The year was 1993. TGIF reigned supreme. Somewhere between the slapstick of Full House and the family dynamics of Step by Step, a curly-haired kid named Cory Matthews walked onto our screens. Most people think they remember boy meets world season 1, but usually, they’re just remembering the 90s aesthetic. They remember the oversized flannels. They remember the hair.
Honestly, it’s a lot weirder and smarter than that.
Looking back now, the first season is a strange beast. It isn’t the teen drama it eventually became. It’s a middle-school sitcom about a kid who is basically a C-student trying to navigate a world that makes no sense. Cory isn't a hero. He's kind of a brat. And that’s exactly why it works.
The Feeny Factor and the Sixth Grade Struggle
If you ask any fan about boy meets world season 1, the first thing they bring up is Mr. Feeny. George Feeny, played by the legendary William Daniels, wasn’t just a teacher. He was the neighbor. He was the antagonist. He was the moral compass.
In "Cory's Alternative Friends," we see the first real glimpse of the show's soul. Cory wants a pair of expensive sneakers to fit in. Classic 90s trope, right? But the show twists it. Instead of just being a lesson about consumerism, it turns into a story about Topanga Lawrence.
Wait. Topanga.
People forget how bizarre Topanga was in the beginning. Before she was the "it girl" of the late 90s, she was the kid drawing on her face with lipstick and chanting about the earth. She was the outcast. Season 1 Cory didn’t love her. He was terrified of her. That dynamic is so much more interesting than the soulmate narrative the later seasons forced down our throats. It felt real. Every middle schooler has that one classmate who is just too much, and the writers nailed that discomfort.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Ben Savage and the Art of the "Everyman"
Ben Savage was only twelve when the pilot aired. Most child actors at that time were polished. They had "sitcom timing" that felt like they were waiting for the laugh track. Savage was different. He was fidgety. He looked genuinely confused half the time.
The chemistry between Cory and Shawn Hunter (Rider Strong) in these early episodes is where the magic started. Shawn wasn't the "bad boy" yet. He was just a kid from a "different part of town." The show didn't lean into the trailer park backstory until later, but the seeds were there. In "Teacher's Bet," when Cory tries to teach the class to prove it's easy, and he realizes Shawn is actually struggling with the material, the show stops being a comedy. It becomes a commentary on privilege. In 1993. On a Friday night.
That Missing Sister and the Changing Cast
Let's talk about the weird stuff. Specifically, the stuff people get wrong.
There’s this Mandela Effect thing where people think Morgan Matthews was always the same actress. Nope. Lily Nicksay played the original Morgan in boy meets world season 1. She was adorable, funny, and then she literally disappeared into thin air for a while before being replaced by Lindsay Ridgeway.
And then there's the cafeteria.
If you rewatch the first season, there’s a character named Mr. Williams. He was the other teacher. He was cool. He wore sweaters. He was basically the "anti-Feeny." By season 2? Gone. Same with some of the background kids like Minkus. Stuart Minkus was the nerd archetype, played by Lee Norris. He was the foil to Cory’s laziness. While the show eventually outgrew the "nerd vs. cool kid" dynamic, Minkus provided some of the best one-liners of the debut season. His absence in the middle years felt like a gap in the show's DNA until his brief, hilarious return at graduation.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The Episodes That Actually Matter
If you’re going to revisit the first 22 episodes, you can’t just binge them all and expect gold. Some are definitely "filler" where Cory just gets into trouble and Eric (Will Friedle) mopes about a girl. But a few stand out as essential television:
- The Pilot: It sets the stage perfectly. Cory tries to listen to a Phillies game during class. Feeny catches him. It establishes the "fence" dynamic that would last seven years.
- Father Knows Less: This is the one where Cory stays up to watch a baseball game with Alan. It deals with the guilt of letting your parents down. It’s subtle and heartbreaking.
- The Fugitive: Shawn hides out in Cory's room because he blew up a mailbox. It sounds like a "Very Special Episode," but it avoids the clichés by focusing on the loyalty between the two boys.
Why Season 1 Hits Different Today
We live in an era of "prestige TV." Everything has to be dark, gritty, or meta. Boy meets world season 1 is none of those things, yet it feels more honest than most modern YA shows. It captures the specific anxiety of being eleven years old.
You aren't a child, but you aren't a teenager. You're in this weird limbo where your biggest problem is a geography test or a girl who wants to "bond" by humming.
The production value is peak 90s. The kitchen set feels lived-in. The Matthews house actually looks like a middle-class home in Philadelphia, not a catalog showroom. There's a warmth to the film stock that digital cameras just can't replicate. It feels like home.
The Alan and Amy Dynamic
We have to give props to William Russ and Betsy Randle. Usually, sitcom parents are either idiots or saints. Alan and Amy Matthews were just... people. Alan was a guy who worked at a tool warehouse. He got cranky. He wanted to watch the game. Amy was smart and didn't take any of Cory's nonsense.
In boy meets world season 1, the parents are the anchors. They aren't just there to deliver the moral at the end; they are actively navigating their own lives. When Alan tells Cory that he’s disappointed in him, you feel it. It’s not a scripted "TV moment." It feels like a real dad who had a long day at work and is tired of his son acting out.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Final Verdict on the Debut
Is it the best season? Probably not. Season 4 and 5 usually take that crown for the "Will They/Won't They" drama and the cult of Eric Matthews (who became a surrealist comedy genius later on).
However, season 1 is the most grounded. It’s the only season where the show is truly about a "boy" meeting the "world." Later, it became "Teens Meeting Relationships."
If you haven't watched it since you were a kid, go back. Look past the bowl cuts and the baggy jeans. Look at the way Feeny looks at Cory with a mix of exhaustion and genuine hope. Look at how the show treats its outcasts. It’s a masterclass in building a world that people would want to live in for seven years.
Actionable Insights for the Ultimate Rewatch
To get the most out of your return to John Adams High, follow these steps:
- Watch for the Background Gags: The chalkboard in Feeny's room often has jokes or relevant historical facts that mirror the episode's theme.
- Track the "Minkus" Moments: Count how many times Stuart actually outsmarts the adults. It’s more often than you think.
- Compare the "Two Morgans": If you're a real nerd, watch the season 1 finale and then skip to the season 3 premiere to see the jarring transition between the two actresses playing Cory's sister.
- Listen to the Theme Song: The season 1 theme is a circus-like instrumental that sounds nothing like the 90s rock theme of the later years. It sets a completely different, more whimsical tone.
- Spot the 90s Tech: From giant cordless phones to mentions of floppy disks, the tech is a time capsule of a world just on the edge of the internet revolution.