’s incompetence. Michael spends a lot of time waiting for Trevor to get the right description (the target is left-handed, he smokes, he has a beard).
Misconceptions About the "Correct" Way to Play
A lot of people think you can minimize the damage to Mr. K to get a better score. Not really. While you can earn a Gold Medal by using all the different "tools" at least once and not letting Mr. K’s heart stop, the narrative outcome is identical.
There is no "hidden" ending where Mr. K walks away unscathed.
The game wants you to feel the weight of what happened. When Trevor drives him to the airport at the end, the tone shifts from chaotic to somber. It’s one of the few times the radio is turned off by default. The silence in the car is deafening.
The Legacy of By the Book in 2026
Looking back, By the Book GTA V served as a turning point for how we discuss violence in media. It wasn't "fun" violence like a high-speed chase. It was "ugly" violence.
In the years since, games like The Last of Us Part II have leaned even harder into this "violence that makes you feel bad" trope. But Rockstar did it first in a massive, mainstream sandbox. They proved that even in a game about stealing cars and flying jets, they could force a global audience to confront the reality of state-sanctioned cruelty.
It remains a masterclass in uncomfortable storytelling. It’s a mission that most people only want to play once, yet nobody ever forgets.
To truly understand the mission's impact, you have to look at how Trevor interacts with the world afterward. He doesn't regret it—he's Trevor—but the game uses that event to cement the FIB as the true villains of Los Santos. The criminals are bad, sure, but the people with the badges are worse.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Pathfinder 2e Core Rulebook PDF: What the Remaster Actually Changed
If you're revisiting this mission today, keep an eye on the dialogue Michael and Dave share while waiting at the house. It’s full of subtle jabs at the inefficiency of government intelligence that are easy to miss while you're distracted by Trevor's basement antics.
Actionable Insights for Players:
- To achieve the Gold Medal, ensure you use the Large Wrench, Pliers, Electric Cables, and Water Jug at least once each.
- Do not allow Mr. K to go into cardiac arrest; if his heart rate flatlines, use the adrenaline immediately to avoid a mission failure.
- When playing as Michael, wait for the target to light a cigarette before taking the shot; it is the most reliable way to confirm his identity among the other NPCs at the party.
- Pay attention to the target's hand; he is left-handed, which is a key identifying marker during the final sniper sequence.
The mission is a grim necessity for 100% completion, but it serves as a vital piece of the game's broader critique of American power structures. Don't rush through the final drive to the airport; Trevor’s dialogue there provides the actual context for why the preceding twenty minutes of gameplay were so intentionally repulsive.