Green Turtle Cay isn't for everyone. If you’re looking for high-rise Marriotts, paved highways, and rows of designer boutiques, you’re basically in the wrong part of the Bahamas. But for those who get it, there is Bluff House Beach Resort & Marina. It’s been sitting on a high point of the island since the 1950s, making it the oldest resort in the Out Islands that’s still kicking.
Honestly, the place has a vibe you can't fake. It’s perched on twelve acres between the Sea of Abaco and White Sound. You’ve got the rugged, limestone cliffs on one side and the calm, boat-filled harbor on the other. It feels less like a corporate hotel and more like a family estate that just happens to have a really good bar.
Most people find their way here because they’re sailors. The marina is legendary. But even if you don't know a jib from a stern, the history of the place pulls you in. After the devastation of Hurricane Dorian in 2019, many thought the old-school Abaco charm might be gone for good. They were wrong. Bluff House didn't just rebuild; it leaned into the grit and hospitality that made it famous seventy years ago.
The Reality of Staying at Bluff House Beach Resort & Marina
Let's talk about the rooms. You aren't getting cookie-cutter suites here. They have these "Abaco Style" cottages and suites that feel airy. Most have cathedral ceilings and balconies that actually look out over the water, not just a parking lot.
The layout is spread out.
It’s private.
You’ll spend a lot of time on a golf cart. On Green Turtle Cay, that is the primary mode of transportation. You rent a cart, toss your snorkel gear in the back, and head into New Settlement or over to the Atlantic side beaches. At the resort itself, you’re basically toggling between the private beach on the Sea of Abaco and the pool.
💡 You might also like: Tiempo en East Hampton NY: What the Forecast Won't Tell You About Your Trip
The beach at Bluff House is a bit of an anomaly. Because of the "bluff" the resort is named for, you get a perspective you don't find elsewhere in the Abacos. Most of these islands are pancake-flat. Standing up at the Ballyhoo Bar and looking down at the turquoise water gives you a sense of scale that's rare in the Bahamas.
Where Everyone Ends Up: The Ballyhoo and the Jolly Roger
If you stay here, you’re going to eat at the Ballyhoo Bar & Grill. It’s the social hub. You’ll see yacht owners who just docked a million-dollar vessel sitting right next to locals and budget travelers. Everyone is drinking a Goombay Smash.
The menu is predictable in the best way possible. Think cracked conch, lobster (when in season), and fresh snapper. They do a Sunday Brunch that brings people in from all over the island. It’s loud, it’s friendly, and it’s where you hear the best stories about the "old Bahamas."
Then there’s the Jolly Roger Bar. It's right on the water in the marina. This is the spot for sunset. Seriously. If you miss the sunset at the marina at least once, you’ve fundamentally failed your vacation. The way the masts of the sailboats catch the orange light is something people try to paint but never quite get right.
Why the Marina is the Real Anchor
The Bluff House Beach Resort & Marina isn't just a name; the marina is arguably more important than the hotel rooms. It’s a full-service facility with about 40 slips. They can handle boats up to 100 feet. For cruisers coming across the Gulf Stream, this is a sanctuary.
It offers:
📖 Related: Finding Your Way: What the Lake Placid Town Map Doesn’t Tell You
- Deepwater access (crucial in the shallow Abacos)
- Power, water, and ice (the holy trinity for boaters)
- Showers and laundry that don't feel like an afterthought
- High-speed internet that actually works, which is a miracle in the Out Islands
Boaters are a picky bunch. They stay here because the dockmasters actually know what they’re doing. There is a sense of community. You’ll see boaters sharing tools, swapping fishing coordinates, or just complaining about the price of diesel together. It's authentic.
Navigating the Post-Dorian Landscape
We have to mention the hurricane. Dorian was a Category 5 monster that sat on the Abacos. It changed everything. For a while, the future of Bluff House was a giant question mark.
The rebuilding process was slow. It was painful. But the owners, the Oane family, stayed committed. They didn't just slap some paint on ruined wood. They reinforced the structures and modernized the infrastructure while keeping the "barefoot luxury" feel. When you walk around the grounds now, you see new palms and fresh shingles, but the soul of the place—that weird, intangible feeling of being totally disconnected from the "real world"—remains intact.
What Most People Get Wrong About Green Turtle Cay
People often assume that because it’s a "resort," everything is inclusive or manicured like a Disney park. It isn't. This is the Out Islands. Sometimes the power flickers. Sometimes the grocery store runs out of fresh milk because the supply boat was delayed by weather.
Bluff House is for the traveler who finds that charming rather than annoying.
If you want a 24-hour fitness center and a pillow menu, go to Nassau. If you want to wake up, jump off a dock into crystal clear water, and spend your day looking for sea turtles at Coco Bay, you come here.
👉 See also: Why Presidio La Bahia Goliad Is The Most Intense History Trip In Texas
Planning Your Logistics
Getting here requires effort. You fly into Marsh Harbour (MHH), take a taxi to the ferry dock at Treasure Cay, and then hop on the Green Turtle Ferry. You tell the ferry captain you’re going to Bluff House, and they’ll drop you right at the resort’s private dock.
- Book your golf cart early. There are only a few rental agencies on the island (like D&P or Seaside), and they sell out weeks in advance during peak season.
- Check the wind. The resort is on a bluff, so if the wind is kicking from the west, the Sea of Abaco side gets choppy.
- Pack a rash guard. The sun in the Abacos is deceptive. You’ll be snorkeling for twenty minutes and realize your back is the color of a boiled lobster.
- Bring cash. While the resort takes cards, some smaller spots in the village of New Plymouth prefer Bahamian or US dollars.
Actionable Steps for Your Trip
To get the most out of a stay at Bluff House, don't just sit by the pool. The resort is a base camp.
First, spend a morning in New Plymouth. It’s a Loyalist settlement with narrow streets and brightly colored houses that look like they belong in New England, just with more palm trees. Visit the Albert Lowe Museum to understand why this tiny scrap of land matters.
Second, charter a boat or take your own to the "swimming pigs" at No Name Cay or the stingrays at Manjack Cay. Bluff House can coordinate these trips. The reefs nearby, like those at Fiddle Cay, offer some of the best shallow-water snorkeling in the hemisphere.
Finally, keep an eye on the event calendar. If you can time your visit for the Heritage Festival or the Island Roots Heritage Festival, do it. The resort becomes a focal point for the festivities, and you’ll get a taste of Bahamian culture—Junkanoo rushes, rake-and-scrape music, and local crafts—that most tourists never see.
The reality is that Bluff House Beach Resort & Marina survives because it doesn't try to be something it's not. It’s a rugged, beautiful, slightly salty slice of Bahamian history. It’s a place where the tide matters more than the time, and the best thing you can do is order another drink and watch the boats come in.
Check the current ferry schedules before you land in Marsh Harbour, as they can shift based on the season. If you are arriving by private vessel, hail the dockmaster on VHF Channel 16 as you approach White Sound to ensure your slip is ready and the depth is clear for your draft. Bring a sturdy pair of walking shoes for the hills, but keep your flip-flops handy—you won't need much else.