He was supposed to be the "Quarterback Whisperer." That was the label, anyway. When the New York Giants hired Brian Daboll back in 2022, the fan base didn't just want wins—they wanted a pulse. They wanted the guy who turned Josh Allen from a chaotic talent into a supernova to do the same for a franchise that had been stuck in the mud since the Obama administration.
And for a second, it worked.
The 2022 season was magic. We saw Daboll in that blue windbreaker, screaming on the sidelines, living every snap with a frantic energy that East Rutherford hadn't seen in years. That road playoff win against the Vikings? It felt like the start of a dynasty. Daboll walked away with the NFL Coach of the Year trophy, and for the first time in forever, Giants fans weren't looking at mock drafts in October.
But the NFL moves fast. Brutally fast.
Fast forward to mid-November 2025, and the vibe had completely soured. On November 10, 2025, the Giants officially pulled the plug, firing Brian Daboll after a dismal 2-8 start. He left town with a regular-season record of 20-40-1. It's a staggering fall from grace. How does a Coach of the Year end up with the fifth-worst winning percentage in franchise history?
📖 Related: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
The Jaxson Dart Gamble and the End of the Road
The 2025 season was basically a "Daboll on trial" campaign. John Mara and Steve Tisch had already given him a pass for the 3-14 disaster in 2024, citing the mess at quarterback and a roster that was still under construction. But 2025 was different. They had their guy.
The Giants traded back into the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft to grab Jaxson Dart at No. 25. Finally, Daboll had the mobile, aggressive passer he’d been begging for. This was the vision.
The weirdest part? The offense actually got better. Statistically, at least. In 2025, the Giants jumped to No. 9 in first-quarter points per drive. They were actually scripting plays that worked. But then, the wheels would just... fall off. They blew four fourth-quarter leads in ten games. Dart, while showing flashes of brilliance, was getting hit constantly. Daboll’s scheme relied heavily on QB runs—Dart led all quarterbacks in designed runs before he was sidelined with multiple concussions.
You can’t build a franchise on a quarterback who is constantly in the blue tent. By the time the Bears beat them in Week 10, the locker room felt fractured. The "grit" was gone.
👉 See also: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Why the "Whisperer" Reputation Faded
If you talk to people around the building, the issues weren't just about the box score. It was the culture.
- The Martindale Feud: The public fallout with former defensive coordinator Wink Martindale was the first real crack. You can't have your top two coaches acting like teenagers on a reality show.
- The Sideline Meltdowns: We all saw the clips. Daboll berating Daniel Jones, then Mike Kafka, then anyone in a five-foot radius. That fire is great when you're 9-7-1. It’s exhausting when you're 2-8.
- Development Stalls: While Malik Nabers turned into a legitimate superstar, the rest of the roster felt stagnant. The offensive line, despite endless investment, remained a revolving door of "what-ifs."
Honestly, it felt like Daboll was trying to outsmart the game rather than manage the team. He took over play-calling in 2024, then handed some back, then took it again. It was frantic.
What’s Next for Brian Daboll?
Don't expect him to be out of work for long. In the NFL, "failed" head coaches with good offensive minds are like gold. As of January 2026, the rumors are already swirling.
The Tennessee Titans apparently have him on their interview list. They have Cam Ward, a young QB who fits exactly what Daboll likes to do. There’s also the nightmare scenario for Big Blue fans: the Philadelphia Eagles. Reports from insiders like Dianna Russini suggest Nick Sirianni might want Daboll as an offensive coordinator. Imagine Daboll in Philly, working with Jalen Hurts and Saquon Barkley, twice a year against the Giants. It’s enough to make a Giants fan sick.
✨ Don't miss: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
He’s still a "QB guru" in the eyes of the league. He helped develop Hurts and Tua Tagovailoa at Alabama. He made Josh Allen a star. Even with the Giants' struggles, he clearly knows how to move the ball—he just couldn't figure out how to win the locker room for the long haul.
The Post-Daboll Giants: A New Era?
While Daboll looks for his next gig, the Giants are moving in a completely different direction. They’ve been heavily linked to John Harbaugh, searching for that "program builder" stability they thought they had with Tom Coughlin.
The mess Daboll left behind isn't easy to clean up. The 2026 draft order has the Giants holding the No. 5 pick. They have a young roster with pieces like Nabers and Abdul Carter, but they lack an identity.
Daboll was a gamble on a specific style of football. It was "point-guard" quarterbacking and high-variance aggression. It was fun for a year. Then it was stressful. Then it was over.
Actionable Insights for Following the Giants Coaching Search:
- Monitor the Titans Interview: If Daboll lands the Tennessee job, keep an eye on how he manages Cam Ward’s carries. It’ll tell you if he learned his lesson about protecting his QB's health.
- Watch the Eagles' OC Spot: If the "Daboll to Philly" rumors come true, expect the Giants-Eagles rivalry to reach a fever pitch by September.
- Draft Watch: With the No. 5 pick, the Giants are in a prime spot to either grab a franchise tackle to protect Jaxson Dart or trade back to recoup the picks they lost in the Daboll-era trades.