If you were a kid in the late nineties or early 2000s, the DCAU (DC Animated Universe) wasn't just a Saturday morning ritual; it was the gold standard for how superheroes should actually be written. Batman Beyond took the moody, gothic DNA of the original series and injected it with cyberpunk grit, and when the film Return of the Joker dropped, it changed everything. It was dark. Brutal. Honestly, it was kind of traumatizing for a "kids" movie. Naturally, Ubisoft and Kemco decided to turn this psychological thriller into a video game. But Batman Beyond Return of the Joker PS1 isn't the sweeping, cinematic experience you might expect from such a heavy source material. Instead, we got a side-scrolling beat ‘em up that feels like it stepped out of a time machine from 1992.
It’s a bizarre artifact.
The game was released in late 2000, right as the PlayStation 2 was starting to make the original PS1 look like a collection of vibrating grey boxes. Because of that timing, the game often gets lost in the shuffle of "late-cycle licensed garbage." But is it actually garbage? That depends on how much you value style over substance.
The Bizarre Disconnect Between Film and Gameplay
Most people remember the movie for the chilling flashback where Tim Drake is broken by the Joker. It’s high-stakes drama. The game, however, greets you with chunky polygons and Terry McGinnis punching his way through endless waves of generic Jokerz gang members. There’s a weirdly charming simplicity to it, but it’s definitely a jarring shift from the film’s tone.
You’ve basically got a standard brawler here. You walk from left to right. You punch things. You kick things. Sometimes you throw a Batarang. The twist—and the thing that actually makes Batman Beyond Return of the Joker PS1 interesting—is the suit system. Unlike the show where the suit is a singular piece of high-tech godhood, the game forces you to swap between four different variations.
There’s the Standard Suit, which is your jack-of-all-trades. Then you have the High-Jump Suit, which is basically mandatory for the platforming sections that feel slightly too floaty for their own good. The Strong Suit lets you move heavy objects (the classic "push the box" mechanic), and the Defense Suit turns you into a tank.
Switching between these on the fly is the core loop. It’s not particularly deep, but it adds a layer of strategy that keeps it from being a total button-masher. You’ll find yourself hitting a wall, realizing you need the Strong Suit to break through, and swapping back. It’s clunky. It’s repetitive. Yet, for some reason, it’s strangely addictive if you’re a fan of the aesthetic.
Why the Graphics Looked "Old" Even in 2000
By the time this game hit shelves, we had already seen Metal Gear Solid and Silent Hill. We knew what the PS1 could do. Batman Beyond Return of the Joker PS1 looks... well, it looks like a Super Nintendo game that was stretched out into three dimensions. The textures are muddy. The backgrounds are often just flat, static images that don't quite line up with the 3D character models.
👉 See also: Why 4 in a row online 2 player Games Still Hook Us After 50 Years
But look at the art direction.
The developers managed to nail the color palette of the show. The neon purples, the harsh reds of the Batman logo, the oppressive darkness of Neo-Gotham—it’s all there. Even if the character models look like they’re made of Lego bricks, the vibe is correct. That’s why it stayed in people's collections. It didn't look "good," but it felt like the show.
The music is another high point. It leans heavily into that industrial, techno-rock sound that defined the Batman Beyond intro. It’s loud, it’s aggressive, and it’s honestly much better than the gameplay deserves. Most licensed games from this era had forgettable MIDI bleeps, but the sound team here clearly understood the assignment.
The Difficulty Spike Nobody Expected
Don’t let the "E for Everyone" rating fool you. This game is hard. Not "Dark Souls" hard, but "unfair 90s design" hard. The hit detection is questionable at best. You’ll swing at a Jokerz thug, miss by a pixel, and get countered into a three-hit combo that takes half your health.
- The bosses are the worst offenders.
- Bonk, Woof, and the twins have patterns that require near-perfect timing.
- The final encounter with the Joker? It's a test of patience more than skill.
You spend half the time fighting the controls. The jump physics are particularly egregious. Terry feels like he’s on the moon, and in a game where falling off a ledge means instant death, that’s a problem. Honestly, if you didn’t have the High-Jump suit, the game would be practically unplayable.
Comparing the PS1 Version to the N64 and Game Boy
It’s easy to forget this game wasn't an exclusive. It landed on the Nintendo 64 and the Game Boy Color as well. Usually, the N64 version of a multi-platform game would be the definitive one due to the hardware power, but that’s not really the case here.
The N64 version lacks the FMV (Full Motion Video) cutscenes from the movie. On the PS1, you get actual clips from the film to bridge the levels. They’re compressed and grainy, sure, but they provide a narrative glue that the N64’s static text boxes just can't match. Seeing Mark Hamill’s Joker actually laugh on your screen makes the mediocre gameplay much easier to swallow.
✨ Don't miss: Lust Academy Season 1: Why This Visual Novel Actually Works
The Game Boy Color version is a completely different beast—a pure 2D side-scroller. Ironically, some fans argue the GBC version is the most "honest" version of the game because it doesn't try to be a 3D brawler. It just knows it’s a simple action game. But for the full "Return of the Joker" experience, the PS1 remains the most cinematic, despite its flaws.
The Legacy of a "Bad" Game
Is Batman Beyond Return of the Joker PS1 a masterpiece? No. Not even close. It currently sits with some pretty dismal scores on sites like GameSpot and IGN from that era. They weren't wrong; as a piece of software, it’s buggy and short. You can beat the whole thing in under two hours if you know what you’re doing.
But there’s a cult following.
There’s something about the specific era of "middle-market" games that we just don't see anymore. Today, a Batman game is either a massive AAA blockbuster like Arkham Knight or a mobile gacha game. There’s no middle ground. Batman Beyond Return of the Joker PS1 represents a time when developers could take a massive IP and just... make a weird little brawler for the fans.
It’s a piece of Neo-Gotham history. For collectors, the game has actually held its value surprisingly well. Finding a "Black Label" copy with the manual intact is becoming harder every year. It’s not because the game is a mechanical triumph, but because it’s the only real way to inhabit Terry McGinnis's world in that specific 32-bit aesthetic.
Technical Hurdles and Emulation
If you’re trying to play this today, you’re probably going to notice the "shimmering" textures immediately. This was a common PS1 issue caused by a lack of sub-pixel precision. On a modern 4K TV, it looks like the game is having a seizure.
If you want the best experience:
🔗 Read more: OG John Wick Skin: Why Everyone Still Calls The Reaper by the Wrong Name
- Play it on an original PS1 or PS2 with a CRT television. The scanlines hide the jagged edges and make those FMV cutscenes look much more natural.
- If you’re emulating, use a "PGXP" tweak. This fixes the wobbling polygons and makes the world feel solid. It’s a game-changer.
- Don't skip the manual. It contains some cool art of the different suits that you don't really get to see clearly in the low-res game menus.
A Missed Opportunity or a Hidden Gem?
There's a persistent rumor that the game was rushed to meet the movie’s release window. Looking at the level design, it’s hard to argue otherwise. The environments are incredibly repetitive. You’ll walk through the same laboratory corridor about fifty times. The enemies are mostly palette swaps.
However, there is a genuine joy in seeing the Return of the Joker story beats play out in a interactive format. When you finally reach the end and face off against the "reborn" Joker, the game taps into that same sense of dread the movie perfected. It’s a flawed tribute to one of the best animated films ever made.
It’s basically the definition of a "5 out of 10" game that somehow feels like an 8 out of 10 if you're wearing nostalgia goggles. You can see the bones of a much better game underneath the surface. If they had another six months to polish the combat and maybe add some voice acting during the levels, we might be talking about this as a classic alongside Spider-Man (2000).
Instead, it’s a curiosity. A relic.
Actionable Steps for Retrogamers
If you’re planning on hunting down a copy or firing up an ISO, keep these things in mind. First, check your expectations. This is a game from an era where "3D" was still a struggle for many developers. It’s stiff.
Second, master the Standard Suit’s glide. It’s the most useful tool in your arsenal and will save you from 90% of the cheap deaths in the platforming sections. Don’t over-rely on the Strong Suit; it makes you a massive target and moves way too slowly for the later levels.
Finally, look for the hidden power-ups. The game doesn't explicitly tell you where they are, but most levels have breakable walls or hidden alcoves that contain health upgrades. You’re going to need them for the final act.
Batman Beyond Return of the Joker PS1 isn't going to win any awards for innovation, but it’s a fascinating look at how we used to handle superhero adaptations. It’s messy, it’s difficult, and it’s unapologetically "Batman Beyond." For some of us, that’s more than enough.
Check the disc for scratches before buying—the PS1 laser is notorious for struggling with the dual-layer nature of high-FMV games, and you don't want the Joker's final monologue to freeze halfway through.