Walk into the corner of 37th and Nicollet and the first thing you notice isn't the smell of yeast or the sight of a perfectly laminated croissant. It's the noise. Not loud, obnoxious noise, but the specific, humming vibration of a neighborhood that has decided this specific 3,000-square-foot space is its living room. Butter Bakery Cafe Minneapolis isn't just a place to grab a quick caffeine fix before your commute; it's a social experiment that actually worked.
People come here for the biscuits. They stay because Suzie—or whoever is behind the counter that day—actually remembers their name.
It's rare. Most cafes in the Twin Cities try too hard to be "industrial chic" or "minimalist Scandi." Butter Bakery Cafe feels like your grandmother’s kitchen if your grandmother happened to be an expert in sustainable business practices and community outreach. It’s warm. It’s messy in a way that feels lived-in. It’s real.
The Mission Behind the Muffin
You can't talk about this place without talking about Dan Swenson-Klatt. He’s the guy who moved the shop from its original, smaller spot down the street to this larger, solar-powered LEED-certified building years ago. He didn't just want to sell more muffins. He wanted to build a bridge.
The "bridge" isn't metaphorical. The cafe shares a building with Nicollet Square, which provides housing for young adults who have experienced homelessness or are aging out of the foster care system. This isn't just a landlord-tenant situation. Butter Bakery Cafe Minneapolis serves as a job training site. If you see a young person behind the counter looking a bit nervous as they foam your latte, they’re likely part of the internship program. They're learning. They're gaining the kind of "soft skills" that corporate recruiters talk about but rarely know how to teach.
Honesty is important here. Sometimes the service isn't lightning-fast. If you’re in a massive rush to get to a 9:00 AM meeting in Downtown Minneapolis, maybe go somewhere with a drive-thru. But if you want to support a business that prioritizes human development over high-speed turnover, you wait the extra three minutes. It’s worth it.
Why the Food Actually Holds Up
Social missions are great, but if the coffee tastes like battery acid, nobody comes back. Thankfully, that's not the case here. The menu is surprisingly deep for a neighborhood joint.
📖 Related: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
Let's talk about the Buttermilk Biscuits.
They are dense. They are salty. They have that golden, craggy top that only comes from someone who knows they shouldn't overwork the dough. You get them with jam, or you get them as the base for a breakfast sandwich that will effectively ruin your productivity for the next two hours. In the best way possible.
They also do a "Baker's Choice" system. It keeps things from getting boring. One day it might be a ginger-pear scone that actually tastes like ginger; the next, it’s a savory muffin packed with herbs and cheese. They use local ingredients whenever they can, sourcing from places like Hope Creamery. You can taste the difference in the fat content. High-quality butter makes high-quality crusts. Simple math.
The Physical Space and the Vibe
The layout is a bit funky. There are high ceilings and big windows that let in that brutal but beautiful Minnesota winter sun.
You’ll see:
- Freelancers hunched over MacBooks.
- Retirees reading the actual, physical newspaper.
- Moms with strollers navigating the wide aisles.
- Students from nearby high schools grabbing a cookie after class.
It's one of the few places left where you don't feel like you’re being "turned" by the staff. You know that feeling? When a server hovers because they want your table for the next paying customer? You don't get that here. You can sit with a single cup of tea for an hour and nobody will look at you sideways.
The walls usually feature local art. Sometimes it's great. Sometimes it's weird. But it’s always local. That’s the recurring theme. Butter Bakery Cafe Minneapolis isn't trying to be a franchise. It’s trying to be a destination for the 3700 block of Nicollet.
👉 See also: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong
Sustainability Isn't Just a Buzzword
They take the "green" stuff seriously. We’re talking composting. We’re talking solar panels on the roof. We’re talking about a commitment to zero waste that most businesses just pay lip service to.
They were early adopters of the Minnesota Department of Commerce’s energy efficiency programs. They don't just recycle cans; they think about the lifecycle of their packaging. When you carry out a sandwich, it’s usually in compostable wrap. It costs the business more. It’s a fact. But Dan and his team have baked those costs into their philosophy because they think it's the right way to run a shop in 2026.
What to Know Before You Go
If you’re heading there for the first time, there are a few quirks to be aware of.
Parking can be a pain. It’s South Minneapolis. The lot is small, and Nicollet is a busy street. If you can’t find a spot in the tiny lot, look on the side streets, but watch the winter parking restrictions. Minneapolis meter maids are notoriously efficient, and a $45 ticket is a quick way to sour a $5 latte.
Also, they close earlier than some of the late-night hangouts. This isn't a midnight oil kind of place. Check their hours before you drive across town, especially on Sundays.
What to Order:
✨ Don't miss: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like
- The Biscuits and Gravy (if it's on the special board).
- A Cafe Miel. They do the honey-cinnamon balance better than most.
- Any of the scones. Seriously. They aren't the dry, hockey-puck style you find at Starbucks.
The Impact of Community Support
Small businesses are struggling. Inflation hit the Twin Cities hard over the last few years, and the cost of flour and eggs has gone through the roof. Butter Bakery Cafe Minneapolis has stayed afloat because the neighborhood refused to let it fail.
During the rough patches of the mid-2020s, you saw people buying gift cards they never intended to use. You saw people tipping 50%. Why? Because people realized that if Butter closed, Nicollet Avenue would lose its heart. It’s a symbiotic relationship. The cafe feeds the people, and the people sustain the cafe.
Navigating the Menu: Not Just Sugar
A lot of people think "bakery" means "sugar bomb."
Butter does plenty of savory stuff too. Their lunch menu features soups that actually taste like they were made in a pot on a stove, not squeezed out of a plastic bag.
Their grilled cheese is a sleeper hit.
It’s simple.
It’s bread, cheese, and a ridiculous amount of butter.
But they use good bread. That’s the secret. When the crumb is right, the toast is right.
And if you’re gluten-free or vegan? They try. They usually have at least one or two options that don't feel like an afterthought. It’s hard to do high-end gluten-free baking, but their GF cookies are surprisingly chewy rather than sandy.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
To get the most out of your trip to Butter Bakery Cafe Minneapolis, don't just treat it like a transaction.
- Go during the "off hours": Between 10:00 AM and 11:30 AM is the sweet spot. The breakfast rush is over, and the lunch crowd hasn't quite descended. You’ll actually get a choice of seating.
- Talk to the staff: Ask what’s fresh. The "Baker's Choice" exists for a reason—it’s usually what the kitchen was most excited about that morning.
- Bring your own mug: They appreciate the sustainability effort, and every little bit helps reduce waste.
- Check the bulletin board: If you want to know what’s actually happening in King Field or East Harriet, the physical board by the door is better than any Facebook group.
- Combine your trip: Walk a few blocks down to check out the other local shops on Nicollet. It’s a walkable stretch of the city that deserves more foot traffic.
Butter Bakery Cafe remains a testament to what happens when a business decides to care about its neighbors as much as its bottom line. It’s not perfect, but it’s honest. And in a world of polished, corporate-owned coffee shops, honesty tastes a lot better than a burnt espresso shot.