It’s called selective color. You’ve definitely seen it. A little girl in a red coat walking through a grey, snowy street. A single yellow rose held by a bride in a grainy, silver-toned shot. Honestly, people have some pretty strong opinions about a black white photo with color accents. Some photographers think it’s a bit of a cliché, a relic of the early 2000s when everyone first figured out how to use the "masking" tool in Photoshop. But there is a reason it won't die. It works.
When you strip away the mess of a full-color spectrum, you’re left with shapes and light. Then, you drop in one specific hue. Suddenly, the viewer’s eye has no choice but to go exactly where you want it. It’s a psychological trick, basically.
The Science of Selective Attention
Why do we look? Humans are hardwired for contrast. Our brains are essentially giant pattern-recognition machines that get bored easily. When you look at a standard photograph, your eyes wander. They take in the sky, the grass, the person's shoes. But a black white photo with color disrupts that natural scanning process.
It creates what psychologists call "visual salience." In a world of monochrome, a splash of red or blue becomes a signal. It’s like a shout in a quiet library. Researchers have studied how we process visual hierarchies, and high contrast—especially color against a neutral background—is the fastest way to grab the human amygdala's attention. It's not just "pretty." It's biological.
Think about the movie Schindler’s List. Steven Spielberg used this exact technique. The girl in the red coat isn't just a stylistic choice; she represents the loss of innocence in a world turned grey and ash-like. It’s heavy stuff. It shows that this isn't just a filter you slap on a vacation photo. It's a storytelling device.
It’s Not Just One "Style"
There are actually a few different ways people approach this. You have the "Spot Color" method, which is the most common. This is where one specific object keeps its original color while everything else is desaturated. Then there’s "Duotone" or "Tritone" work, where the entire image is mapped to two or three specific colors, usually a dark blue or brown for the shadows and a cream for the highlights.
Then you have hand-tinting. This is the old-school grandfather of the digital black white photo with color we see today. Back in the 1800s, before Technicolor or Kodachrome were things, artists would literally take a brush and paint oil colors or watercolors directly onto a silver gelatin print. It was painstakingly slow. It looked surreal because the colors never perfectly matched reality. That "off-kilter" look is exactly what modern digital filters are trying to replicate.
📖 Related: Installing a Push Button Start Kit: What You Need to Know Before Tearing Your Dash Apart
How the Tech Has Changed the Game
Back in the day, you needed a darkroom and some chemicals. Or, later on, a very expensive copy of Adobe Photoshop and about an hour of free time to zoom in at 400% and carefully trace around a flower petal with a mouse.
Now? It’s different.
AI-driven segmentation is the new standard. If you open an app on your phone today, the software can usually distinguish between a "person," a "car," and "sky" almost instantly. It creates a depth map. This means you can create a black white photo with color in about three seconds.
But here is the catch.
Because it’s so easy, the world is flooded with bad versions of it. You’ve seen them on social media—the ones where the edges are fuzzy, or a bit of the background accidentally stayed green while the rest turned grey. It looks cheap. Real expertise in this medium comes from knowing why you are highlighting a color, not just that you can.
The Problem with "Selective Color" Overuse
There’s a reason high-end wedding photographers sometimes groan when a client asks for this. It can feel dated. If you use it on every single photo, it loses its power. It becomes a gimmick.
👉 See also: Maya How to Mirror: What Most People Get Wrong
The most effective use of a black white photo with color is when the color itself carries a symbolic weight. If you're photographing a firefighter, maybe the only thing in color is the orange glow of a flame. That makes sense. It tells a story about danger. If you just make a random mailbox red in a black and white street scene, the viewer wonders... why? What am I supposed to feel about this mailbox?
Expert Tips for Getting it Right
If you’re going to do this, don't just use a "one-tap" filter. Those usually look like garbage. You want to control the "spill."
- Pick the right subject. Busy backgrounds are great for this because the black and white conversion cleans up the "noise," leaving your colorful subject to pop.
- Watch your saturation. Sometimes, when you turn everything else grey, the remaining color looks too bright. It looks fake. Pull the saturation down just a tiny bit on your colored object so it feels like it belongs in the scene.
- Feather your edges. This is the biggest mistake people make. If the line between the color and the black and white is too sharp, it looks like a sticker pasted on a page. You need a tiny bit of "bleed" to make it look optical and natural.
- Think about the "grey" tones. Not all black and white is the same. Do you want high contrast with deep blacks? Or a soft, silvery look? The tone of the background changes how the color feels. A bright red against a dark, moody black background feels aggressive. That same red against a light, misty grey background feels romantic.
Real-World Examples and History
We have to talk about the 1940s and 50s. Advertisements used this heavily. Because color printing was incredibly expensive, magazines would often print an entire page in black and white but pay for a "second pass" of just one ink—usually red. This was a limitation of the printing press, but it created an iconic aesthetic that we now associate with "vintage" cool. Brands like Coca-Cola or various lipstick companies used this to make their products stand out on a crowded newsstand.
Fast forward to today, and you see it in high-fashion photography. Vogue or Harper’s Bazaar often feature shoots where the clothing is vibrant but the model's skin and the environment are desaturated. It's a way to keep the focus on the "product" while maintaining a "fine art" vibe.
Tools You Should Actually Use
If you're doing this on a computer, Adobe Lightroom is arguably better than Photoshop for this specific task now. The "Point Color" and "Masking" tools let you select a specific range of hues and invert the selection to desaturate everything else. It’s non-destructive, meaning you can change your mind later.
For mobile, Snapseed is still the king. Use the "Brush" tool or the "Stacking" menu to mask back in color. It gives you more manual control than those automated "Color Splash" apps that usually just mess up the hair and edges.
✨ Don't miss: Why the iPhone 7 Red iPhone 7 Special Edition Still Hits Different Today
Actionable Next Steps
If you want to master the black white photo with color look, stop looking at "filter" galleries and start looking at noir films. Watch how they use light.
Start with an image that has one dominant, clear color. A yellow taxi, a red dress, a bright blue balloon. Convert the whole thing to black and white first. Don't just desaturate it; actually use a Black and White mix tool to adjust how the different colors (like the blue sky) look as shades of grey. Then, use a mask to "paint" the color back in only on the primary subject.
Always ask yourself: "If I took the color away, would this still be a good photo?" If the answer is no, the color is just a crutch. If the answer is yes, then the color is an enhancement. That is the difference between an amateur "edit" and a professional piece of visual art.
Experiment with the "opacity" of your color. Sometimes having the subject at 50% color and the background at 0% looks much more sophisticated than a 100% color "pop." It creates a dreamier, more cohesive look that doesn't scream for attention quite as loudly.
Look at your own portfolio. Find a photo that feels "too busy." Maybe there’s a distracting sign in the background or too many competing colors. Try converting it to black and white and bringing back just the soul of the image in color. You might find that the photo you were about to delete is actually the most striking one you’ve ever taken.