He’s kind of a mess. Honestly, if you’ve watched Andrew Gower’s portrayal of Charles Edward Stuart in the Starz hit series, you probably have a complicated relationship with the man. One minute you’re laughing at his "Mark me!" catchphrase, and the next, you’re screaming at the screen because his ego is literally walking Jamie and Claire Fraser straight into the blood-soaked disaster of Culloden. Bonnie Prince Charlie Outlander depictions aren't just for drama; they tap into a very real, very tragic historical figure who was far more nuanced—and far more desperate—than a simple caricature of a spoiled royal.
The show makes him look like a pampered dreamer. Is that fair? History says: mostly.
But there is a massive difference between the "Young Pretender" who sipped wine in Parisian salons and the man who spent five months running for his life through the Scottish Highlands with a massive bounty on his head. If you want to understand why Outlander fans can’t stop talking about him, you have to look at the gap between the man Charles thought he was and the leader the Jacobites actually needed.
The "Mark Me" Phenomenon and the Real Charles
Let’s talk about that catchphrase. "Mark me" became a meme almost instantly. In the show, it's used to show his need for attention, his insistence that everyone around him acknowledges his divine right to rule. It makes him feel small. Petty.
Interestingly, Andrew Gower actually found that phrase in his research, though he leaned into it to give the Prince a specific verbal tic. In reality, the Prince was obsessed with his image. He was born in Rome, raised in a gilded cage, and told from birth by his father, James Francis Edward Stuart, that Great Britain was a stolen property that belonged to their family. Imagine being told your whole life that you are a literal king in exile. It warps a person.
By the time we meet Bonnie Prince Charlie Outlander style in Season 2, he’s broke but acting rich. He’s trying to secure funding from the French court, specifically King Louis XV. The show captures this perfectly—the desperate vanity of a man who has nothing but a name. He truly believed that the moment he stepped foot on Scottish soil, the entire country would rise as one.
He was wrong.
Many of the Highland clan chiefs were actually pretty skeptical. They remembered the failed uprisings of 1715 and 1719. They knew the cost of failure wasn't just a lost battle; it was the total destruction of their way of life. When Charles landed at Glenfinnan in 1745, he didn't even have the French troops he promised. He had seven men. Seven.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
It was his sheer, stubborn charisma that convinced people like Donald Cameron of Lochiel to join him. Without that "bonnie" charm, the '45 rebellion would have died on a beach in the Hebrides.
The Strategy That Failed at Culloden
In Outlander, we see Jamie Fraser trying to play both sides, desperately attempting to sabotage the rebellion because he knows—thanks to Claire’s 20th-century knowledge—that it ends in fire and execution. The Prince, however, is portrayed as militarily incompetent.
Is that accurate?
Mostly, yeah. Charles wasn't a general. He was a symbol. Lord George Murray was the actual tactical brain behind the Jacobite army, and the two of them hated each other. Charles didn't trust Murray because Murray was a professional soldier who understood the reality of logistics, hunger, and superior British firepower. Charles, on the other hand, believed in "God’s will" and the unstoppable nature of a Highland charge.
The Fatal Retreat from Derby
This is the big "what if" of history. The Jacobites actually got as far south as Derby, just about 125 miles from London. Panic was hitting the capital. King George II was reportedly packing his bags.
If Charles had pushed forward, he might have actually won.
But his commanders, led by Murray, saw they were being squeezed by three different British armies. They didn't have the popular support in England they expected. They retreated. Charles was devastated. He spent the rest of the retreat in a sulk, often drinking heavily and losing the respect of the men who were freezing and starving for his crown.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
By the time they reached Culloden Moor on April 16, 1746, the army was exhausted. Charles insisted on fighting on a boggy, flat moor that was literally the worst possible terrain for Highland tactics. He wanted a "gentleman’s battle." He got a massacre.
Why the "Bonnie" Prince Became a Fugitive
After the slaughter at Culloden, Charles didn't die with his men. He fled.
This is where the Bonnie Prince Charlie Outlander narrative gets really dark. While the Duke of Cumberland’s "Redcoats" were busy "pacifying" the Highlands—which is a polite way of saying they were committing war crimes, burning homes, and executing anyone with a kilt—Charles was hiding in caves.
- He dressed as a maid named "Betty Burke."
- He was smuggled to the Isle of Skye by Flora Macdonald.
- He spent months living off the land with a £30,000 bounty on his head (millions in today's money).
The wildest part? Nobody betrayed him. Not one impoverished Highlander handed him over for a life-changing sum of money. That loyalty is why the legend of the Bonnie Prince persists today, despite his personal failings. He represented the hope of an independent Scotland, even if he was personally ill-equipped to deliver it.
The Sad Reality of His Later Life
If you’re waiting for a happy ending for Charles in the later seasons of Outlander or in history books, stop. It doesn't exist.
After escaping to France, he became a PR nightmare for the French government. Eventually, they kicked him out. He wandered Europe, became an alcoholic, and treated his mistress, Clementina Walkinshaw, and their daughter quite poorly. He was a man who lived the first 25 years of his life for a single moment of glory and the next 40 years mourning its loss.
When he finally died in Rome in 1788, the Jacobite cause was already dead. The Highland Clearances had gutted the culture he claimed to love. The tartans were banned. The pipes were silenced.
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
What Outlander Gets Right (and Wrong)
The show does an incredible job of capturing the vibe of the Prince. Andrew Gower brings a certain vulnerability to the role that makes you pity him even when you want to shake him.
What they got right:
The Prince's absolute conviction. He really did believe he was doing God's work. His inability to listen to practical advice was his undoing, and the show nails that friction between him and Jamie/Murray.
What they simplified:
The Jacobite movement wasn't just "Scotland vs. England." It was way more complex. It was Catholics vs. Protestants, it was about the line of succession, and it involved a lot of English and Irish supporters too. The show focuses on the Highland clans because that’s where the emotional heart of the Frasers lies, but the real Charles had a much broader (and messier) coalition.
Real Actions for History Buffs and Fans
If you want to move beyond the screen and actually see where the Bonnie Prince Charlie Outlander story took place, you need to look at specific sites that haven't changed much in 280 years.
- Visit the Glenfinnan Monument: This is where Charles raised his standard. It’s hauntingly beautiful and sits at the head of Loch Shiel. If you go, you’ll see why he thought he could win; the landscape feels unconquerable.
- Walk Culloden Battlefield: The National Trust for Scotland manages this site. It is a war grave. Standing on the line where the Jacobites stood, looking across the moor at the Redcoat positions, makes you realize just how suicidal that final charge was.
- Read the Lyon in Mourning: This is a collection of journals and accounts from people who actually knew the Prince during his escape. It was compiled by Bishop Robert Forbes and is the best source for seeing the "human" side of the fugitive Prince.
- Explore the West Highland Museum: Located in Fort William, they have a "Secret Portrait" of the Prince that can only be seen when reflected in a silver cylinder. It’s a great example of the clandestine nature of Jacobite loyalty.
Understanding the Prince requires looking past the "Mark me" memes. He was a man born into a myth who tried to force that myth into reality, only to watch it crumble and take an entire culture down with it. That’s the true tragedy of the Bonnie Prince, and it’s why his character remains the most frustrating, fascinating part of the Outlander saga.
For those looking to dive deeper, start by researching the Battle of Prestonpans, where Charles actually won a stunning victory. It shows that for a brief moment, the "Bonnie" Prince actually had the world at his feet before it all slipped through his fingers on the moors of Culloden.