Why Being an Imposter Is the Wrong Way to Describe Imposter Syndrome

Why Being an Imposter Is the Wrong Way to Describe Imposter Syndrome

You’re sitting in a meeting, and suddenly, your stomach drops. It isn’t food poisoning or a lack of coffee. It’s that nagging, cold realization that everyone in the room is smarter than you. You think they’re going to find out. Any second now, a colleague will point a finger and shout that you’ve been faking it this whole time. This experience—that specific, gut-wrenching feeling of being a fraud despite having the receipts to prove your success—is called imposter syndrome.

It’s a weird phenomenon.

Honestly, the name is a bit of a misnomer because it suggests a medical condition. It’s not. It is a psychological pattern. Psychologists Pauline Rose Clance and Suzanne Imes first identified this back in 1978. They didn’t call it a "syndrome" initially; they called it the "imposter phenomenon." They were looking at high-achieving women who, despite having advanced degrees and professional honors, remained convinced they were just lucky or had somehow tricked people into thinking they were competent. Since then, we’ve realized it hits almost everyone. Research published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine suggests up to 82% of people face these feelings at some point. That’s a massive number of people walking around feeling like they’re wearing a mask that’s about to slip.

Understanding the Different Flavors of Imposter Syndrome

Most people think imposter syndrome is just a single feeling of "I'm a fake." It’s actually more nuanced than that. Dr. Valerie Young, a leading expert on the subject, broke it down into five distinct subgroups. It’s helpful to figure out which one you fall into because the "cure" is different for each.

The first is the Perfectionist. These folks set impossibly high goals for themselves. Even if they hit 99% of their target, they obsess over the 1% they missed. To them, anything less than perfection is a total failure. Then you have the Natural Genius. If they don’t master a new skill on the first try, their brain tells them they’re a fraud. They judge their competence based on ease and speed rather than effort. It's a brutal way to live.

✨ Don't miss: Why Titanic Death of a Dream Still Haunts the History of Luxury Travel

The Soloist feels like they have to do everything alone. If they ask for help, they feel like they’re admitting they don't know what they're doing. There is also the Expert. They are never satisfied with their level of knowledge. They’re the ones constantly signing up for more certifications or degrees because they don't feel "qualified enough" to speak up in a meeting. Finally, there’s the Superhuman. They push themselves to work harder than everyone else to prove they aren’t a fake. It’s a fast track to burnout.

You might see yourself in one of these, or maybe all of them depending on the day. It’s a spectrum.

Why Do We Feel This Way?

It isn't just "low self-esteem." That’s a common misconception. You can have high self-esteem and still struggle with imposter syndrome. Often, it’s rooted in how we were raised. Some families flip-flop between over-praising and harsh criticism. This creates a confusing internal compass. If you were the "smart one" in the family, you might feel like you have to maintain that image at all costs. If you were the "average one" who worked hard, you might feel like your success is just a fluke of effort rather than actual talent.

Environment matters a lot too.

If you’re in a field where you’re a minority—whether because of your gender, race, or background—the feeling of being an imposter is magnified. It’s not just in your head; it’s a reflection of systemic biases. When the world doesn't expect you to succeed, you start wondering if you actually belong there when you do. Dr. Kevin Cokley, a professor at the University of Michigan, has done extensive research on how racial identity impacts these feelings. He found that for many Black students, imposter syndrome is often tied to the pressure of representing their entire race, which is an exhausting burden to carry.

The Problem With the Term "Syndrome"

Lately, there’s been a bit of a backlash against the term imposter syndrome. Critics argue that by calling it a syndrome, we’re pathologizing a normal human reaction to high-pressure environments. In a 2021 article for Harvard Business Review, Ruchika Tulshyan and Joni Hodaie argued that the concept directs the blame toward the individual rather than the toxic workplace cultures that create these feelings.

Think about it.

If you’re in a workplace that doesn't value your input or ignores your achievements, of course you’re going to feel like you don't belong. Labeling that as a personal psychological flaw ignores the fact that the environment might be the real problem. It’s a fair point. Sometimes, your "imposter syndrome" is actually just a very accurate intuition that you are in a room full of people who aren't supporting you.

Real-World Examples of High-Profile "Imposters"

If you feel like a fraud, you’re in good company. Maya Angelou, an absolute titan of literature, once said, "I have written eleven books, but each time I think, ‘Uh oh, they’re going to find out now. I’ve run a game on everybody, and they’re going to find me out.’"

Eleven books. Multiple awards. And she still felt like she was playing a game.

Tom Hanks has admitted to similar feelings. He’s described the feeling of waking up and thinking, "How did I get here? When are they going to discover that I am, in fact, a fraud and take everything away from me?" Even Albert Einstein reportedly referred to himself as an "involuntary swindler" shortly before his death. It seems that the more successful you are, the more likely you are to feel like you don’t deserve it. This is partly due to the Dunning-Kruger effect, where highly competent people tend to underestimate their abilities because they assume that if a task is easy for them, it must be easy for everyone else.

How to Handle These Feelings Without Losing Your Mind

The goal isn’t necessarily to make the feeling go away forever. For many people, it’s a lifelong companion. The goal is to stop it from paralyzing you.

First, talk about it. When you keep these thoughts in your head, they grow. When you say them out loud to a mentor or a trusted friend, they often sound ridiculous. Most of the time, that person will respond with, "Wait, you feel that way too? I thought it was just me." Normalizing the experience takes away its power.

Second, keep a "hype file." This sounds cheesy, but it works. Every time you get a positive email, a compliment from a client, or a successful project post-mortem, save it. Put it in a folder. When the imposter feelings start to spiral, go back and read the objective evidence of your success. Your brain is lying to you; the hype file is telling the truth.

Third, reframe "I don't know what I'm doing" to "I am learning." The expectation that we should know everything is what fuels the Expert and Natural Genius archetypes. If you accept that you are a work in progress, the pressure to be a finished masterpiece disappears.

📖 Related: January 19 2027: Why This Tuesday is More Than Just a Date on the Calendar

Actionable Steps to Reclaim Your Confidence

  • Audit your inner circle. If the people around you are constantly undermining your confidence, your imposter feelings will never fade. Find people who provide "radical candor"—they’ll tell you when you messed up, but they also acknowledge your wins.
  • Stop the "just" habit. Watch your language. Do you say, "I just did the research," or "I just managed the project"? Remove the word "just." It’s a linguistic way of shrinking your accomplishments.
  • Teach someone else. One of the best ways to realize how much you actually know is to mentor someone who is a few steps behind you. When you explain a concept to them, you’ll realize that your knowledge isn't "common sense"—it’s expertise you’ve built over time.
  • Visualize the worst-case scenario. Usually, the "they’re going to find out" fear is vague. If they "found out," what would actually happen? Would you be fired? Probably not. Would you have to ask a question? Probably. Most of the time, the "discovery" we fear is just an admission of being human.

Ultimately, imposter syndrome is often a sign that you are pushing yourself. You don’t feel like an imposter when you’re staying in your comfort zone doing things you’ve done a thousand times. You feel it when you’re growing, taking risks, and stepping into new territory. Instead of seeing it as a red flag that you’re a fraud, try seeing it as a green light that you’re challenging yourself. It’s an uncomfortable byproduct of ambition. Own the feeling, but don’t let it drive the car. You’ve earned your seat at the table. Now, stay there.