If you ask a casual fan about the definitive Batman stories, you’re going to hear the usual suspects. Year One. The Dark Knight Returns. Maybe The Killing Joke if they're feeling edgy. But there is a weird, occult-soaked three-issue arc from 1990 that basically changed the DNA of Gotham City forever, and honestly, hardly anyone outside of hardcore collectors talks about it anymore. I’m talking about Batman Dark Knight Dark City.
It’s a nightmare.
Written by Peter Milligan with art by Kieron Dwyer, this story didn't just give us a "darker" Batman; it suggested that the city itself is a sentient, malevolent engine designed to break Bruce Wayne. It’s the kind of comic that makes you want to wash your hands after reading it. It’s gritty, sure, but it’s also deeply psychedelic and ritualistic in a way that feels totally different from the flashy blockbuster vibes we get from modern DC titles.
The Riddler Like You’ve Never Seen Him
Forget the guy in the green spandex telling puns. In Batman Dark Knight Dark City, Edward Nygma is a straight-up psychopath. He isn't just trying to outsmart Batman; he’s performing a blood sacrifice.
Milligan took the Riddler—who, let’s be real, was often a bit of a joke in the late 80s—and turned him into a conduit for something ancient. The plot follows Batman as he’s led through a series of increasingly grisly "riddles." These aren't word games. They are tasks involving human blood, ritualistic desecration, and a literal throat-cutting of a baby (don't worry, Batman saves the day, but the imagery stays with you).
Why the sudden shift?
Nygma finds a diary. It’s an old, dusty thing belonging to a group of occultists from the 1700s—including, shockingly, Thomas Jefferson. They tried to summon a demon named Barbatos in a basement in colonial Gotham. It went wrong. Or maybe it went exactly right. The Riddler realizes that by recreating these "ceremonies," he can gain absolute power over the city.
✨ Don't miss: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
The pacing is frantic. One minute Batman is fighting off a literal pit bull with a bomb strapped to it, and the next, he's hallucinating about his own parents in a way that feels way more visceral than the standard "pearls hitting the pavement" flashback we've seen a thousand times. Dwyer’s art is crucial here. He uses these heavy, oppressive shadows that make Gotham feel like it’s physically closing in on the characters.
Barbartos and the Secret History of Gotham
This is where the story gets really heavy. Before Batman Dark Knight Dark City, Gotham was just a shitty city with a lot of crime. After this book, Gotham became a cursed place.
Milligan introduces the idea that the demon Barbatos was trapped beneath the city for centuries. The theory the book proposes is that the city’s inherent darkness—the corruption, the madness of the villains, the tragedy of the Waynes—was all a "feed" for this entity. It’s a massive retcon if you think about it. It implies that Bruce Wayne didn't just choose to be Batman because he was sad. He was shaped by the city to be the perfect vessel for a supernatural endgame.
Grant Morrison would eventually pick up these threads decades later during their massive Batman run and Final Crisis. If you’ve read The Return of Bruce Wayne or Dark Nights: Metal, you’ve seen Barbatos. But this 1990 arc is the ground zero for that entire mythology. Without Milligan’s weird little three-issue run in Batman #452-#454, the modern "Dark Multiverse" stuff probably wouldn't exist.
It's kinda wild how much weight these three issues carry.
Back then, fans weren't sure what to make of it. It was a huge departure from the more grounded, "urban legend" Batman that Jim Starlin and Alan Grant were writing. It felt more like a Vertigo title before Vertigo even existed. The story suggests that Gotham isn't just a setting; it's a character. And that character is a monster.
🔗 Read more: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the Atmosphere Still Holds Up
The 90s were a weird time for comics. We were moving away from the neon colors of the 80s into something more experimental. Batman Dark Knight Dark City captures that transition perfectly.
The dialogue is snappy but pretentious in the best way. Nygma talks like a man possessed, because he basically is. Batman, on the other hand, sounds exhausted. You can feel the weight of the mystery on him. When he discovers the secret chamber where the founding fathers supposedly performed their dark rites, the sense of dread is palpable.
- The Rituals: Each "test" the Riddler sets up is a mockery of Batman's skills.
- The Twist: The ending isn't a clean victory. It leaves a lingering sense of "what if?" regarding Bruce's agency.
- The Art: Kieron Dwyer's inks are thick and muddy, perfectly matching the "dark city" vibe.
I've talked to collectors who say this is the one story they won't let their kids read. It’s not just the violence. It’s the implication of the violence. It touches on themes of infant mortality, historical conspiracy, and the idea that our heroes might just be pawns for cosmic horrors.
Honestly, it’s a miracle it got past the censors at the time.
How to Read It Today and What to Look For
If you’re looking to track this down, you’ve got a few options. It was originally published in Batman issues #452, #453, and #454. You can usually find the back issues in dollar bins if you’re lucky, but DC has since collected it in a trade paperback also titled Batman: Dark Knight, Dark City.
When you read it, pay attention to the background details. Dwyer hides a lot of occult symbolism in the architecture of the buildings. Look at the way the Riddler’s costume changes as he gets deeper into the ritual. He starts off looking like his usual self, but by the end, he’s disheveled, wild-eyed, and genuinely terrifying.
💡 You might also like: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
There’s a specific scene involving a graveyard and a sequence of events that mirrors the "death" of the old Gotham. It’s heavy-handed, sure, but it works because the stakes feel so much higher than a simple bank robbery.
One thing that people get wrong about this book is thinking it's a "Riddler story." It’s not. It’s a "Gotham story." The Riddler is just the guy who happened to find the instruction manual for the city’s destruction.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you're diving into the darker side of DC, here is how to get the most out of this specific era:
- Read it alongside Morrison's run. If you jump from Dark City straight into Batman R.I.P., the connections are mind-blowing. You’ll see exactly where Morrison got the idea for the "Bat-Demon."
- Check the publication dates. Notice how this came out right after Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth. DC was clearly testing the waters to see how far they could push the "horror" element of Batman.
- Don't skip the prose. Milligan’s writing is dense. If you skim the word bubbles, you’ll miss the historical parallels he’s drawing between 18th-century occultism and modern crime.
- Look for the 2015 reprint. The colors are slightly remastered, which helps Dwyer’s art pop on modern paper stock, though some purists prefer the original newsprint for that "grimy" feel.
Batman Dark Knight Dark City remains a masterclass in how to take a well-known character and make them feel vulnerable again. It strips away the gadgets and the "prep time" memes and leaves Bruce Wayne alone in a basement, staring at a history he doesn't want to believe is true. It’s essential reading for anyone who thinks they know everything about the Caped Crusader.
Go find a copy. Read it at night. Turn the lights down. It’s the only way to experience Gotham the way Milligan intended.